Who can speak Urdu here?

[aaj]

You have some huge misunderstanding.

Arabic is the language of the Qur'aan, the language of Jannah, the language of the Malaa'ikah, the language in the Qabr, the language of Rasoolullaah صلى الله عليه وسلم and the language Allaah Ta`aalaa has chosen for this Ummah.
.

I'm just a laymen, you are the student of knowledge with access to all those books and scholars. So when do you think you will be able to bring proof for those claims of yours?

 

[Huzaifah ibn Adam]

I'm just a laymen, you are the student of knowledge with access to all those books and scholars. So when do you think you will be able to bring proof for those claims of yours?

The `Ulamaa are divided on the issue. Those who follow Shaykh-ul-Islaam ibn Taymiyyah's view maintain that there is no proof that Arabic is the language of Jannah, and the Qabr, etc. However, there were many `Ulamaa besides Imaam ibn Taymiyyah who did not hold his view and they, in turn, maintained that the language of Jannah will be Arabic. See the following website:

http://hadithanswers.com/the-language-of-jannah/

 

[Scimitar]

The `Ulamaa are divided on the issue. Those who follow Shaykh-ul-Islaam ibn Taymiyyah's view maintain that there is no proof that Arabic is the language of Jannah, and the Qabr, etc. However, there were many `Ulamaa besides Imaam ibn Taymiyyah who did not hold his view and they, in turn, maintained that the language of Jannah will be Arabic. See the following website:

http://hadithanswers.com/the-language-of-jannah/

I honestly don't care what the language is in heaven - I have no idea why it even matters to Muslims.

Bro Huzaifah, maybe you can give these idiots some advice on how to measure what is important and what is just a waste of time.

Scimi

 

[Huzaifah ibn Adam]

Bro Huzaifah, maybe you can give these idiots some advice on how to measure what is important and what is just a waste of time.

That's good advice. I will take it myself, first and foremost, and not waste anymore time in this thread as it has now simply gone off-topic and whatever needed to be said has already been said.

Final advice to brothers aaj and islamirama: I notice that one (or both of you) quote from IslamQA. Meaning you accept al-Munajjid, correct? Write to him and ask him about your beliefs regarding the Qur'aan and the Arabic language, and see what he says. If you write to him in Arabic he replies back sooner, but if you will be writing to him in non-Arabic, then one of the students will have to translate your question to him first and translate his answer back to you, so you'll have to wait patiently for a few days.

Was-Salaam.

 

[Scimitar]

I'm out too, bro Huzaifah.

...

Scimi

 

[anatolian]

There is so much nationalism in this thread finally. And this is a reflection of today's Muslim enviroment. Arabs are nationalist, Pakistanis are nationalist, Indians are nationalist, Turks are the professors of nationalism etc. etc.. There is even a sister who promotes English language ;D

This is why we cannot achive the union of ummah today.

 

[Scimitar]

I'm Indian, but no patriot to the nation lol. I don't believe in the concept of bordered nations. Mankind may have to deal with it, but we don't have to "believe in it".

Scimi