Are the Prophets sinless according to Ibn Taymiyyah and Imam AbdulWahab? (OP)
Are Prophets Ma'zoom? i.e, sinless, they are protected from sin:
It has been suggested that Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahhab implied that the Messenger of Allah was led astray by Shaitan in the work Mukhtasir Sirat ir-Rasul, pp. 23-25 by the said author. Furthermore, it has been claimed that Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahhabs son wrote or commented on a book under the same title, too implying that the Messenger of Allah was led astray by Shaytaan. - pp. 81-84. It has also been said by the accuser that this understanding was derived from Imam Ibn Taymiyah's Majmu`a Fataawa, V. 4, p. 319-20 as well as V. 10, p. 296.
It is my creed that the Prophets are sinless. In agreement with what has been said by Imam Abu Hanifah in his Fiqh ul Akbar, Imams Nawawi in his Sharh ul Muslim, V. 3, pp. 53-55 and Qadi Iyad Ibn Musa in his classical work Ash-Shifaa. I am interested in seeing the said works in Salafi publications and anything that fairly confirms or refutes these suggestions.
Please read my signature to know that i am not bigoted in my approach. I only try to be fair and just. I tend to find i always get to the truth by using just methods. I can not condemn or defend without evidence, therefore please do not delete this post. Anybody that even trys to say a bad word about Ibn Taymiyah, Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahhab in this thread i have created might aswell be spat on by myself. Please understand, i have no reason to fight, but i have every reason to know whats right and whats wrong. Infact i would like it if people from the Salafiyah answered to this thread only, unless you have the books on your shelve in Arabic and that you will be happy for me to come and persoanlly meet you and take photocopies.
wasalams
A person with personal hatred in the heart will argue, however the one who questions his sincerity will reason.
i dont deduce them as mistakes, i said reminders, its a difference of language, he was reminded by Allah (Swt) not to do this, so that is prove! also we need to understand none of the Prophets (saw) intentionally did wrong, whatever they did they was commanded by Allah (Swt) its like a message and story for all of us
subhanAllah difference on such a simple thing, subhanAllah lol the evidence is there! people just want to follow their own way
like qatadah bro said, their is a difference:blind: so i think its best the discussion is stopped and this thread is closed!!
Jaa-Ro-Nee-Mo!!!
"they ask you when will the help of Allah (swt) come! Certainly Allah (Swt) help is always near"
Re: Are the Prophets sinless according to Ibn Taymiyyah and Imam AbdulWahab?
format_quote Originally Posted by chacha_jalebi
i dont deduce them as mistakes, i said reminders, its a difference of language, he was reminded by Allah (Swt) not to do this, so that is prove! also we need to understand none of the Prophets (saw) intentionally did wrong, whatever they did they was commanded by Allah (Swt) its like a message and story for all of us
subhanAllah difference on such a simple thing, subhanAllah lol the evidence is there! people just want to follow their own way
like qatadah bro said, their is a difference:blind: so i think its best the discussion is stopped and this thread is closed!!
Agreed on that Bro Jazakallah khair , but you did not answer me on my stance of modern day scholars .
Re: Are the Prophets sinless according to Ibn Taymiyyah and Imam AbdulWahab?
thats good subhanAllah, trying to follow the salaf, but if you do actually read some of the stuff by the khalaf scholars such as ibn taymiyyah, ibn baz, subhanallah you will see their manhaj is the same as the salaf, they provide pin point evidence and refer it all back to authentic sources
and ok un officially until we get a mod in this section to close it, this thread is closed
capiche!!
we all love each other, we are all bros n sisters!! so woo hoo
Jaa-Ro-Nee-Mo!!!
"they ask you when will the help of Allah (swt) come! Certainly Allah (Swt) help is always near"
Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
When you create an account, we remember exactly what you've read, so you always come right back where you left off. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and share your thoughts. Sign Up
Jaa-Ro-Nee-Mo!!!
lol
Hide
Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
Bookmarks