I love music!!!!!!!!!!!...

  • Thread starter Thread starter truemuslim
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 46
  • Views Views 7K
bewildred said:
Well, ain't we going to extremes here? Okay, it's bad but is it the path to haram? Who's guilty, the murderer or the gun?

Too many of my posts were deleted because of absence of daleel in Hadith. I see no one has used any daleel in here and yet their opinions were accepted. Please, anyone who has a daleel saying that music is haram, do share with us. When I say a daleel, I mean a hadith or Surah and not a fatwa of x or y mufti.
Click to expand...

:sl:

I think no one brought any daleel here because its been discussed on this forum many times over, and I don't think it was the intent of this thread to provide daleel. However,if you're up for some reading, here is an e-book I've put up on the forum which contains everything you're looking for:

http://www.islamicboard.com/fiqh/20238-music-singing-light-quran-sunnah.html
 
Okay, interesting read bro. To be honest, I haven't found anything saying music is haram. I mean music in its actual conception. Your daleel consisted of interpreting words that are isolated in different hadeeths. For every sin there's a kaffara. What's the kaffara of listening to music????

Please, brothers and sisters, don't misunderstand my intentions. My doubs are the fruit of a bitter disappointment. I explain: I bought a book called "Asbab an'nuzuul". I wanted to learn more about the reason many verses came to exist. To my great dismay, I discovered that there were too many versions that were provided. Scholars gave too different meanings of a word. The conclusion is that after reading that big book, I don't know for sure about one surah.

Is it the same to listen to music in an ipod and to be in an assembly where music is played?????
 
bewildred said:
Okay, interesting read bro. To be honest, I haven't found anything saying music is haram. I mean music in its actual conception. Your daleel consisted of interpreting words that are isolated in different hadeeths. For every sin there's a kaffara. What's the kaffara of listening to music????
Click to expand...

It depends on what you're looking for, and what will satisfy you? If you want statements of the Companions of their Tafseer of the Qur'an and understanding of what the Messenger (saw) said, then I can give it to you. It's in the book I linked to. If that isn't enough, then I can give you the opinions of the early Salaf and the four Imaams and the opinions of each of the madahib. If that doesn't suffice, then wallahi, I don't know what will.

At the end of the day, I'm not going to force you to agree with me. I just intend to show you the opinion that was the opinion of our Salaf.
Please, brothers and sisters, don't misunderstand my intentions. My doubs are the fruit of a bitter disappointment. I explain: I bought a book called "Asbab an'nuzuul". I wanted to learn more about the reason many verses came to exist. To my great dismay, I discovered that there were too many versions that were provided. Scholars gave too different meanings of a word. The conclusion is that after reading that big book, I don't know for sure about one surah.
Click to expand...

This is why an individual isn't supposed to jump into the sciences. It's like a pre-med student jumping into something to do with heart surgery. Uloom al-Qur'an needs to be studied in a systematic way, and definetly not alone and from a book. And the study has pre-requisites as well. The study of Uloom al-Quran demands the need for a teacher, a book can only complement actual learning, it can't be the teacher in and of itself.

Is it the same to listen to music in an ipod and to be in an assembly where music is played?????
Click to expand...
Are you listening to the same thing?
 
Brother Abu Sayyad, you were in no case condescendent to me when answering my questions. You took the time to give me links and read my bewildering statements. For that kindness of yours, I dedicate to you my warmest thanks. You showed no impatience and it really means a lot to me. You represent what's good in Muslims, mashallah and jazakallah.

By the way, the example you provided me, you know about the medical stuff, was really relevant and well-chosen.

(Just between us, I truly believe that music is haram,lol)
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top