issit haram if thers no instruments????

[------]

salam

I have no idea, the same way I have no idea if music is haram......

yeh u do have an idea

u asked this question so many times before. why do u insist on slipping down into gangster lifestyle again? subhanAllaah you were doing so well...:skeleton:

 

[------]

:salamext:

IbnAbdulHakim's got a good suggestion - if you can sing! :skeleton:

Lol if you know the lyrics to some songs or whatever, try humming/singing them in tune with what you listen to, and you'lll find you won't need to listen to the song because ur singing it and listening to it without music!

 

[truemuslim]

lol i kno people! i sayd if they dont say anything bad. like they talkin bout kwl thangs man! i aint talkin bout if the lyrics are good i said if the lyrics ARE good. nah they aint islamic but they aint haram either!

jazakumallah khairan for ur replies

:salamext:

IbnAbdulHakim's got a good suggestion - if you can sing! :skeleton:

Lol if you know the lyrics to some songs or whatever, try humming/singing them in tune with what you listen to, and you'lll find you won't need to listen to the song because ur singing it and listening to it without music!

lol ok lets move that whole idea out coz i do sing/rap all the time but cmon whats thugz mansion without beat ??
besides that was pretty much my question, lol. i asked if its halal with normal lyrics and no instruments, just like me singing it! so i take it fine since u just suggested it
jazakallah khair
thank u
peace!

 

[IbnAbdulHakim]

^ singing tupac without the beats is haram coz his one foul mouthed piece o....

 

[truemuslim]

^ singing tupac without the beats is haram coz his one foul mouthed piece o....

dam if u were in america u woulda gettin ur a** whuped by now! sshhh! u like them xxx!(u dunt want the bludz witcha man!) besides have u heard his good songs? also have u ever heard the CLEAN VERSION on any songs of his? yhhh .

 

[IbnAbdulHakim]

dam if u were in america u woulda gettin ur a** whuped by now! sshhh! u like them xxx!(u dunt want the bludz witcha man!) besides have u heard his good songs? also have u ever heard the CLEAN VERSION on any songs of his? yhhh .

ur listening to some tunes right now arent you? i can tell by the way your typing :| !

 

[noorseeker]

go on you tube and listen to mutah beale or napoleon as he is known, you know tupacs bedrin, YEs TUPAC, everyones hero, if he's bedrin is sayin gangster life is haram,and he's lived that life , then he's in a good position to tell us its haram.

truly inspiring talker mashallah

 

[truemuslim]

ur listening to some tunes right now arent you? i can tell by the way your typing :| !

wow. thats scary. and actually im listening to something good. nothing bad. well yeh bad beat, but the lyrics are sickkkkly clean! (its not tupac)

go on you tube and listen to mutah beale or napoleon as he is known, you know tupacs bedrin, YEs TUPAC, everyones hero, if he's bedrin is sayin gangster life is haram,and he's lived that life , then he's in a good position to tell us its haram.

truly inspiring talker mashallah

wow...the outlawz guys??? noway...wow...
jazakallah khair but no talker talks me outta anything. :-[ mayb inspire but nothing more, no action just thinking.