Palestine

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hope1995
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 10
  • Views Views 3K
H

Hope1995

Senior Member
Messages
90
Reaction score
0
Gender
Male
Religion
Other
I would like to know is there proof the Hebrews weren’t indigenous to Palestine?
 
Because I would like to understand from an Islamic point of view and a historical point of view.
 
It doesn't matter if they are, Palestinians have as much of a right to that land if not more. Not all Jews were exiled from that land, most Palestinians are descendants of Jews who have lived there since the Romans. Many of them converted to Christianity and Islam. Yes, Arabs came and mixed with them, but only a small percentage.

The Jews who were expelled from that land brought the expulsion upon themselves. They went against Prophet Isa (Alayhi AsSalam) and committed terrorism against the Romans and even caused harm to their own people with their attacks. For the most part, Jews were allowed to live in peace and practice their religion under Islamic rule.
 
Avis said:
It doesn't matter if they are, Palestinians have as much of a right to that land if not more. Not all Jews were exiled from that land, most Palestinians are descendants of Jews who have lived there since the Romans. Many of them converted to Christianity and Islam. Yes, Arabs came and mixed with them, but only a small percentage.

The Jews who were expelled from that land brought the expulsion upon themselves. They went against Prophet Isa (Alayhi AsSalam) and committed terrorism against the Romans and even caused harm to their own people with their attacks. For the most part, Jews were allowed to live in peace and practice their religion under Islamic rule.
Click to expand...
Than why Palestinians are not counted in the population of people with Jewish ancestors if they are Israelites? Does it have to do with that rule in Judaism if your mom is an Israelite(non-stop chain of Jewish moms), you are an Israelite but if it’s flipped, you’re not one and you are cursed by God?
 
May I ask why we are having this forum? It does not seem to benefit anyone but rather causes strife amongst each other. Islam does not hate jews or any other race. This issue is a political issue and will only offend others.
 
Studentofdeed said:
May I ask why we are having this forum? It does not seem to benefit anyone but rather causes strife amongst each other. Islam does not hate jews or any other race. This issue is a political issue and will only offend others.
Click to expand...
I ask because I’m just trying to understand this world and see what Islam says about it. It’s meant to be a brief discussion anyways and not to be spoken for long and can be brought up on occasion. It shouldn’t be overdone.
 
I cannot say because I fear I will offend others. But I will say it is political issue and it not a clear black and white issue. Its a gray issue. Islam talks about justice and equality for all races and fair treatment. Muslims are supposed to not harm innocents. This law gets transgressed over and over again. Therefore this has nothing to do islam because no one there applies. Its nothing more but a strife of land. Muslims and nonmuslims are involved.
 
Studentofdeed said:
I cannot say because I fear I will offend others. But I will say it is political issue and it not a clear black and white issue. Its a gray issue. Islam talks about justice and equality for all races and fair treatment. Muslims are supposed to not harm innocents. This law gets transgressed over and over again. Therefore this has nothing to do islam because no one there applies. Its nothing more but a strife of land. Muslims and nonmuslims are involved.
Click to expand...
It’s that some Muslims do say it has to do with Islam, like Islamqa and it does confuse me. Thank you for expressing what you think. Let’s stop this discussion so we don’t offend anyone else. No one should add to this discussion. Consider it closed.
 
Hope1995 said:
I ask because I’m just trying to understand this world and see what Islam says about it. It’s meant to be a brief discussion anyways and not to be spoken for long and can be brought up on occasion. It shouldn’t be overdone.
Click to expand...

Here is more reading about Jerusalem and it's importance in Islam: https://islamqa.info/en/answers/772...-muslims-and-do-the-jews-have-any-right-to-it

[TABLE="class: grid, width: 100%, align: center"]
[TR][TD]The importance of al-Quds for the Muslims – and do the Jews have any right to it? - Islam Question & Answer
As a muslim, I am always told that the city of Jerusalem is important to us. But why? I am aware that Prophet Yaqoob built the Asqa Mosque in it and that P ......[/TD][/TR][/TABLE]
 
Avis said:
Here is more reading about Jerusalem and it's importance in Islam: https://islamqa.info/en/answers/772...-muslims-and-do-the-jews-have-any-right-to-it

[TABLE="class: grid, width: 100%, align: center"]
[TR]
[TD]The importance of al-Quds for the Muslims – and do the Jews have any right to it? - Islam Question & Answer
As a muslim, I am always told that the city of Jerusalem is important to us. But why? I am aware that Prophet Yaqoob built the Asqa Mosque in it and that P ......[/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]
Click to expand...
Thank you for that.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top