Won't you participate in my experiment please?

  • Thread starter Thread starter جوري
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 140
  • Views Views 18K

Would you choose to live forever?


  • Total voters
    0
Live forever? Thats more of a curse than a blessing. I don't want to live forever on earth and I certainly don't want to live forever in this heaven place I keep hearing about. After just a few milenia I think I'd go stir crazy and wish it to end.
 
If living forever on earth means you can skip judgement day than I wouldn't mind living on earth forever. If your family and friends could live forever too, if you could live in health and not worry about getting old etc. then life on earth wouldn't be so bad. Probably because I haven't been the best follower of my religion and I fear of being punished of sins...
 
I certainly don't want to live forever in this heaven place I keep hearing about. After just a few milenia I think I'd go stir crazy and wish it to end.
:sl:
Part of being in Heaven is that you do not experience any sadness, you and everybody else would be happy all the time. Thus, you would not get bored or tired of it in the same way that we do on Earth.
:w:
 
Is there such thing as jealousy in heaven? What happens if you are in heaven and two people are in love with the same person (a love triangle) wouldn't that cause jealousy and conflict etc? kind of a silly/off topic question...
 
. If your family and friends could live forever too, if you could live in health and not worry about getting old etc. then life on earth wouldn't be so bad. ...
Yup, family, friends, advancement, books, change, new good things, space exploration, travel, books, movies, music.. I don't see how a non deist could possibly want to turn down such an offer?

:w:
 
I might want to...



...if I stay young-looking and beautiful. :D lol

Someone said "it's bad 'cause you'd sin more", but I might have a more idealistic perspective on this, I think one could do more good in this time... Engage yourself fully in the Deen.

Live a 'normal life' until the people of my generation die, be as a guide for the granchildren that exist, learn from great scholars, then go somewhere all alone place and live in total solitarity, only surrounded my great books of faith etc. become a hermit forever, whom wanderers meet and are amazed by...


But of course, as a Muslim, I do believe even if you'd attain something near immortality, you'd still be kicked to the Hereafter.


Hmm, I'm confused what to vote. :skeleton:
 
Yup, family, friends, advancement, books, change, new good things, space exploration, travel, books, movies, music.. I don't see how a non deist could possibly want to turn down such an offer?

:w:

If I knew I was going straight to heaven that would be different. If I was offered life on earth vs not knowing where I am going after death I choose my mundane life over there being a slightest chance that I'm gonna spend anytime in hell
 
:sl: ''Kulu nafsindaa iqatul mawt'' - Verily every soul shall taste death.

Like sis Ayesha said, I'd like to keep my life the way that Allaah Ta'ala intended it to be, so therefore I wouldn't participate.
 
It makes room.

look at all that unexplored space.. people can set up life else where.. just the pleasure of getting there and finding out new life and if you can co-exist.. new machines for inter-planetary travel .. never having to know loss of family or friends.. always learning, getting new degrees, enough time to see all your off spring and their off spring without ever getting old or tiring, endless days at the beach or in your beach cabin
NorthMyrtleBeach1992-1.jpg

6397_tn_winter%20beach.jpg


tons of travel.. I don't see how this could be an offer for anyone to refuse unless there really was another purpose to life and death..

cheers
 
Last edited:
Everything else does, especially when it is a global experience, as in skips no one, much like the need to eat or pee or sleep...



I agree

And agree with that too...


peace!

everything may have a purpose but we are not able to know the reasons for everything.
i have been privileged to be born in a prosperous and relatively free country. i've never gone hungry and i've never had to live through the horrors of war. very few on the planet have this luxury. for this i thank god, but at some point, it is enough.
this reminds me of the saying "be careful what you wish for - you may get it.
 
this reminds me of the saying "be careful what you wish for - you may get it.

It isn't my wish to be honest.. I suspect that the poll wouldn't really give me an honest estimate, given the pool of people are more religious than not...
But, how many times have I heard the statements 'I hate aging' --'wish I had a chance to go back and do things differently, 'wish I could freeze this moment forever' our mortality undoubtedly plays a large part in our approach to how we live and perceive our existence ...
this thread was really inspired by the ' in paradise, now what?'..

It is because we experience a myriad of emotions that we can differentiate between them and select the few that are endearing to wrap ourselves in their memory ... I don't think many appreciate that it is part of the way we were created---it is because we experience, aging, boredom, disease, debt, depression, that we understand excitement, youth, riches, health.. and we aspire for all of those most of our lives, I know because of the billions spent on the beauty and plastic surgery industry.. people spend their youth working, so they can earn money, to have some in the bank for that retirement home, some for a jar of anti-wrinkle cream, a bottle of hair dye or even plastic surgery if need be, and an occasional trip abroad, a good holiday time with the family, new clothes to buy.. but we experience so much unpleasantness for so few moments of rejoicing and happiness and it is in that contrast to the others unpleasant emotions that makes the good ones so real and actual for us.

But that is all we know.... if God were to communicate with us with what we know of happiness it would be to recapture that which we as humans find most pleasant. How else can we make a contrast? It is in health, eternal youth, family, friends, warmth, streams and meadows that we find our happiness here...

How else to communicate to us when there are no words to describe to conjure up an image of that which no eyes have seen nor ears have heard nor ever occurred to 'the human mind' to what do we compare it to? There is no contrast to what we don't know...

A different creation will not need nor have a reason to be bound by earthly conditions.. We are what we are if we see a different face in the mirror by morning from disease or a burn, or amputation of even a fabulous new body...what is inside of us remains and goes and can most definitely go on to better... Anyhow this was pre-mature a conclusion, as I was hoping to hear some from those who have chosen the other options..

thank you though to all the participants..

peace
 
Nah...no thanks.

this world is becoming too expensive to live in and too polluted to.

i don't think i'll be happy to live forever...lol
 
what about on another planet?-- no pollution, reasonably priced, and they want earthly immigrants you know for exhange of ideas, rise of new civilizations hybridization etc and it was beautiful, just breath taking?
some four brave souls voted non-conventionally.. but they don't want to come forth to talk about it.......... hmmmmmmmn ;D

:w:
 
the thing is i'm too lazy :X.

i'm a very simple lady...not that motivated though :hiding:

:D
 
Well since ' Every soul shall have a taste of death in the end to Us shall ye be brought back. 29:57" then living forever isnt and option. But I would try it for a little bit to keep living some extra years. I'd just go for Hajj for a last time then I'd get bored of life and stop taking then booster. But I wouldn't want to live forever. No way.
 
i dont want to live forever... i want to die as Allah wants, i hope i die in the best emaan...ameen

live forever wouldn't be exciting, the earth is already full of human, disasters and i think like what prophet has said, the day of judgement is coming...
 
If living forever on earth means you can skip judgement day than I wouldn't mind living on earth forever. If your family and friends could live forever too, if you could live in health and not worry about getting old etc. then life on earth wouldn't be so bad. Probably because I haven't been the best follower of my religion and I fear of being punished of sins...
If I knew I was going straight to heaven that would be different. If I was offered life on earth vs not knowing where I am going after death I choose my mundane life over there being a slightest chance that I'm gonna spend anytime in hell
I voted no, because I presupposed that I would be going to Heaven after my death. These posts puts things in a competely different light. If I knew that my place in the Hereafter was in fact the Hellfire for eternity, then I would definitely choose, "Yes , sign me up for eternity!" If I knew that I would eventually be brought out of the Hellfire before entering Heaven, then "No, I wouldn't participate."
 
Last edited:
I voted no. I have no urge do live on this planet for eternity. Allah (swt) does not have that plan for me.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top