Prophets, Imitation and Sin

  • Thread starter Thread starter wth1257
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 3
  • Views Views 2K
W

wth1257

IB Veteran
Messages
604
Reaction score
104
So I am a bit confused. I have been told that in Islam Prophet’s cannot sin. But didn’t Adam sin, and hence the expulsion? Moreover doesn’t the Qur’an mention Adam atoning for his wrong and God forgiving him? I guess what really confuses me is the Sunnah. It seems like Muslims confer infallibility on Muhammad. Was Muhammad morally perfect? To what extent must Muslims imitate him? Is it simply with regard to ethics and religious ritual (like prayer movements)? I mean let’s say Muhammad did not like the taste of apple juice and never drank it; I would not have to imitate this behavior? Does one simply follow the literal actions of Muhammad or their deeper, more esoteric meanings? For example. Muhammad said to grow a beard and trim your moustache to distinguish oneself from unbelievers. Let’s say one was living in a non Muslim country where the larger, unbelieving population, by chance, follow just this fashion and growing a beard and trimming your moustache would in no way distinguish you from the larger population. In such a situation would one shave one’s beard to distinguish oneself thus following the spirit of the Hadith, or maintain the beard to follow the letter of it?
 
Peace be unto you brother
Lol you're probably tired of me already but I'll answer this to the best of my ability. If it was a minor thing like not liking apple juice, I don't think you'd have to hate it too.. It's more about the morals and living your daily life as he did.. As for living in a place where the population had beards, you would still have to do it because it's part of your religion, even if it'll make you blend in with the disbelievers.. If you have any questions, you should go on www.amjaonline.com On the left side, they have a section saying "submit a question" or something like that, and you should ask whatever bothers/confuses you and you'll hopefully receive a reply in your email within a few days.. Wish you the best.
 
Confused0122 said:
Peace be unto you brother
Lol you're probably tired of me already but I'll answer this to the best of my ability. If it was a minor thing like not liking apple juice, I don't think you'd have to hate it too.. It's more about the morals and living your daily life as he did.. As for living in a place where the population had beards, you would still have to do it because it's part of your religion, even if it'll make you blend in with the disbelievers.. If you have any questions, you should go on www.amjaonline.com On the left side, they have a section saying "submit a question" or something like that, and you should ask whatever bothers/confuses you and you'll hopefully receive a reply in your email within a few days.. Wish you the best.
Click to expand...

Thanks, I appreciate your help and am not tired of it.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top