Is Harry Potter frowned upon?

[Wyatt]

To someone who obviously doesn't believe in the magic portrayed in Harry Potter, is reading it still frowned upon in Islam?

 

[Muezzin]

It's frowned upon by certain Muslims, yes. But those certain Muslims frown upon many things.

 

[سلثتحعرين!]

I love harry potter, ignore the magic side of it, its abot belief, friendship, corruption of government, war, death, loss, new life, and sacrifice, and so much more. I love the harry potter books because It shows that just because someones important doesnt mean they are right and good people.

And the fact he never strays from the path or gives up. And he always does what is right, NOT what is easy.

 

[Hamayun]

Nothing wrong with reading a fictional story

 

[KittyKat]

That is true isn't it? Harry always does stick to the straight path no matter how hard or the difficulties. Especially in the last book. Especially.

 

[doorster]

To someone who obviously doesn't believe in the magic portrayed in Harry Potter, is reading it still frowned upon in Islam?

short answer: yes! "And when they hear al-Laghw (useless or dirty or false or evil or vain talk etc.), they withdraw from it and say: 'To us our deeds, and to you your deeds".

Longer answer:

‘Harry Potter’ books and movies are all about magic and mythology, and that is why reading or watching them is to be avoided. There is almost a consensus among Muslim scholars that learning magic is haram. For sure, there are many useful books and movies to read and watch other than ‘Harry Potter’. The issue becomes more dangerous when parents allow their children to watch or read such stories as it may affect their creed in their earliest years.

Responding to the question, Sheikh Muhammad Al-Mukhtar Al-Shinqiti, Director of the Islamic Center of South Plains, Lubbock, Texas, states the following:

"Traditionally, there is almost consensus among Muslim scholars that learning magic is haram. They base their argument on the verse mentioning people who learn magic: “And they learn what harms them, not what profits them. And they knew that the buyers of (magic) would have no share in the happiness of the Hereafter. And vile was the price for which they did sell their souls, if they but knew.” (Al-Baqarah: 102)

According to the trustworthy people who read the works of “Harry Potter” it is all about magic and mythology. Therefore, I would not advise young people to read it or parents to give it to their children.

The attractive way in which these works are done is very dangerous and might negatively affect the basic concept of `aqeedah or Islamic creed and values of our youth. People of knowledge recognize the impact such artistic works might have on the mind and soul. The late well-known Muslim poet, Muhammad Iqbal, is quoted to have said: “Aridity of logic cannot overwhelm the beauty of poetry.”

Therefore, a Muslim is advised to stay away from these attractive but poisonous works."

You can also read:

Magic Shows to Entertain Children

How to Instill Islamic Manners in Children

Habituating Children to Reciting the Qur'an

Protecting Our Children from the Evils of Media

Necessary Tips for Raising Children Islamically

Films and Drama in the Islamic Perspective

​

Allah Almighty knows best.​

for even loooooooonnger and confusing answers: Click >> here

 

[UmmahFollower09]

I personally think there's nothing wrong with reading Harr Potter as long as you don't believe in the magic part.

The book exemplifies many things that are also exemplified in Islam like Hard work, determination and patience.

Its a really good book to read and the people who say that the book isn't are going a bit far .

 

[doorster]

Harry Potter is seen as dangerous for religious people (Jews,Christians and Muslims) because this book contains much occultist stuff and magical-pagan influences. You can see that there is no GOD in this book but magic,wizards, and often teenagers get interested in this things too.

why o why is it that I see more good sense in Christians, Buddhists and agnostic members than Muslim members?

 

[Hamayun]

Like the Brother said. As long as you don't believe Harry Potter Magic to be true there is nothing wrong.

Muslim Scholars read the Ramayana, Bhagwat Gita etc so Harry Potter is pretty harmless in comparison.

 

[doorster]

Like the Brother said. As long as you don't believe Harry Potter Magic to be true there is nothing wrong.

Muslim Scholars read the Ramayana, Bhagwat Gita etc so Harry Potter is pretty harmless in comparison.

which Muslim scholars? and for what purpose?

the only ones I knew who did that was either to "prove legitimacy of Islam" (as if Qura'an ain't enough) or to use it as a weapon to bash the kuffar in dumb debating matches

 

[Hamayun]

which Muslim scholars? and for what purpose?

the only ones I knew who did that was either to "prove legitimacy of Islam" (as if Qura'an ain't enough) or to use it as a weapon to bash the kuffar in dumb debating matches

They read it to gain understanding of the other religions so that it can help them draw comparisons.

Reading a fictional story and treating it as fiction is completely harmless.

Reading a story and believing in it can be harmful.

I have watched the Harry Potter movie myself and I can assure you it is completely harmless unless you are 3 years of age or are suffering from a mental illness.

Peace

 

[سلثتحعرين!]

i believe no story should be taken to heart unless its based upon fact. The book is meant to be for entertainment and educational and some sorta warning to kids that not everyone is meant means well to you

 

[doorster]

They read it to gain understanding of the other religions so that it can help them draw comparisons.

Reading a fictional story and treating it as fiction is completely harmless.

Reading a story and believing in it can be harmful.

I have watched the Harry Potter movie myself and I can assure you it is completely harmless unless you are 3 years of age or are suffering from a mental illness.

Peace

as Br. Woodrow might say: "less is more"; and since I've said enough in this thread already, I shall leave thee with some words from The Book of The(One)God:

"And when they hear al-Laghw (useless, dirty, false, evil vain talk etc..),
they withdraw from it and say:
'To us our deeds, and to you your deeds".

 

[Keltoi]

I believe it to be more of a personal decision based on one's confidence in allowing a child to watch Harry Potter as a harmless diversion. I personally am not too troubled by it, but there are others who are. If a parent doesn't believe their child is intellectually developed enough to understand the ludicrous nature of the story then they probably shouldn't allow their child to get caught up in it. On the other hand, if the child understands it is simply a work of fiction and a pointless diversion from everyday life...why not. There are worse things out there than Harry Potter when it comes to children.

 

[Hamayun]

"And when they hear al-Laghw (useless, dirty, false, evil vain talk etc..),
they withdraw from it and say:
'To us our deeds, and to you your deeds".

That was not in reference to a fairy tale my brother. That was in reference to the false religions people actually believe and follow.

Also there is no filthy, dirty talk in Harry Potter???

 

[IslamicRevival]

As long as it isnt lke The Simpsons and Southpark which shows kids disrespecting their parents and other lewd comments I dont see a problem with Harry Potter.

 

[doorster]

That was not in reference to a fairy tale my brother. That was in reference to the false religions people actually believe and follow other religions.

funny that! for I know ultra Saudis and their followers who used it to outlaw all types of Music using "useless talk" as their proof, first time ever I see it being used to describe other religions

I am hoping this will really be my last post in this thread:-[

edit: you have gone and changed your post, naughty!

you win (I surrender)!!!

 

[Hamayun]

funny that! for I know ultra Saudis and their followers who used it to outlaw all types of Music using "useless talk" as their proof, first time ever I see it being used to describe other religions

I am hoping this will really be my last post in this thread:-[

If we are talking about banning "useless talk" then half the threads on this forum need to be deleted. Bro you seem to be taking it too literally.

You really need to relax a bit. Are you telling me you have never watched any movies? If you have then you better repent for the "usless talk" you indulged in.

 

[Fishman]

As long as it isnt lke The Simpsons and Southpark which shows kids disrespecting their parents and other lewd comments I dont see a problem with Harry Potter.

Southpark is pretty bad. The people who make it try to be clever, but it is all really about shock and controversy.

Plus, I notice that nobody has actually tried to post a real fatwa about this either. Usually we get one in the first few posts. Unfortunately finding real fatwas is hard on the internet...

 

[doorster]

Southpark is pretty bad. The people who make it try to be clever, but it is all really about shock and controversy.

Plus, I notice that nobody has actually tried to post a real fatwa about this either. Usually we get one in the first few posts. Unfortunately finding real fatwas is hard on the internet...

wa alaikum Salam

in the link I posted, in my first post, there is one posted by Sr. Faiza as last post of one of many many many many many many harry potter threads



Watching & Reading “Harry Potter”: Permissible? - IslamonLine.net ...

‘Harry Potter’ books and movies are all about magic and mythology, and that is why reading or watching them is to be avoided. There is almost a consensus among Muslim scholars that learning magic is haram. For sure, there are many useful books and movies to read and watch other than ‘Harry Potter’. The issue becomes more dangerous when parents allow their children to watch or read such stories as it may affect their creed in their earliest years.


Harry Potter: Fun to Some, Dangerous Sorcery to Others ...

With fascinating characters, numerous plot twists, and an underlying theme of good versus evil, the Harry Potter books have enticed a young video and ...


Harry Potter Spreads Christianity - IslamOnline.net - News

"There's plenty in the Harry Potter books to make young people think about the choices they make in their everyday lives and their place in the world," said Diocese of Oxford Bishop John Pritchard