AvarAllahNoor
IB Expert
- Messages
- 3,170
- Reaction score
- 257
- Gender
- Male
- Religion
- Sikhism
![]()
Muhammad (pbuh) did cause much of the world to recite the Quran though!
![]()
How was it spread throughout history though! :brother:
![]()
Muhammad (pbuh) did cause much of the world to recite the Quran though!
![]()
I don't understand how you can acknowledge him as a prophet if he contradicts sikh doctrine. How can you respect him if he teaches different things about God, which in sikh eyes is untrue about God?
How do you know the verse 'Mohammed is the only last prophet' wasn't added in by his followeres just as you claim the Bible has been altered?
If that is the case and what you believe about Gods actions, then ask yourself-why is the whole world not Muslim.
Muhammed didn't cause the world to recite naam (divine profit). For further info read the many informative posts that ppl have typed.
bhul chuk maaf
How was it spread throughout history though! :brother:
OK, this 'may' help you in understanding. You believe Jesus was a prophet, but don't accept him as God in human form, why?? You say the Bible has been changed how convenient!![]()
How do you know the verse 'Mohammed is the only last prophet' wasn't added in by his followeres just as you claim the Bible has been altered?
Through peaceful means. Majority of people converted because they knew it was the truth. Look at the conversion during the prophet PBUH's time, everybody converted out of free choice, even when people (old and young) would know if they converted they would face persecution and starvation. look at indonesia, look at the western world today, where is the sword today forcing people to convert. People are converting out of their own free choice.
It is, simply because of such a belief that some Religious belief works against the constantly being reminded of any specific individual. This fits within the same teaching as not worshiping idols. Yet both warn also against worship of false prophets. I was postulating that it is possible that a figure such as Guru Ji may have been not using the personality of Mohammed in his teaching only out of deferrence. In some systems of belief it is regarded that our tendency to depend upon a single teacher's past life story can actualise delaying that such person enter Jannah. I do not know if this is the case with Guru Ji, he could as easily be establishing himself falsely by not placing his own teaching under that of Mohammed
well now, I am finding my self only able to believe in the worth of Guru Nanak (Dev Ji). Could it be that he received in Prayer that it was permitted for him to present himself as an adequate alternative to Mohammed to profess Faith within the teaching of, and because he himself is a believer in Qur'an. But that he lived at a time in which there were disputes between the Religious tradtions existant in India shows that in Allah he could have been accepting upon his own self the comprehension that it was more important at that time for Peace to exist, than that a perfect form of Islam be adhered to. So therefore we can all accept, that if indeed, as the case seems to quite obviously evidence, Guru Nanak is of Mujahideen, then we can also assume that he under took a huge burden of responsibility in having accepted to his own account that of not fully adhereing to Islam, but in the cause of Peace. Perhaps it was that at that time in India there could not have been a definitive victory of Islam over other Hindi religious worship. But surely what is important in this whole context is that all worship in India is clearly effected positively by the fact that Islam has been the dominant Religion in India. My belief is that hearing recitation of Qur'an and reading, can make a positive impact upon the future genetics. And so long as a persons sustains belief in One God, that such a positive impact is a part of the miracle of Qur'an. If one man choses not to accord his behaviour to every available teaching of Mohammed, but sustains Faith in One God, and Faith in Qur'an, then what business it is of another man to fault him. But perhaps in that very interest of Peace, we can never know whether Guru Nanak is in fact a true follower of Mohammed. And we can know that the more closely we follow the exact teaching of Mohammed, the less sever our penalty will be through the visit in the fires of Hell before attaining Jannah.
Thankyou for those website links. (from a quick look at it is clear that Guru Nanak was able to inspire persons with the same feeling of Allah's Grace as had Mohammed been)
That is a good point that you make, that for any religious teacher to be true, their cause must be in a true calling received in prayer and not in circumstances.
Can you relate what the connection is between the Guru Gobind Singh Ji that you quote from above, and the Guru Singh whom passed away fairly recently and was the leader of the "Know Yourself as Soul" foundation. They have a meditation group near to where I live that I have attended twice, after finding some work in that tradition in a second hand bookshop. It was most illuminating upon the matter of defining Karma.
mohsin is trying to say, why dont you believe in the prophet, because god didnt send down different prophets for different people, they were all trying to bring the same message! we believ that the message of other prophets before prophet muhammed (pbuh) were changed and prophet muhammed did state he was the last prophet so do you think he was lying or is the quran not completely the word of god as that also states that he is the last prophet!
yeah...if guru nanek says that muhammad was indeed a prophet of god, why don't you accept what he says? and he said that he was the last prophet, and no new faith/religion would come after him.
that is the question every muslim has been asking to the sikhs on this forum, but it is failed to be answered, instead, the response you get is some verses from the sggs.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.