I know Music is Haraam but...

[Salah ad-din]

if the nasheed has no instruments or only had the duff in it den its ok.. but anythin other than the duff its haram..

Why is the duff permissible and not other instruements?

 

[Salah ad-din]

Plus, some instruments were created posthumous, so who made them illegal in Islam? I don't understand this, please help me to understand this.

 

[IbnAbdulHakim]

if the nasheed has no instruments or only had the duff in it den its ok.. but anythin other than the duff its haram..

Agreed !

 

[IbnAbdulHakim]

salah ha-din i was shown the proof by dr.zakir naik but if i ever find it again i'l post it asap inshaAllah

 

[Salah ad-din]

Proof with Qur'an and/or Ahadith refferences brother?

 

[IbnAbdulHakim]

Proof with Qur'an and/or Ahadith refferences brother?

yes bro , dr.zakir naik ALWAYS provides proof seeing as his "viewed" as a salaf he doesnt rely on just an imams opinion he shows his own proof. This is the main reason i have agreed with his view, the proof he gave was good enough for me.

 

[Salah ad-din]

Cool. I like him already!
There's nothing better than direct proof. This way we are not left to assumptions. I'll wait for you to post his words.

 

[IbnAbdulHakim]

Cool. I like him already!
There's nothing better than direct proof. This way we are not left to assumptions. I'll wait for you to post his words.

its in the midst of one of these videos:

http://www.irf.net/irf/videogallery/index.htm


lol i cant go through them all :X, forgive me, if i ever run into it i'll let you know inshaAllah

 

[Salah ad-din]

Do you know what it is titled? I can't find it. I see that it has one of my favorite listed: Dr. Ahmed Deedat. May Allah ta'ala grant him Paradise.

 

[IbnAbdulHakim]

ye Ahmed Deedat is zakir naiks teacher, i think Deedat was the best though

may Allah grant him jannah Ameen!


bro im sry i dont kno which one it was :?, its in the question and answer section of one of them..

 

[Salah ad-din]

I love Deedat. I have so many of his lectures. I'll find it inshaAllah.

 

[MusLiM 4 LiFe]

Deedat, mashallah he was wikid! may allah grant him paradise..

yup dt woz dr zakir naik teacher.. dr zakir naik, iz amazin! hes so cleva mashallah

 

[Hijrah]

Music is def. Haraam, read it here: http://thetruewayoflife.blogspot.com/2006/07/incompatibility-of-music-and-faith.html

I'm asking about Nasheeds there has to be something done to make it usic which would make it haraam, and what would that be?

 

[Muhammad]

Please see:

http://www.islamicboard.com/islamic-jurisprudence/20238-music-singing-light-quran-sunnah.html

and for other threads about the issue: http://www.islamicboard.com/405605-post2.html

:threadclo