Moroccan wins Iran's Holocaust Cartoon Contest

Status
Not open for further replies.
Of the two offended groups, the Jews certainly showed more wisdom in their response than did the Muslims.
 
Muhammad said:
:sl:

It is best not to paste or post links to the picture that was drawn, as this is likely to cause offence to our Jewish members here and perhaps others too. If it were the Danish caricatures, any links would not be allowed. Similarly, it is befitting for us to be respectful in this regard.
Click to expand...

Very respectful Muhammad.

All this cartoon business is really quite stupid. Making offensive cartoons about the muslim prophet. Going beserk about the cartoons and rioting. Holding a contest in retaliation. It's all stupid, just a waste of energy. Cartoons. Silly drawings. Offensive? Sure, maybe. Just silly drawings though. Sticks and stones people, sticks and stones.
 
Joe98 said:
Have you seen those cartoons yourself?
Click to expand...
Do you need to see cartoons denying the Holocaust in order to condemn them?

Cartoons like those in the Holocaust Cartoon contest should be criticised on a conceptual level. They are needlessly and deeply offensive to members of the Jewish faith.

Similarly, those Danish cartoons were deeply offensive to members of the Islamic faith. Opening this Holocaust Cartoon Contest is a classic example of two wrongs not making a right.
 
Muhammad said:
:sl:

It is best not to paste or post links to the picture that was drawn, as this is likely to cause offence to our Jewish members here and perhaps others too. If it were the Danish caricatures, any links would not be allowed. Similarly, it is befitting for us to be respectful in this regard.
Click to expand...

Good.... mocking holocaust is like mocking humanity...
 
blunderbus said:
Of the two offended groups, the Jews certainly showed more wisdom in their response than did the Muslims.
Click to expand...

ummm theres a BIG difference between cartoons of a Prophet and cartoon of a holocaust....
 
amani said:
ummm theres a BIG difference between cartoons of a Prophet and cartoon of a holocaust....
Click to expand...

There certainly is. From the perspective of many, many people the holocaust cartoons are much more offensive.
 
GARY said:
There certainly is. From the perspective of many, many people the holocaust cartoons are much more offensive.
Click to expand...

i dont deny the holocaust cartoons were wrong however you cannot throw petrol on some flames and blame the fire for erupting....
 
What is more offensive, rationally speaking? The insulting of Muhammad, or any prophet, or the insulting of the murders of 6 million innocent people?

If you sit down and think about it?
 
stannis said:
What is more offensive, rationally speaking? The insulting of Muhammad, or any prophet, or the insulting of the murders of 6 million innocent people?

If you sit down and think about it?
Click to expand...

You obviously have no idea how much the Prophet (sal-Allahu 'alayhi wa sallam) means to Muslims. I'm not defending the holocaust cartoons, not at all. I think they are disgusting. But you have to be Muslim to understand just how much those cartoons hurt us.

-Peace
 
With respect, Muhammad does not equal 6 million men, women and children.
 
So it is alright to kill millions of people, as not making pictures of Muhammad is worth more than human lives?
 
Many Muslims seem to find the Holocaust cartoons amusing, as a counter-attack on the Danish cartoons and perhaps because they are anti-Jewish. This in itself shows a lack of respect for human life - millions of Jews died, and Muslims are willing to mock that.
 
stannis said:
Many Muslims seem to find the Holocaust cartoons amusing, as a counter-attack on the Danish cartoons and perhaps because they are anti-Jewish. This in itself shows a lack of respect for human life - millions of Jews died, and Muslims are willing to mock that.
Click to expand...

I already told you I thought the cartoons were disgusting, and quite a few people have said this aswell. So please stop generalising.

Anyway, you didn't answer my question. Who said:

it is alright to kill millions of people, as not making pictures of Muhammad is worth more than human lives?
Click to expand...

It seems like you just want to keep presenting Muslims in a bad light. So I doubt we'll have a productive discussion.
 
I already told you I thought the cartoons were disgusting, and quite a few people have said this aswell. So please stop generalising.
Click to expand...

I apologise for my misconception : embarrass Should have paid more attention.
 
stannis said:
Many Muslims seem to find the Holocaust cartoons amusing, as a counter-attack on the Danish cartoons and perhaps because they are anti-Jewish. This in itself shows a lack of respect for human life - millions of Jews died, and Muslims are willing to mock that.
Click to expand...

You dont understand. I am not in favor of the Holocaust cartoons nor do i support them, but to bellitle our Prophet isnt something nice, even if you say "With respect". So we thank you for your opinion on this matter.

Our opinion is in terms of value, yes we value the life of the Messenger of God over all of humanity and of the entire world and everything in it.

:w:
 
Ähmed said:
Our opinion is in terms of value, yes we value the life of the Messenger of God over all of humanity and of the entire world and everything in it.

:w:
Click to expand...

It would seem that you have raised your prophet from being a man to more than man, worthy of worship. Does this please God?
 
GARY said:
It would seem that you have raised your prophet from being a man to more than man, worthy of worship. Does this please God?
Click to expand...


We love the messenger of Allaah, and choose to obey him. We obey him because he brought the message, and if it wasn't for the guidance that he recieved from Allaah - we would be misguided.

We love him for the sake of Allaah, because he brought us closer to Allaah through the message. The love of Allaah is a divine love all muslims should have above anything else, and anything that Allaah sends (i.e. prophets) are all loved for the sake of Allaah and not as equals to Allah. They were the one's whom Allaah loves, and they are those whom Allaah Almighty chose out of His Eternal Wisdom. So we love them purely for the sake of Allaah Almighty.




Peace.
 
GARY said:
It would seem that you have raised your prophet from being a man to more than man, worthy of worship. Does this please God?
Click to expand...

It is ironic that a Christian would accuse a muslim of this when they have raised Jesus from being a man to "more than a man, worthy of worship" as the son of God! God is above all that they ascribe to Him.

Br. Fi Sabillilah has answered your inquiry.

I think this thread has served its purpose, hence

:threadclo
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top