Joining congregationn

  • Thread starter Thread starter soheil1
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 17
  • Views Views 3K
S

soheil1

Esteemed Member
Messages
162
Reaction score
3
Gender
Male
Religion
Islam
Hello.
What would a Sunni Muslim (of different schools) do if they arrive at a congregation when imam is in Ruku'? What about Sojood?
 
eesa the kiwi said:
Join the ruku or sujood respectively

What's your agenda for asking
Click to expand...
In Iran, we used to utter 'yaa-allaah' so the Imam would lengthen the ruku' so that we have time for Takbir and going to Ruku' (pillars of namaaz are the takbir.at-ul-ehraam, pre-Ruku', ruku, post-Ruku', sujood). We cannot join while imam is in sojood.
But I don't see this practice here in Calgary, so I wonder why is that.
 
soheil1 said:
In Iran, we used to utter 'yaa-allaah' so the Imam would lengthen the ruku' so that we have time for Takbir and going to Ruku' (pillars of namaaz are the takbir.at-ul-ehraam, pre-Ruku', ruku, post-Ruku', sujood). We cannot join while imam is in sojood.
But I don't see this practice here in Calgary, so I wonder why is that.
Click to expand...

Doesn't make sense to me. So you saying that if ten people were to come one after another, saying Ya Allah....then the Imam would have to remain in Ruku all that time ?
 
Supernova said:
Doesn't make sense to me. So you saying that if ten people were to come one after another, saying Ya Allah....then the Imam would have to remain in Ruku all that time ?
Click to expand...
not all thhe time, but sometimes he legthens it
 
soheil1 said:
not all thhe time, but sometimes he legthens it
Click to expand...

So he the Imam has the autonomy to lengthen the ruku despite someone calling out Ya Allah (Even-though the objective of calling out Ya Allah is for him to lengthen it in the first place) ????

That now REALLY doesn't make sense. Please expound on this fully so we may understand.
 
soheil1 said:
In Iran, we used to utter 'yaa-allaah' so the Imam would lengthen the ruku' so that we have time for Takbir and going to Ruku' (pillars of namaaz are the takbir.at-ul-ehraam, pre-Ruku', ruku, post-Ruku', sujood). We cannot join while imam is in sojood.
But I don't see this practice here in Calgary, so I wonder why is that.
Click to expand...

You don't see that practice because it's not from the sunnah
 
Assalam O Alaikum WaRahmatullahi WaBarakatuh,

Hope you find videos below helpful:

And thanks for asking this question.
Jazakallah khair
Ma’aSalaam
 
HabibUrrehman said:
Assalam O Alaikum WaRahmatullahi WaBarakatuh,

Hope you find videos below helpful:


And thanks for asking this question.
Jazakallah khair
Ma’aSalaam
Click to expand...
No, didn't search for videos, my English is not very good, but thanks. I got a feeling from the first video.
Yes, we also pray the missed ruk'a's, but when we imam lengthens the ruku', we at least don't miss that ruk'at.
 

If you understand farsī - the following link is a question & answer site. You can find the sunnah manner of namāz, the supporting evidences & opinions of scholars .

https://islamqa.info/fa



[TABLE="class: grid, width: 100%, align: center"]
[TR][TD]اسلام سوال و جواب
موقع دعوي، علمي تربوي يهدف إلى تقديم الفتاوى والإجابات العلمية المؤصلة عن الأسئلة المتعلقة بالإسلام بشكل واف وميسر قدر الاستطاعة...[/TD][/TR][/TABLE]
 
eesa the kiwi said:
Not when it wasn't done by the prophet sallaho alayhi wa sallam or his companions may Allah bless them with the highest ranks of jannah
Click to expand...

Who said saying rewarding dhikr wasn't done by thhe prophet, a sahabi, or a household of the prophet? The prophet himself would make Qunut, so it is not something new
 


احکام مسبوق در نماز (کسی که دیر به نماز جماعت رسیده)


سوال

می-خواهم احکام کسی که دیر به نماز جماعت رسیده را به تفصیل بدانم.
​

https://islamqa.info/fa/answers/246225/احکام-مسبوق-در-نماز-کسی-که-دیر-به-نماز-جماعت-رسیده


English - Rulings for one who is late for the congregational prayer

https://islamqa.info/en/answers/246225/rulings-for-one-who-is-late-for-the-congregational-prayer

 
soheil1 said:
In Iran, we used to utter 'yaa-allaah' so the Imam would lengthen the ruku' so that we have time for Takbir and going to Ruku' (pillars of namaaz are the takbir.at-ul-ehraam, pre-Ruku', ruku, post-Ruku', sujood). We cannot join while imam is in sojood.
But I don't see this practice here in Calgary, so I wonder why is that.
Click to expand...

Salaam brother soheil1,

We should try to be respectful of the culture. Maybe in Iran, this was a practice you and the Muslims there have done...

But if you live in Calgary Canada, and you notice nobody does this cultural practice, it's because we Canadian Muslims don't.

While the Imam is leading the prayer, we may say Ameen aloud after Surah Fatihah. Other than that. we don't utter anything aloud as not to distract others or the Imam. If you are late to congregation, you silently join in and pray the missed rakat after the prayer has ended.

Only Allah knows best.
 
soheil1 said:
But I heard that Islamqa is run by an excommunicated Sheikh ...
Click to expand...

If he's not willing to compromise his religion for the rulers. More reason to listen to him.
 
Last edited:
Iceee said:
Salaam brother soheil1,

We should try to be respectful of the culture. Maybe in Iran, this was a practice you and the Muslims there have done...

But if you live in Calgary Canada, and you notice nobody does this cultural practice, it's because we Canadian Muslims don't.

While the Imam is leading the prayer, we may say Ameen aloud after Surah Fatihah. Other than that. we don't utter anything aloud as not to distract others or the Imam. If you are late to congregation, you silently join in and pray the missed rakat after the prayer has ended.

Only Allah knows best.
Click to expand...
WAS,
But 3 out of 5 prayers require audible(جهریة) reciting of Al-Fatihah&the surah, while others' Fatihah&Surah have to be inaudible (سریة)
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top