marwen
IB Expert
- Messages
- 2,089
- Reaction score
- 596
- Gender
- Male
- Religion
- Islam
Assalamu 3alaycom wr wb !
Hope you're all in good health aftre the upgrade storm ;D
Ok, if this topic is already existing in another thread, so please someone link this thread to it or just delete this thread and give me the other link.
That's something which made me confused : When I open the 'mushaf' and read Surat al-Fatiha, I find the the word/ayah "bismillah-ir-ra7hmen-ir-rahim" (In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.) is numbered as Ayah N°1. So we should always read it, otherwise the Fatiha will not be complete. And if, in the salat, the fatiha is not complete (completely read), then the salat will be invalid.
But after praying behind a big number of Imams, I realised that they do not pronounce the first ayah (bismillah...) and start reciting from "Al-hamdulilli rabi-l-aalamin...etc", So I'm confused :
1) did they not read it at all ? and in this case, is their salat correct ?
2) did they read it in a low voice so i can't hear it ? and also is this correct ? For example in Isha Prayer, you have to read qur'an aloud (every ayah in fatiha should be read aloud), so will salat in this case be considered incomplete ?
Please if someone has a clear response from scholars or ahadeeth, it'll be very helpful.
Hope you're all in good health aftre the upgrade storm ;D
Ok, if this topic is already existing in another thread, so please someone link this thread to it or just delete this thread and give me the other link.
That's something which made me confused : When I open the 'mushaf' and read Surat al-Fatiha, I find the the word/ayah "bismillah-ir-ra7hmen-ir-rahim" (In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.) is numbered as Ayah N°1. So we should always read it, otherwise the Fatiha will not be complete. And if, in the salat, the fatiha is not complete (completely read), then the salat will be invalid.
But after praying behind a big number of Imams, I realised that they do not pronounce the first ayah (bismillah...) and start reciting from "Al-hamdulilli rabi-l-aalamin...etc", So I'm confused :
1) did they not read it at all ? and in this case, is their salat correct ?
2) did they read it in a low voice so i can't hear it ? and also is this correct ? For example in Isha Prayer, you have to read qur'an aloud (every ayah in fatiha should be read aloud), so will salat in this case be considered incomplete ?
Please if someone has a clear response from scholars or ahadeeth, it'll be very helpful.
