sorry I saw this question in a closed thread, and I could not help but just want to somehow put my 2 cents in they are all baffled by this question... who created the Creator? well in our world their is a time for everything right? a time for when things begin to exist and a time for when things end in their existence! God (Allah) exists outside of the frame of time! thus if you are not held down by the concept of time or have to go by the rules of time their does not need to be a beginning for a Creator or an end