Is the Taliban/Islamic Leadership in general against modern day technology and scient

Salaam,

Sorry I cannot hear him because may laptop is diseased. I may have to watch it on my PS3.

As for Anjem Choudary, I do agree with him on many issues but I wish him and his followers were not too intimidating and avoid being too judgemental.
 
From what i know , they are not, not at all actually. They are quite in favour of hospitals , schools, universities, science & tech and etc. One must know though that the taliban movement has taken a lot of time, effort and re-adjusments to even have come so far at this. And those adjustments are still going on, for the better InshAllah, as more and more learned and educated people are joining them ,their tolerance has been increasing and they have been firm in condemning terrorism any where in the world.
 
I have read that the Taliban banned or outlawed tv or television and computers is this true I just want the context as to why this was done because my understanding is that Muslims have invented things therefor Islam is not saying we must live in the 7th centruy is this correct or right I also respect and admire Anjem Choudary is the context that Afghanistan is tribal and made up of tribes and feared western influence with the use of technology ?

Taliban slowly adopting modern technology Written by Scott Taylor Sunday, 24 June 2007 19:00 0diggsdigg

LAST TUESDAY, the Taliban made public a videotape of what was reportedly a graduation ceremony for a new class of suicide bombers. The footage showed a couple of dozen masked "graduates" wearing black turbans and waving little white flags.
Addressing the graduating class of '07 was Mansoor Dadullah, the brother of recently slain Taliban military commander Mullah Dadullah. Brandishing a Kalashnikov assault rifle, Principal Mansoor urged the would-be suicide bombers to spread terror outside of Afghanistan and to target western countries, including Canada.
It was last year at about this same time that the Taliban issued a similar statement claiming they had trained some 300 suicide bombers who were prepared to wreak havoc on the foreign coalition troops occupying Afghanistan. What made this year's annual graduation ceremony more newsworthy was that the Taliban seemed to have discovered the magical magnetic power of video to the western media. Not to be confused with Osama bin Laden's al-Qaida network, the Taliban is a religious movement that preaches an extreme version of Islam. Until now, the senior Taliban mullahs have shunned modern inventions and technology, believing such progress to be inspired by evil. According to Kathy Gannon, the author of the bestseller I is for Islam, at the time of the U.S. intervention in Afghanistan in 2001, the Taliban possessed only one computer in Kandahar. Apparently it sat unopened in its packaging in the office of Taliban founder Mullah Omar because he was afraid to open it. In another anecdote related by a diplomat who met with Taliban officials in Kabul, the mullahs were afraid to sit down to dinner. They thought that the tables and chairs were western-inspired comforts and therefore to be avoided.
It seems that someone in the Taliban organization, perhaps with the assistance of their worldlier al-Qaida allies, has twigged to the importance of television images in spreading fear via the western media. It doesn't have to be a logical threat; it just has to look menacing, and mentioning countries by name as specific targets guarantees coverage. I mean, let's get real for a minute - a graduation ceremony from suicide bomber school? What sort of courses do they teach and to whom do they submit their diplomas? Do they start off using small amounts of explosives and just blow off a limb or write a detailed thesis on the merits of electric detonators versus toggle igniters?
Another message conveyed by Principal Mansoor in his graduation address was that some of these "pupils" were in fact foreign students who had come from western countries (like Canada) to take this training in Afghanistan. If this statement is true, then we can all breath a sigh of relief knowing the Taliban is attracting morons into their ranks. If indeed an Islamic extremist was residing in a western country plotting mischief, travelling to the Kandahar region would certainly red-flag them to every intelligence agency involved in the war against terrorism.
What made the copycat homegrown terror attacks in London and Madrid successful was that the perpetrators were already in location. It was Public Safety Minister Stockwell Day who quickly pointed out the obvious fact that the graduates of the Kandahar suicide bomber school would still have to negotiate the elaborate security measures already in place before they could ever carry out an attack on Canadian soil.
Such international travel requires visas and passports and the battery of X-ray machines and security checks at a multitude of airports before they could ever get to Canada.
However, if Canadians were left with the impression that dozens of masked suicide bombers are heading our way in droves, they can be forgiven. That was the Taliban's intention, and our media obligingly helped them achieve their goal.


http://www.espritdecorps.ca/index.p...ern-technology&catid=40:afghanistan&Itemid=83

Overview

The Taliban initially enjoyed goodwill from Afghans weary of the warlords' corruption, brutality, and incessant fighting.[108] However, this popularity was not universal, particularly among non-Pashtuns.
The Taliban's extremely strict and anti-modern ideology has been described as an "innovative form of sharia combining Pashtun tribal codes,"[109] or Pashtunwali, with radical Deobandi interpretations of Islam favored by JUI and its splinter groups. Also contributing to the mix was the jihadism and pan-Islamism of Osama bin Laden.[110] Their ideology was a departure from the Islamism of the anti-Soviet mujahideen rulers they replaced who tended to be mystical Sufis, traditionalists, or radical Islamicists inspired by the Muslim Brotherhood (Ikhwan).[111]
Under the Taliban regime, Sharia law was interpreted to forbid a wide variety of previously lawful activities in Afghanistan. One Taliban list of prohibitions included: pork, pig, pig oil, anything made from human hair, satellite dishes, cinematography, and equipment that produces the joy of music, pool tables, chess, masks, alcohol, tapes, computers, VCRs, television, anything that propagates sex and is full of music, wine, lobster, nail polish, firecrackers, statues, sewing catalogs, pictures, Christmas cards.[112] They also got rid of employment, education, and sports for all women, dancing, clapping during sports events, kite flying, and characterizations of living things, no matter if they were drawings, paintings, photographs, stuffed animals, or dolls. Men had to have a fist size beard at the bottom of their chin. Conversely, they had to wear their head hair short. Men had to wear a head covering.[113]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taliban

Word for Word/www.taliban.com; Allah Is Good. Technology Is Bad. Visit Our Web Site.

By JOE SHARKEY
Published: October 25, 1998





THE Taliban hard-liners who rule most of Afghanistan are arguably the world's most vociferous enemies of modern technology. When they aren't busy enforcing the rules that prohibit females from leaving their homes unveiled or unaccompanied by a close male relative, the Taliban religious police roam neighborhoods searching for radios, TV's, VCR's, phonographs, satellite dishes or computers, which are promptly destroyed while the owners are arrested.
What a surprise, then, to go on line, type in ''www.taliban.com'' and witness what spills forth: Taliban Online, a profusion of graphics and text (in awkward English) employing the most modern communications tool -- the Internet -- to extol the virtues and triumphs of the least modern of regimes. Here are excerpts from the site, which appears to originate in Pakistan and is evidently designed for external use only. JOE SHARKEY
Among Taliban Online features are news summaries from the pages of the unofficial Taliban weekly newspaper, Dharb-i-Mumin, which chronicles efforts to enforce sharia, or Islamic law, in Afghanistan. Some recent items:
Drive of Kandahar Police Against Antisocial Elements: The Kandahar police, in a drive against antisocial elements yesterday, rounded up different criminals from around the city. They arrested a man and seized . . . 240 song cassettes and packs of playing cards from his possessions. All the things were then set on fire while the culprit was handed over to the police. Oct. 4
Televisions Seized and Smashed in Kabul: [The religious police] have started their country-wide campaign of destroying televisions, VCR's, satellite dishes, etc. . . . On Tuesday, here in Kabul, hundreds of television sets and other instruments of immoral pastimes were seized from markets and work places and then destroyed. These means of corruption were, in some places, even thrown out of the windows of high buildings to smash on the streets below. A source revealed that the campaign will be carried on with the same fervor and zeal till the complete destruction of these instruments of moral depravity. Aug. 9
Kabul: 16 Punished for Trimming Beard: [The religious police] arrested 16 people in raids on different parts of the city, on the charge of having their beard trimmed to less than the required length. Two taxi drivers were also arrested for taking unattended, unveiled women as passengers. Aug. 2

http://www.nytimes.com/1998/10/25/w...hnology-is-bad-visit-our-web-site.html?src=pm

Note: During the reign of the Taliban, Afghan people were expressly forbidden from watching television or listening to the radio. It was (and is) seen by Salafi Islamic people as Satanic and un-Islamic.

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20110507112820AAE0162
 
Last edited:
I don't think they are against technology, modern day technology, or science in general. I believe they are against (in their way/understanding) the corruptions that use technology as medium and propagate quickly and easly.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone else have any opinions ?


Salaam

Yes , If I may then please allow me to :)

I think you should seperate between Islam and the Muslim Leaders, Whether the Taliban or any other Islamic Organization supports scientific research or not , then that should not be your reference to Islam and its teachings.
In
In Islam a Muslim is highly encouraged to seek Knowledge and Science is a significant branch of Knowledge (My Favorite I love science!) and also Technology(I don't like very much but that irrelevant to your question)
Anyway,Islam is one of the most religions that encouraged it's followers to follow up with the latest types of Knowledge( what ever it may be) but with regards to Islamic Boundaries For example I don't think The cell embryo planting thing that came out in 2009 is very Islamic if not Islamic at all. But anything else that is not against the essential teaching of Islam I don't think that there is any problem with that.

This is of my short knowledge ..And God knows best
I hope it helps

Salaam
 
Does anyone think they had good reasons to ban tv since tv has many unIslamic stuff on tv ?


Salaam

They banned tv? Reminds me of a story my mother narrated to me about her friend, she married this brother and he is "very" religous to the extent that he totally banned her from watching anything on tv anything at all .. The marriage ended with a divorce I am not sure if that was a reason.


If they banned tv then that is not something that Islam really calls for at least for Tv you will be accounted as an indiviual just as there are bad things on T.V there are also good things I think one should be using it in a positive way and always acknowledge Allah's presence and that God is watching over every thing.

Salaam
 
I don't know about Taliban, but "taliban" is not equal to "Islamic leaderships in general".
And islamic leaderships, if they are based on Qur'an and sunnah, certainly is not against modern day technology and science (In fact, it is the opposite: there are Qur'an verses and ahadith that say knowledge is much better than ignorance and people with knowledge are preferrable than ignoramus and that it is fardh ain to seek knowledge).
Also, when islamic leaderships and the society were based on qur'an and sunnah, technology and science flourished like never before, eg. Baghdad between 9th and 12th century before the mongol invasion. Sure, their science is
now ancient, but at that time, the science and technological inventions that flourished in Baghdad was so advanced and can be compared to anything produced by today's cambridge/mass., silicon valley and most advanced theoretical physics coming out from Princeton or CERN, combined.

Contrast this to other any other societies who needed to divorce from their religions to advance scientifically, example: christian europe during the dark ages who were so backward, and was only able to advance
during renaissance period when they de-coupled christianity from every day life.


 
Last edited:
Is the Taliban/Islamic Leadership in general against modern day technology and scientific progress ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p0bFN7Plt2M


Well my first question to you is have you got proof Taliban exist?

I think America has just put a name for these guys and shown them evil yet we only hear this on mainstream TV.

Taliban are people defending their country because they know what's going in their country stuff like this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyDcYDLJycg
 
Is anyone here a expert on Afghanistan and Technology I know Afghanistan has many Tribes and has been attacked many times by the British the Soviets and the Americans is this correct speaking for myself I don't know much about the Taliban but would like to know why they banned tv radios or computers I do think Technology can be bad but I think Technology can be good if not for Computers I would know nothing about Islam ?
 
Last edited:
One reason for the ban ( if it is there) could be that all this technology, computers and etc can be very easily used to track them down and since they have invaders in their country who use very sensitive high tech stuff and can utilize that information to a great benefit against the local people of afghanistan, it makes it naive Not to ban them. I see no other reason for the ban, and i'm not even sure if there is a ban because they (taliban) have their news agency, media and websites, who said it was all banned?
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top