[nafy]

salaamz

im a little confused bro's n sistaz....i read sumwhere...i cant rememba where:? ....but n e wayz.....

it said sumfin lyk,....both the murderer and the one who is murdered will go to hell....

i was wondering if this was true??? :? and is der any evidence for this? and if its true then why? cus i really dont understand!

dont worry....am not about 2 murder n e 1 lol...was jus sumfin i was unclear about :giggling:

hope u can help me out inshallah

take care
w/salaamz

 

[Salaam]

Salaam,

If the person who was murdered had the intension to kill the Murderer, then he also will go to hell...

So it's to do with the Intension...

(correct me if im Wrong)

 

[Smok]

But if murdered person was just trying to defend himself will he go to hell?

 

[afriend2]

salaam,

never heard of that before, now im all confused :? must find evidence for this, anyone....?

wassalam

 

[nafy]

salaamz

yeh evidence.......das wat i was lukin 4 lol any1? bro Fi_sabilillah usually is gud wiv dis kinda stuff.......but hes in hiding lolz

if anybody knows....plz help

take care
w/salaamz

 

[basitisnumberone]

“If two Muslims meet with their swords (attacking each other) then (both) the killer and the killed one are in the (Hell) Fire.' I (Al-Ahnaf Ibn Qays) said, 'O Allah's Messenger! It is all right for the killer, but what about the killed one?' He said, 'The killed one was eager to kill his opponent.’” (Reported by Al-Bukhari)

 

[Salaam]

But if murdered person was just trying to defend himself will he go to hell?

Salaam, (peace)

No, if the person was just defending them selves, they will not go to hell, unless for other reasons...

 

[Ahmad ibn Saleh]

Assalamu 'Alaikum

The referrence to this Hadith is: Sahih Al Bukhari, Book 2, Hadith 30.

Wa Assalam

 

[Ahmad ibn Saleh]

Assalamu 'Alaikum

This Hadith must be kept in context. It implies that when two believers go out with the intention to kill one another with no valid reason and they actually engage in battle, then both are destined for the Hell Fire.

Wa Assalam

 

[nafy]

Salaamz

jazakallah khayr!

i fink i get it now.....so if the murdered just gets murdered....n he didnt wanna kill da murderer.....for example it happened all of a sudden....den they dont go 2 hell?......yeh i fink i get it

thnk u
take care
w/salaamz

 

[Ahmad ibn Saleh]

Assalamu 'Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahi

Yes, you have got it!

ALHAMDULILLAH!

Wa Assalam

 

[nafy]

salaamz

jazakallah khayr brother!

take care

w/salaamz