Which mathhab to follow?

[ZeeshanParvez]

Hes more of a mujtahaid then you and me. We are both Muqalid.

But we are not discussing that.

The rules of the Madhabs say you cannot follow any scholar of the Madhab. The Madhabs have certain scholars you make Taqliid of as the Madhab is based on them.

Did you know this?

 

[Zafran]

But we are not discussing that.

The rules of the Madhabs say you cannot follow any scholar of the Madhab. The Madhabs have certain scholars you make Taqliid of as the Madhab is based on them.

Did you know this?

We are both muqalids of Great Mujtahaids, scholars.

 

[ZeeshanParvez]

We are both muqalids of Great Mujtahaids, scholars.

Now you are just repeating a phrase over and over again. That will not lead to a fruitful discussion. You will become frustrated and the mods will have no choice but to delete the posts.

I will leave you with your fallacy. Have a nice day. : )

 

[Zafran]

Now you are just repeating a phrase over and over again. That will not lead to a fruitful discussion. You will become frustrated and the mods will have no choice but to delete the posts.

I will leave you with your fallacy. Have a nice day. : )

Allah akbar.

 

[ZeeshanParvez]

Allah akbar.

Indeed, Allaah is the greatest. : )

 

[ZeeshanParvez]

Allah akbar.

Since you feel you won I would like to leave you with a quote of the Mujtahid Imaam al-Shaafi'i:

İmam al-Shafi'i said: "If I were argue with one thousand knowledgeable people,I would surely win the argument.But if I were to argue with one fool,I would lose the argument"

I see the quote come true every day!

Enjoy the win ; )

 

[ZeeshanParvez]

which madhab we need to follow?

Follow the Qur'aan and Sunnah but if you must then follow the Shaafi'i Madhab. Sheikh al-Albaani and other independent researchers say it is closest to the Qur'aan and Sunnah.

That will light some fireworks.

 

[Zafran]

Since you feel you won I would like to leave you with a quote of the Mujtahid Imaam al-Shaafi'i:

İmam al-Shafi'i said: "If I were argue with one thousand knowledgeable people,I would surely win the argument.But if I were to argue with one fool,I would lose the argument"

I see the quote come true every day!

Enjoy the win ; )

May God preserve and keep you in good health. Arguments never get us anywhere. Not about Fiqh anyway.

 

[ZeeshanParvez]

May God preserve and keep you in good health. Arguments never get us anywhere. Not about Fiqh anyway.

Don't worry. I love you and all Muslims. But as did the Companions (may Allaah be pleased with them) we will always disagree.

It only becomes bad when we get ill feelings towards the other.

 

[azc]

Nah you didn't follow the thread. He claims there is no need for Qiyaas.

Why you've twisted the discussion?
You claimed that those rulings of imams' which were based on qiyas for not getting the Dalil, so modern age scholars can do qiyas if they find the dalil concerning same issue.
And I asked you to prove it that all four imams remain in darkness without dalil and had to do qiyas.

It should be known to you that only 4800 approximately ahadith were reported from prophet s.a.w but later on they're changed into millions due to different chains of transmission.

Now try to understand where an imam did qiyas.
e.g.

Can a zaani marry the mother of zaaniya (or her daughter born to their zina)?

There is no specific dalil in Quran, hadith and ijma of Sahaba ikam RA concerning the Hurmat of nikah.

in such cases Qiyas was done

If your scholars have got any specific dalil, plz tell us