is Allah fair ? Yes!

I wondered a question similar to this when I was much younger than I am now. I looked around the world and saw people who have, and who have not. I wondered why God made it so people have to suffer more than others, just like the author of this tread but then I understood. It seems really strange to me that you would blame, if that's the right word, Allah for what is "fair" and what is not "fair".

Allah (swt) created this world for us. We inhabit it. It is our job to take care of this earth. Yet, there are some people in this world who don't play by the rules. While there are people in other parts of the world who are dying of hunger everyday, there are people in the United States who are dying from over-consumption of food. We have an abundance but we certainly don't do all that we can to help those in need. Many just make excuses.

People have put political systems in place that make it so there will always be people who are without. Whether it is access to education, food, clean water, clothes, etc. There is not an equal distribution of wealth in the world and that is because some people simply take more than they need. Others just don't have a moral compass. Some are just greedy and really don't care. As long as they "take care of their own" then the rest of the world just doesn't matter. There are a lot of people these days, at least in my area, who live by "sucks to be you." if something bad ever happened.

Tell me, if people did what Allah (swt) said we should do, prayed, gave charity, treated their fellow brothers and sisters with respect, we probably wouldn't have these "rich" and "poor" issues in the world as you see it now. There might be some people who have more than others, but not to the extent of the devastation that you see today. I see the poverty in the world as a mirror that looks back on us in this day and time and says, "Who are we and what have we become?" Generations from now people will study our time in history books and they'll see how we let other generations of people die, while there were nations in the world who could have helped that, but they just didn't. The ones in power didn't and we rarely do anything to tell those in power to do anything about it. As long as "my people" are OK then who cares about the others? That's how it is in the USA. There are citizens who think that we should help ourselves before we help anyone else, even if anyone else is much worse off than we are. People here don't see humanity as one, but divided nations. The problem is we now live in a world where people think they know better than God when Allah knows best. Not all people quite understand that.

So you want to blame Allah (swt) for some of mankind's misdeeds and selfishness? I think what you need to do is take a look in the mirror at yourself. Instead of blaming Allah (swt), what have you done lately to help fix some of what is wrong in your community? What have you done to help tone down some of the education and poverty issues that plague the community that you live in? What have you done to inspire others around you to help fix some of these problems? I imagine not much or else you wouldn't be on the message board asking this question.

May Allah give you the strength to see the beauty in your community and to help out your fellow brothers and sisters.
Allahumma inne asaloka wal amaan e wal imaan fid dunya wal akhera. Ameen.
 
Allah is way beyond fair. You remind me of a man who asked one Muslim scholar:

"Why, if Allah is all that great, can't Allah just make all man good?"

To which the Muslim scholar answered:

"If everything in the world tasted sweet, you will not know what is the taste of sweet. If everything in the world were colored white, you will not know what is the color of white."

To try to understand Allah, to use a very poor analogy, is to be like a fly that tries to understand a frog. The difference in magnitude of intelligence is simply too great a chasm to be bridged. Actually you don't have to understand Allah to be able to live fully as a Muslim. Myself, I just try my best to do what Allah says to do, and tries my best not to do what Allah forbids to do. And I find that life is wonderful. AlhamduliLLah.
 
Assalaam Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuh,

It is certainly the case that Allah knows how we act and live in this world. He sends us to be tested by Him, so that we can improve our abilities and skills through the responsibilities He ordains for us. Undoubtedly, Allah creates us just as He creates minerals such as coal, copper, iron, silver and gold: He is the Lord, the Cherisher, the Owner and Maker of all.

A person with artistic talents wants to express those talents and so is known through his works of art. In the same way, the majesty and splendour and artistry of the creation of Allah is a presentation and reflection of His sacred Names and Attributes. To show human beings His art (Might, Power, Knowledge, Wisdom, Beauty and Mercy) He created the universe and exhibited aspects of His mysterious, hidden treasures in it.

To show us how His Names, Attributes and Divine Art become manifest, He created the universe step by step. In different qualities and quantities, He grants us countless opportunities to get to know Him better, endless ways to acquire sound knowledge about Him. He is the absolute Creator who makes everything from one, and adds to whatever He wills thousands of additional benefits. Thus it is that, for example, carbon may be manifest as coal or diamond, and each further refined and adapted to a multitude of different uses.

Through whatever is created and exhibited in the universe and is given to man, man himself is tested, purified and prepared as a candidate for eternal bliss in paradise. In the same way, raw materials are refined, purified and processed into silver, gold or diamonds. In one hadith, the Prophet Muhammad, upon him be peace, said: ‘Human beings are just like minerals. One who is good in jahiliyya (the time of pagan ignorance in Arabia before Islam) is also good in Islam’ (Bukhari, Iman, 10, Anbiya’, 8–14; Muslim, Fada’il al-Sahaba, 168, Mana-qib, 25; Ibn Hanbal, Musnad, 3, 101). For example, ‘Umar enjoyed dignity, glory and honour before Islam, but when he became a Muslim he had more. He gained a calmer dignity, tender-heartedness and the grandeur of iman. Before Islam, he might be tough, quick-tempered, haughty, as one who thought he had everything; after becoming Muslim, he was one of the most modest and humble of men in his bearing towards the believers. Through Islam, he improved his qualities and attributes. Therefore, when we see well-mannered, dynamic, ener-getic, audacious and spirited people, we wish them to be Muslim, for one who was good, great, glorious and es-teemed before Islam will be far more so in Islam.
Islam deals with the most precious and invaluable of minerals─man. It takes man, kneads, improves and ma¬tures him, refining him as gold is refined pure. The Com¬panions of the Prophet, upon him be peace, became so, 24 carat pure. Later on, however, Muslims began to fall off from this standard of fineness, from 24 to 15 carats. In the twentieth century, some people have even fallen to a standard of one carat or less in their fineness. In consequence, sadly, this century has witnessed the trouble caused by many dissolute and criminal persons.
We are tested in this world so that we may become clari¬fied, purified and attain virtue and perfection. Even though Allah knows how well or otherwise we perform in the test, He tests us all the same. It is not because He does not know and wants to learn what He does not know through us, rather He knows and accordingly tests a man against himself, and man against others. When we make strenuous efforts to refine ourselves, to find out and prove what we are, what we have, and whether we are worthless and valueless like iron or great like gold, we are only acting as a means to make happen what Allah already knows from eternity. We are tested in what we strive for, and in what we exert ourselves to do. In this way, we shall enter the presence of Allah and give account of ourselves to Him: ...But their hands will speak to us, and their feet bear witness, to all that they did (al-Fussilat, 41.65). ‘Hands and feet’ symbolically represent all our instruments for action, all the members of our bodies, including our faculties and opportunities. In other verses, ‘eyes, ears and skins’ are all mentioned as bearing witness against us if we have misused them.

We are being tested against ourselves, in all that we have─all the members of our bodies, all our faculties of thought and feeling, and all the opportunities we have been granted to use them. Allah, Exalted is He, does not test us because He wants to know how we do in the test, but because He wants to show us ourselves so that we become aware that we are testing ourselves and being tested. And Allah knows best.
 
:sl:

so allah allows suffering of some people with injustice ...


Prophets pbut were the chosen people , yet they suffered more than us ( ordinary people ) . Hope u dont think
Allah did injustice to His messengers pbut ?



.. allah is not human .. how could he possiably understand human feelings ?

because He is our Creator . He knows about everything . If Allah needs to become human to
understand us , then He needs to be Jinn , angel and lower class animals to understand their feelings ?

Astagferrullah.
 
sorry to bring up an old old topic
but i just wanted to say thanks to Allah
i no longer feel the same way i did years ago
i saw the forums message in my email inbox and reminded me
of why i signed up and thought i might come back and say this

now i look back at it . it seems like childish question
but it helped me alot to understand my God and religion more
and thankfully Allah gave me my answers
hopefully everyone gets their answers as well
the answer vary from person to person
and only Allah can give answer good enough to remove doubts entirely
and He will when the time is right
peace ! and again sorry to bring up a very old topic
 
Allah swt is just..

I have no knowledge of the afterlife so my answer should end there.

But how do you consider this life?


Years of research..

To define your character.


Answer 1: yes its easiest to be nice when not walking up hill..

But if you ever have to walk up hill.. Try not to push a boulder along with you.

Maybe it will make you realise that every person pushes a boulder of some kind.

Or not.

Answer 2: iv been humbled or humiliated by both rich men and cleaners..

Recognise authority in its many forms. Wait till you get old.. Those flippin upstarts >:(

But yes, it would be rather nice to wear a better suit.. Or a clean one some days.

Answer 3: all you can do is try. Sometimes at least you can show how not to do it.. Or inspire others.. In work or ideas.

Let me pick your brain for a moment...

Funny I didn't think I had one :/

...I do, that was a joke

Really? I was so angry I missed it.


Question 4: yes, the most we can do is oppose Allah swt with all that we have..

If only to know our selves.

...I would pray so hard!!

(Not isreal)

Answer 5: yes the world is actually a test. I'd fight tooth and nail for what I believe in..

As much as my character allows me..

Mr.muscle the kitchen cleaner.



Imo... These are quick answers that should turn your frown upside down for a moment.

It's not entirely in jest.

You can't look up out of the hole and say how on earth did I get here?

We all get what we put forward.. Good deeds and conduct are something for Allah swt to decide on..

All you can do is try..


Out of work for an absolute age, cv's like the post man.. Finally got two job interviews in a week... Two! Count em!

Admitted to hospital a few days before and missed them both.

You couldn't make it up if you tried. Alhamdulillah.

It would be ungrateful of me to overlook those that have helped me all this time.
 
Last edited:
Allah is fair. The Quran mentions several times that he is just. [emoji173]
 
Allah tala Owns all of Creation,

He has the right to set the rules and punish accordingly any of his creation that Disobeys and Forgive whom he wills,

As stated before several times,

Allah tala is not unjust in the Least degree,
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Am i late? I think I am late..

Hello I'm 16 years old, and since around a month ago, i also have this problem of overthinking whether is Allah fair, then later on it leads me to the question "is Allah really the right God?" But judging from other religions, it seems to me that Islam is the current most logical religion out of all the others. But still, i can't stop thinking of it because in my head there's like so much conclusions... aaaaaaaaarghhh...
Have you found the answers yet?
I am very confused by this, and i think i will die before knowing the truths
Please if you know the answers to this topic, i really need it
 
Am i late? I think I am late..

Hello I'm 16 years old, and since around a month ago, i also have this problem of overthinking whether is Allah fair, then later on it leads me to the question "is Allah really the right God?" But judging from other religions, it seems to me that Islam is the current most logical religion out of all the others. But still, i can't stop thinking of it because in my head there's like so much conclusions... aaaaaaaaarghhh...
Have you found the answers yet?
I am very confused by this, and i think i will die before knowing the truths
Please if you know the answers to this topic, i really need it

What makes you question Allah's fairness..?

But to answer your question yes, Allah is Just and He is the One and Only God.
 
Aoa. Allah is whatever you think of Him.
Yes and no.

I am aware of the hadeeth:
[FONT=&quot]The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Allah says: 'I am just as My slave thinks I am, (i.e. I am able to do for him what he thinks I can do for him) and I am with him if He remembers Me. If he remembers Me in himself, I too, remember him in Myself; and if he remembers Me in a group of people, I remember him in a group that is better than they; and if he comes one span nearer to Me, I go one cubit nearer to him; and if he comes one cubit nearer to Me, I go a distance of two outstretched arms nearer to him; and if he comes to Me walking, I go to him running.' "[/FONT]

However, this does not mean that if you think "Allah is unjust" that Allah is indeed unjust in reality. Allahs justice is not dependant on our thoughts...He is ALWAYS just.

The hadeeth just means that, If you for example do not make dua because you think "Allah is unjust, so He will not grant my dua anyways"...then it means that He probably will not give you want you want...


Am i late? I think I am late..

Hello I'm 16 years old, and since around a month ago, i also have this problem of overthinking whether is Allah fair, then later on it leads me to the question "is Allah really the right God?" But judging from other religions, it seems to me that Islam is the current most logical religion out of all the others. But still, i can't stop thinking of it because in my head there's like so much conclusions... aaaaaaaaarghhh...
Have you found the answers yet?
I am very confused by this, and i think i will die before knowing the truths
Please if you know the answers to this topic, i really need it

Like sister a_user already asked, what is exactly what you are confused about?
This question is relevant because the topic is huge.
I think you just don't have enough information to see the whole picture...there are some gaps in your general knowledge about Islaam that creates confusion.
Read and investigate more and I'm sure your confusion will slowly go away.
The things that are unclear you could ask here and we can look at it together.

Right now I want to say that humans are all different and they undergo different tests. individuals that are strong, usually undergo a heavier test and weaker individuals undergo a lighter test.
No one will get a heavier burden than he/she can carry.

This of course results in an unjust world...but this world being unjust has nothing to do with Allah being unjust...those are two separate things.
depending how you have done your test in this world, you will get your reward, and that compensates the unjustness of this world more than enough.
 
Aoa. I didnt know it is limited to dua only. Howeber i do believe if u think اللہ is unfair, then things become unfair and unjust.
But thanku
 
Aoa. I didnt know it is limited to dua only. Howeber i do believe if u think اللہ is unfair, then things become unfair and unjust.
But thanku

Yes...things SEEMS to become unfair...you just earned that because you were thinking bad about Allah...so in the end it is still fair.

Allah is never unfair...if something seems unfair...then it is your own fault...not Allah.
 
Posting on behalf of br. [MENTION=370]Eric H[/MENTION]

Eric H said:
is Allah really the right God?"

Allah chooses whom he wills, if you feel called towards Islam it is because Allah has first chosen you.

If you are not sure who Allah is, study and reflect on his 99 names.

May Allah bless you on your journey,
Eric
 
Aoa. We can look at it from another perspective. Fair is a relative concept.. For some it might be unfair that they get to drive a honda, while their neighbor drives a mercedes whereas works half as hard as themselves. Fair could also mean that a person gets meals twice a day.
 
Aoa. We can look at it from another perspective. Fair is a relative concept.. For some it might be unfair that they get to drive a honda, while their neighbor drives a mercedes whereas works half as hard as themselves. Fair could also mean that a person gets meals twice a day.

İ agree...however, it is only a relative concept because we live in an unfair world.
A person in this world could drive a mercedes without earning it.
So yes..."fair" is relative in this world.
İn the next world if someone is driving a "mercedes"...no one will be in the position of saying "that is unfair".
 
Alhamdulillah, I've found my own answer.
My confusion was about the ones who don't know Islam, but they are kind peoples..
I've come to the conclusion that if they try to really learn who the true God is(of course it's Allah) they will (Insha Allah) find the answer because there are many things in their bible that are not true so of course they will sometimes come up with a question, and that will lead them to Qur'an sooner or later.

Sorry for the stupid question, and thank you for your answersᕙ(@°▽°@)ᕗ
stay halal brothers, may we all go to Jannah when Allah calls us.. Aamiin...

(also "Read and investigate" will really help)
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top