Schools to close on Muslim holidays in order to cut absence rates

  • Thread starter Thread starter Uthman
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 29
  • Views Views 4K

Uthman

LI News Service
Messages
5,513
Reaction score
1,216
Gender
Male
Religion
Islam
Schools will be allowed to close for Islamic holidays in order to improve attendance rates, under new plans.

Many Muslim children are currently taken out of lessons to celebrate religious festivals such as Eid.

In an attempt to lower levels of classroom absences, Manchester City Council is considering allowing schools attended by large numbers of non-Christians to close on these holy days.

Education departments in some parts of east London, where the majority of pupils are Muslim, already tell schools to close on two days for Eid.

But critics point out that Christianity remains the state religion in England, and claim that communities risk becoming more segregated if different groups are allowed to change the school calendar.

Douglas Murray, director of the Centre for Social Cohesion think tank, said: “Either people are British and go to British schools and have a particular holiday system, or we decide to carve the country up into areas that are Muslim and non-Muslim, and I think that’s what this does.

“To have a quota above which schools are designated as Muslims seems to be, putting it at its mildest, an unhelpful way to bring cohesion to Britain.

“I don’t see why, under pressure, education departments should alter the way in which schools are run.”

English schools currently close for the main Christian festivals of Christmas and Easter, but parents are allowed to take children out of lessons to celebrate other religious festivals.

This means that teachers can be faced with half-empty classrooms in areas with high proportions of non-Christian children, adding to official absence rates.

Manchester has the third worst school attendance rates in the country with a total of 8.2 per cent of lesson time lost. Almost one in 10 of all missed days in the city’s schools is put down to religious observance.

In an attempt to improve the figures, it has been suggested that schools where more than 40 per cent of pupils are likely to take a day off for religious reasons should be allowed to consider closing.

Headteachers will be encouraged to hold teacher training days on the three days permitted for non-Christian festivals, while the traditional school holidays will remain unchanged.

John Edwards, the council’s deputy director of children’s services, told the Manchester Evening News: “We encourage schools to work with local faith groups to develop guidance and co-ordinate the times taken for religious observance.

“It is about asking schools to plan ahead and to try not to put themselves in the position where they could be asked to allow additional absence.”

Some schools in London where the majority of pupils are Hindu or Sikh already close on significant days in the calendars of those faiths, while Bradford and Tower Hamlets recommends that its schools close on the Islamic feasts of Eid al-Fitr and Eid ul-Adha, and hold teacher training days instead.

The local authority states: “Tower Hamlets policy is that schools should close for Eid (these dates have been advised by the East London Mosque).

“It is important to ensure that all Muslim pupils and staff can participate in religious observance without being absent from school. This is consistent with the council’s attendance policy that “every day matters”.

“In 2005/6 the overall attendance figures for Tower Hamlets were adversely affected by 0.5 per cent by schools that remained open for Eid.”

edi_1387759c-1.jpg

A child is seen among Muslims attending prayers during Eid al-Fitr, which marks the end of the fasting month of Ramadan

Source
 
Thats OK.

The annual summer school holidays can be reduced by 5 days ( or one week) so the students don't miss out on education.

-
 
Thats OK.

The annual summer school holidays can be reduced by 5 days ( or one week) so the students don't miss out on education.

-

Or they could just not spend the week before they break up for Christmas watching movies. So the students don't miss out on education.

Don't the schools close anyway? The ones that have a high muslim percentage?
 
The Ruler said:
Don't the schools close anyway? The ones that have a high muslim percentage?

Yes, and so all the children miss out on an education. They need to catch up somehow.

The teachers and children should all spend one extra week in school to catch up.

Doesn't matter whether its a week in August or a week in December so long as it's a week.

-
 
That is good news for England unfortunately I'm in Canada:( wish there would be a holiday like this.
 
Douglas Murray, the person from the article who opposed this move, is the author of a book called Neoconservatism: Why we need it. I have seen his "think-tank" known as the Centre for Social Cohesion which was launched by Civitas being described as a right-wing think-tank in the media .The group seems to show a peculiar focus on Muslims and Islam and some have accused the centre of "doing the opposite to what it says on the tin" in that it doesn't appear to be doing much in the way of cohesion. Douglas Murray has also never failed to make his personal negative views on Islam very clear. If you youtube him, you'll know what I mean.
 
:sl:
In my old college, on eid days the place was empty. It was not a muslim-only college but its population was 90% muslim.

They never closed the college on those days in either two years I was there.
 
no one turns up anyway, and their not exactly gona discipline 1000 kids are they.
 
Douglas Murray, director of the Centre for Social Cohesion think tank, said: “Either people are British and go to British schools and have a particular holiday system, or we decide to carve the country up into areas that are Muslim and non-Muslim, and I think that’s what this does.
What a stupid statement.
What of those who are British and Muslim?
 
he probably means, it's either united under british tag, or divided under religion tag.
As long as schools themselves make the decision, and it isn't forced I see no problem with this.
 
I don't really think you can be both..

Yeh you're right but we'd rather be muslims. I still don't know what the definition of being british is, do you?

And I don't see what the problem is with absences, its only two days a year
 
Yes whatsthepoint I'm British and muslim I'm from British Columbia.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top