tuna in brine :rollseyes

MusLiM 4 LiFe

MusLiM 4 LiFe

IB Expert
Messages
3,819
Reaction score
156
Gender
Female
Religion
Islam
:sl:

da utha say i got told it was haram n i woz like :-\ noooo! so is it.. :rollseyes

:w:
 
MusLiM 4 LiFe said:
:sl:

da utha say i got told it was haram n i woz like :-\ noooo! so is it.. :rollseyes

:w:
Click to expand...

to be honest I can not think of any way a person could make Tuna in Brine Haraam. Perhaps you could post what brand you are talking about and we could all look and see if there is a reason why someone would say it is Haraam.
 
Woodrow said:
to be honest I can not think of any way a person could make Tuna in Brine Haraam. Perhaps you could post what brand you are talking about and we could all look and see if there is a reason why someone would say it is Haraam.
Click to expand...

cant remember da brand, il post it up later
 
nooooooo...that cannot be possibly rite sis....:uuh: :uuh: :uuh:

jus had tuna in brine.....mum made home-made sandwiches....delicious man...

are u sure? da ingredients dnt contain anything haraam.....are u abosolutely sure?

u defintley sure?
 
MusLiM 4 LiFe said:
i bin told but dunno.. i love tuna :cry: :'(
Click to expand...


yeah moi tuna too man......we usually have da john west brand....

i dont get it...how can it be haraam? its fish at the end......

how did u find this out sis? this is the first time am hearing this....
 
john west is haraam...nooo way man...they do the best tuna...

is it the ingredients or da label?

any proof?
 
let me knw sis...

this investigation shall carry on..let moi knw da result man....
 
yeah i will sis....

but i cant figure it out...how can it be haraam? :uuh: :uuh: :uuh:
 
Personaly I suspect that this is a rumor started. A while back there was a big push to ban tuna as sometimes porposes get in the nets and drown. Also there is some talk that too much tuna may be harmfull as tuna from some areas is showing a high Mercury level.

Here are the ingrediants from the John West Site:

Tuna in Brine 425g
Tuna chunks in brine

Ingredients:
Lightmeat tuna (70%), Springwater, Salt


Source:http://www.johnwest.com.au/Products/IndividualProduct.aspx?id=112&idProductCategory=1&idProductType=1
 
so irs harmful now :cry: i fink thats wat she meant 2 say but she said its haram bcuz ur harmin urself :rollseyes
 
Woodrow said:
Personaly I suspect that this is a rumor started. A while back there was a big push to ban tuna as sometimes porposes get in the nets and drown. Also there is some talk that too much tuna may be harmfull as tuna from some areas is showing a high Mercury level.

Here are the ingrediants from the John West Site:

Tuna in Brine 425g
Tuna chunks in brine

Ingredients:
Lightmeat tuna (70%), Springwater, Salt


Source:http://www.johnwest.com.au/Products/IndividualProduct.aspx?id=112&idProductCategory=1&idProductType=1
Click to expand...

its halaal rite...must be a rumour.....man i nearly got a heart attack...
 
yeah its harmful...

but am sure having it once in a while...wont effect us..
 
I would only be concerned about the mercury levels if you ate a lot, say like every day. Or if you were pregnant. I notice that is a UK company, that Tuna most likely comes from the North Sea. I doubt if you even have any mercury problems there. The USA coasts have become notorious for mercury.

I want to blame it on our nuclear power plants. But, so far can't find any link.
 
I think we should be more worried about having a mouth full of mercury in tooth fillings than eating tuna once in a while.

We can't label tuna as haraam just because it may be contaminated with mercury. In that case all agricultural produce (except organic) would become haraam as it's all laced with pesticides which are also harmful to health. I once read somewhere that reciting Bismillah before eating food, assures benefit from it even if the food is poor quality. Allah knows best.
 
Brine is water saturated or nearly saturated with salt. (source: wikipedia

tuna is a fish

so both are halal thus its halal 100%

and if anyne says otherwise they must present their evidence from accredited sources and not imam bubba bob billy of the university of outhouse
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top