Open to all member prizes include things like Islamic Gifts and CDs books etc etc
What say ya all?
like maybe answer questions or write a story or poem or summmat!
Poem
Question and Answers
Essays / Stories
Other (Please specify)
Array
Open to all member prizes include things like Islamic Gifts and CDs books etc etc
What say ya all?
like maybe answer questions or write a story or poem or summmat!
to be honest everyone is intelligent on different levels, and everyone might know the answers to one topic better then the other. in the same way people might be better in writing on one field then the other.
so honestly i think both are the same when it comes to judging.
also we can make the judging factor not how enjoyable the story is, but how much of islam the story teaches.
A strong structured story built around one ayyat could teach a lesson which can benefit someone for life... sadaqah jaariyah right there...
How about two different competitions or something? Those who want stories can have stories? And those who want Q/A's can have them?
And i don't want the story thing to be limited to one topic only.. but it would have to be anything related to Islam maybe.
not maybe bro lol it HAS to be islamic, whats the point of writing a story which takes someone away from the remembrance of ALlah right?format_quote Originally Posted by - Qatada -
but it would have to be anything related to Islam maybe.
format_quote Originally Posted by IbnAbdulHakimnot maybe bro lol it HAS to be islamic, whats the point of writing a story which takes someone away from the remembrance of ALlah right?
lol i meant i don't want it to be limited to death only.. obviously it has to be sutin islamic lol..
lol sry my mistakeformat_quote Originally Posted by - Qatada -
lol i meant i don't want it to be limited to death only.. obviously it has to be sutin islamic lol..
There should be a word limit. Maybe 500 words? And no less than 250 words. Otherwise it wouldn't be fair. Someone could write a 2000 word story, which can't be compared to a 200 word story.
Plus, if it's too long, it would take the judges too long to read through it and thus waste time.
Salam.
wat about islamic riddle?
I think stories or poems would be more interesting as a competition theme, where other members could get to see some of the entries later. It's something that everyone can have a go at, even if they don't feel confident in doing so. However, it does depend on how it is going to be judged and who will be judging it.
proberly the adminstrators
I'm not good with essays and poems but i wanna win too
I think then it would be much better an question and answer competitionformat_quote Originally Posted by syillaI'm not good with essays and poems but i wanna win too
Personally I think stories/poems and essays would be the best to judge. Question and answer means you'll get 300 people who get all questions right out of 400 competitors, if you're rich, Go for it. However, personally I think stories and poems would be more interesting.
Last edited by Silver Pearl; 07-01-2007 at 07:47 PM.
^^ I agree with u sis! stories and poems wud be more interesting!
so i just have to make 8 new users and vote story lol
i dont really wanna do QnA... it seems like it wont be fair. allahu a'lam how its gnna b judged..
im in for Q&A :X
format_quote Originally Posted by Silver Pearl
Personally I think stories/poems and essays would be the best to judge.
stories and poems maybe, but i dont like essays
reminds me of homework :X
Alhamdulillah, i hope another 7 people will vote for stories inshaAllah
format_quote Originally Posted by piXie
stories and poems maybe, but i dont like essays
reminds me of homework :X
stories = essay... See? the equation isn't that hard.
Re: Who here is up for a competition
i wana change my vote now.
Hide
Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
Posting Permissions
Quote
Bookmarks