north_malaysian
IB Legend
- Messages
- 8,215
- Reaction score
- 831
OK, I try.
I Prefer Kari kambing, ayam, udang.
Ok, Saya cuba.
Saya lebih gemarkan kari kambing, ayam dan udang.
OK, I try.
I Prefer Kari kambing, ayam, udang.
LOL...
i think I is saya...wots like in malay? saya.....Kari ketam and notKari kambing...lol, ayam,dan lain-lain...
how do u say and in malay?.......
Gelak terbahak-bahak...
;D ;D ;D
i don't know why...i think that is funny
(saya tidak tahu mengapa...saya rasa kelakar)
ketam is crab i think.
Ketam = Crab
Ada dua jenis ketam:
There are two kind of crabs:
1) Ketam yang hanya hidup di air
2) Crab that live in the water
2) Ketam yang hidup di darat dan di air
Crab that live on both land and water
Muslimin di Malaysia bermazhab Shafi'i, di mana semua hidupan yang 100% hidup di air halal dimakan.
Muslims in Malaysia are Shafiites, which all living things that live 100% in the water are halal to be eaten.
indon panggil ketam = kepiting
(we call ketam as kepiting)
ketam mana-mana pun halal kat sini
(both crabs are halal here)
Kenapa dhulqarneen tanya sama ada ketam itu halal atau tidak?
Then, why dhulqarneen asked whether crabs are halal or not?
Kenapa dhulqarneen tanya sama ada ketam itu halal atau tidak?
Then, why dhulqarneen asked whether crabs are halal or not?
Memang ada mazhab yang mengharamkan makan ketam... mungkin hanafi.
There is a mazhab prohibiting us from eating crab... might be Hanafite
Manakala pengikut mazhab Syiah Ismailiyah Bohra, semua haiwan mestilah disembelih sebelum makan .... tapi, macam mana nak sembelih ketam?^o)
Meanwhile the followers of Bohra Ismailite Shiite mazhab, all animals must be slaughtered before eating them... but, how to slaughter a crab?^o)
Rasanya sebab ada ikhtilaf ulama mengenai perkara ni kan....
I think it's because there is a difference of ulama about this
Saya tak berapa ingat madhab apa yang mengharamkan ketam....hanafi kot? :?
I dont really remember which madhab makes it haram to eat crab...hanafi maybe?
Allahu A3lam.......saya memang suka makan ketam....but i'm allergic to itI'm allergic to any shell foods actually
![]()
![]()
Tak pedulilah which mahdhab kan? ^o) Maybe theres fatawa from ulama salaf mutaakhireen about this matter ukhti, please bring it on insha Allah :shade:
And ana heran, its ajeeb (ajaib) Abu Hanifah (Hanafi) can said ketam itu haram. Cause I doubt theres ketam in Arab that time ;D apelagi ketam yang hanye hidup di air, mencari air ajee sulit bukan main di arab, nii mencari ketam yang hidup di air pulak :happy: Isnt it?
Rasanya sebab ada ikhtilaf ulama mengenai perkara ni kan....
I think it's because there is a difference of ulama about this
Saya tak berapa ingat madhab apa yang mengharamkan ketam....hanafi kot? :?
I dont really remember which madhab makes it haram to eat crab...hanafi maybe?
Allahu A3lam.......saya memang suka makan ketam....but i'm allergic to itI'm allergic to any shell foods actually
![]()
my mother make lovely steamed sweet sour crab...nyum nyum...
(mak saya masak masam manis ketam kukus yang lazat)
![]()
You see the eyes of the ketam bro...thats the place you should sembelih I think ;D You made me laugh hard enough :happy: macam-macam ajee you niii akhi.
And naam, ana dengar kite tak boleh makan haiwan yang hidup di dua alam, please bring the hadith about this insha Allah. tuu kenape ana tanya apa halal memakan ketam.
But, seperti yang bro north ucapkan, memang ade dua macam ketam, yang hidup di air ajee and hidup di dua alam right. BUT maybe ade 4 macam ketam lah, ketam yang hidup di air ajee, and then ketam yang hidup di dua alam, and then ketam hitam and ketam putih which we eat with durian ;D .......its ketan I think and not ketam.
Memang ada mazhab yang mengharamkan makan ketam... mungkin hanafi.
There is a mazhab prohibiting us from eating crab... might be Hanafite
Manakala pengikut mazhab Syiah Ismailiyah Bohra, semua haiwan mestilah disembelih sebelum makan .... tapi, macam mana nak sembelih ketam?^o)
Meanwhile the followers of Bohra Ismailite Shiite mazhab, all animals must be slaughtered before eating them... but, how to slaughter a crab?^o)
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.