A prophet by any other name

  • Thread starter Thread starter IAmZamzam
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 2
  • Views Views 2K
I

IAmZamzam

IB Expert
Messages
1,480
Reaction score
181
Gender
Male
Religion
Islam
Wikipedia claims that Hud has often been identified with the biblical prophet Eber and Shuayb with Jethro. Thing is I’m not seeing any citations. Have any of you ever heard of this theory? And if so what do you think of it?

And while we’re at it what do you guys think of the very real age-old controversies over whether Zul-Kifl was Ezekiel and Idris was Enoch?
 
Yahya Sulaiman said:
Wikipedia claims that Hud has often been identified with the biblical prophet Eber and Shuayb with Jethro. Thing is I’m not seeing any citations. Have any of you ever heard of this theory? And if so what do you think of it?

And while we’re at it what do you guys think of the very real age-old controversies over whether Zul-Kifl was Ezekiel and Idris was Enoch?
Click to expand...

As'alaamu Alaikkum John

Good thread. I think the only connection that Prophet Shua'ib (Alayhi Salaam) could be Jethro is that both are from Midyan. Jethro was ofcourse, also the father in law of Prophet Musa (Alayhi Salaam). I don't really know how one can make a connection. We are told that Prophet Shua'ib (Alayhi Salaam) was preaching against cheating travellers of false weight measurements.

I suppose some of the Prophets can be linked linguistically. For example, Musa (Moses), Job (Ayyub), Jonah (Yunus), Yakkub (Jacob) etc. But when it comes to Zul Khifl or Idris etc then we have a problem. I don't think there are any prophetic narrations to help us either. Allahu Alum.
 
I don't know. It seems to me that if you say "Ezekiel" through a mouthful of Chex Mix you pretty much have said "Zul-Kifl". As I understand it a lot of The Quran's names for the other prophets aren't the most obvious cognates in the world either.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top