Milk and fish

SJ2000 said:
Is it true that milk and fish should not be eaten together?
Click to expand...

:sl:
As kids we were told the same thing and after doing some research on it I found it to be true.. here's a short list of foods that shouldn't be combined according to the principles ayurveda:

INCOMPATIBLE FOOD COMBINATIONS

Milk Is Incompatible With:

Bananas
Fish
Meat
Melons
Curd
Sour Fruits
Kitchari
Bread containing yeast
Cherries

Melons Are Incompatible With:
Grains
Starch
Fried foods
Cheese

Starches Are Incompatible With:
Eggs
Milk
Bananas
Dates

Honey Is Incompatible With:
Ghee (in equal proportions)
Heating or cooking with.

Radishes Are Incompatible With:
Milk
Bananas
Raisins

Nightshades, (Potato, Tomato, Brinjal, Chilies) Are Incompatible With:
Yogurt
Milk
Melon
Cucumber

Yogurt Is Incompatible With:
Milk
Sour Fruits
Melons
Hot drinks
Meat
Fish
Mangoes
Starch

Eggs Are Incompatible With:
Milk
Meat
Yogurt
Melons
Cheese
Fish
Bananas

Mangos Are Incompatible With:
Yogurt
Cheese
Cucumbers

Corn Is Incompatible With:
Dates
Raisins
Bananas

Lemon Is Incompatible With:
Yogurt
Milk
Cucumbers
Tomatoes

Source:http://www.niam.com/corp-web/foodcomb.html
 
Whoever learned arabic grammer out there would know that there is a whole 2 or three lessons over the gramattical rules in the sentence "laa ta'kul assamaka wa tashrab allaban."

dont eat fish and drink the milk.

looooool. I asked my teacher if it was true, that we shouldnt eat milk and fish together and she said yessss. lol.
 
Nawal89 said:
Whoever learned arabic grammer out there would know that there is a whole 2 or three lessons over the gramattical rules in the sentence "laa ta'kul assamaka wa tashrab allaban."

dont eat fish and drink the milk.

Yep, i know what you mean
Wassalam
Click to expand...
 
mizan_aliashraf said:
Salam
Milk and Fish? Together? No way, yuk!
Wassalam
Click to expand...
I agree. Who the heck eats milk and fish together anyway?

Also, I might be mistaken, but I think it's the part of the Jewish belief that milk and fish should not be taken together.

Just an observation. All these religious dietary requirements do serve a practical purpose, whatever religion a person is. That's pretty cool. :brother:
 
ermmm...sumtimes i c ppl cukin meat wid a lil bit o milk in der...wat bout dat :?

:w:
 
Thanks everyone for your help! I was just asking because I heard somewhere that the Prophet SAW recommended that some foods not be mixed, such as milk and fish.

Oh and Halima, are you joking?! I think its chocolate that cats can't eat!
 
Thanks for the info Muslimah_sis, i have always heard of certain foods being incompatible with other but wasnt too sure if it was true.

Well people could possible have fish and have tea aftrwards, I wonder if thart is same? but apprently that skin condition can occur (virloo)
 
Yah i was always tld milk and fish should not be eaten to toghether
 
Shining Star said:
Thanks everyone for your help! I was just asking because I heard somewhere that the Prophet SAW recommended that some foods not be mixed, such as milk and fish.

Oh and Halima, are you joking?! I think its chocolate that cats can't eat!
Click to expand...


haha No, i'm not joking. I would always see in the cartoons cats in the alley drinking milk and chasing after fish up til now that is what I have always thought that is what they eat. Until one day I asked this one lady that gave her cats to me and she specially said food like that can really make them sick. So its my best bet that they just eat alot of protein even when they would go hunting.
 
seriously im confused by this.

The above says that tomato and cucumber should not be eaten totgether...so i guess we cant have salad no more :?

also have you ever eaten white fish which has been cooked in milk? its really nice. a lot of old british people enjoy cooking fish this way.

are there medical reasons for it? or is it just superstition?

:w:

Rabi'ya:rose
 
Is it true that milk and fish should not be eaten together?
Click to expand...

It's commonly accepted in the asian community that milk and fish can't be eaten together. They believe it can result in adverse skin effects, like spots, but I can't confirm this.

And, by the way, it's not "disgusting" (as someone put it) to have, for example, fried fish followed by rice pudding (as dessert)!

:w:

A.
 
aakhirah said:
It's commonly accepted in the asian community that milk and fish can't be eaten together. They believe it can result in adverse skin effects, like spots, but I can't confirm this.

And, by the way, it's not "disgusting" (as someone put it) to have, for example, fried fish followed by rice pudding (as dessert)!

:w:

A.
Click to expand...


Fried Fish? do you know how much fat it has in it.
And the Rice Pudding is eaten after the fish NOT WITH IT!!!:rant: :rant: :rant:
Jazakillah
Wassalam
 
Rabi'ya said:
what if it was friend in milk - not in oil?

:w:

Rabi'ya:rose:
Click to expand...


can you fry in milk? new to me, and i can cook! Who knows, i might go home and try it, but if my place goes up in flames i know where to come for the insurance lol
Wassalam
 
mizan_aliashraf said:
And the Rice Pudding is eaten after the fish NOT WITH IT...
Click to expand...

But that's the problem: according to the 'saying' you're supposed to wait until the counterpart has been digested before you can have the other! Therefore, having rice pudding immediately after the fish could also be detrimental to health (and don't quote me on this one; I'm just going with the asian flow!).

:w:

A.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top