Migration-in Islam...&...Phalestine.

[rpwelton]

didn't jews migrate from Germany in recent past???
were there no border rules back then???

Afghanis migrated into Pakistan in huge numbers & Pakistan welcomed them..... when USSR was expelled from there, they gradually started returning to their homeland. Their migration in a way helped fighters to fight USSR better.

Now it's Egypt's turn to welcome Palestinians into Egypt.

Each situation has its own particular circumstances. Of course it's ideal for someone to seek out a safer land free of oppression, but that's binding upon the leaders of other nations to let them in.

If Egypt will welcome Palestinians, sure, there's nothing wrong with that if they can make the journey. As I said before, I don't want to throw out generalizations upon an entire people because the circumstances for each individual are different.

 

[The_Prince]

sur, u shud go to a zionist forum, they will love u, heck, the Israeli goverment will even honour, heck even more, the Zionist fathers will love you as well, you are great for them, you want all Palestinians to leave their land, just like the zionists, wow they will sure loveeeeeee u.

 

[The_Prince]

probably you are the one who need to improve your reading:
read again:-
IF I'M NOT FORGETTING PPL WANTED TO KILL PROPHET & muslims, WASN'T THAT A REASON FOR THEIR MIGRATION.....???//? SO WHEN ISRAEL WANT TO KILL ALL PALESTINIANS SHOULDN'T THEY FOLLOW WHAT PROPHET DID TO SAVE HIS & HIS FELLOWS LIVES..........???

order of immigration in Quran is exactly for the situation that Palestinians are going throgh.

wrong wrong again, Muslims should migrate when the oppresion is so bad that they cant follow their religion anymore, thats when they should migrate, and also if their in the minority.

when Israel wants to kill all Palis, the Palis should fight back as their not in the minority, nor are they banned from their religion, hence they must do Jihad, one of the greatest Islamic duty.

 

[The_Prince]

probably you are the one who need to improve your reading:
read again:-
IF I'M NOT FORGETTING PPL WANTED TO KILL PROPHET & muslims while they were too weak to take enemy head on, WASN'T THAT A REASON FOR THEIR MIGRATION.....???//? SO WHEN ISRAEL WANT TO KILL ALL PALESTINIANS SHOULDN'T THEY FOLLOW WHAT PROPHET DID TO SAVE HIS & HIS FELLOWS LIVES..........???

order of immigration in Quran is exactly for the situation that Palestinians are going throgh.

where scholars said that ppl should not migrate when their lives are under threat...???

no, that wasnt the reason, the prophet was planning to migrate EVEN BEFORE THEY TRIED KILLED HIM, stop quoting out of context, the prophet didnt decide to migrate as a result of the assasination attempt, rather that was the sign for him to finally go. hence again your wrong, the prophet wanted to migrate BEFORE THEY TRIED TO KILL HIM, YET HE WAS WAITING FOR ALLAH'S PERMISSION.

 

[sur]

sur, u shud go to a zionist forum, they will love u, heck, the Israeli goverment will even honour, heck even more, the Zionist fathers will love you as well, you are great for them, you want all Palestinians to leave their land, just like the zionists, wow they will sure loveeeeeee u.

Like Quraish loved Prophet when he migrated from MAkkah....!!!! & left his land.

wrong wrong again, Muslims should migrate when the oppresion is so bad that they cant follow their religion anymore, thats when they should migrate, and also if their in the minority.

when Israel wants to kill all Palis, the Palis should fight back as their not in the minority, nor are they banned from their religion, hence they must do Jihad, one of the greatest Islamic duty.

lets wait, & leave till ALLAH decides. I just had to present Quran's verse. You dont wanna believe.. up to you. No point in lenghtening the thread.

 

[Muhammad]

This thread is an example of why we need to refer to the knowledgeable i.e. the scholars for solutions. The task of making analogy between two things, as well as interpreting Islamic texts, requires the person to have a deep understanding of the Islamic sciences, hence it is not something for the layman. Let us remember this for future discussions Insha'Allaah.

Thread closed.