Permissibility of Nasheeds

sisters thats sad i look at nasheeds as the nasheed singers spreading dawa i think saying they arent permissible is too extreme but Allah knows best

asalaamualaikum sisters do not worry allah will grant u something much better than nasheeds!!! u shud thank allah that you are not listening to that which COULD in the slightest lead to sin, as some nasheed singers begin using music and the like after some 'record breaking albums', pathetic, and their loyal 'fans' begin thinking that this nasheed singer is now a 'sheikh' or a scholar, and begin saying that musical instruments are halaal just because their beloved 'icon' uses it. astaghfirullah its a sad state of affairs. also, the extent that artists go to e.g. creating foto albums of themselves on sites, posing for the camera so that the opposite sex talks about them (this may nt be their intention but it is what it leads to) and then their loyal fans go right out of their way, and create a FAN CLUB site for them may allah save us from this fitnah. zina and the toy of shaytaan i.e. musical instruments all in one

but anyway, once more, imy advice wud be to thank allah swt for the glorious quran, focus on that, as ur brother sys poetry is good, so u cud begin revealing ur talents and writin your very own poetry perhaps one day u cud even compile an islamic poetry book inshallah! i dont mean to sound blatant sisters, but quite frankly you dont miss out on a WHOLE lot when it comes to nasheeds. its a time pass in a way. and secondly its far better to just, GET ON and listen to what ur bro says since he duz seem to have the 'say' in this issue lol, than to wish you cud listen to them and long for something wich u may/may not achieve dont mean to sound mean, but i didnt know how else to put it sisters lol.

nasheeds are simply a 'time-pass', we dont need them, we can live without them, and we can practice islam just as well, without them walaikumussalam

format_quote Originally Posted by Ukhti_TM

sisters thats sad i look at nasheeds as the nasheed singers spreading dawa i think saying they arent permissible is too extreme but Allah knows best

Subhanallah sis. that's what i said to him. He just doesn't listen and since he is elder than me i should respect his orders.

format_quote Originally Posted by HumbleServant

asalaamualaikum sisters do not worry allah will grant u something much better than nasheeds!!! u shud thank allah that you are not listening to that which COULD in the slightest lead to sin, as some nasheed singers begin using music and the like after some 'record breaking albums', pathetic, and their loyal 'fans' begin thinking that this nasheed singer is now a 'sheikh' or a scholar, and begin saying that musical instruments are halaal just because their beloved 'icon' uses it. astaghfirullah its a sad state of affairs. also, the extent that artists go to e.g. creating foto albums of themselves on sites, posing for the camera so that the opposite sex talks about them (this may nt be their intention but it is what it leads to) and then their loyal fans go right out of their way, and create a FAN CLUB site for them may allah save us from this fitnah. zina and the toy of shaytaan i.e. musical instruments all in one

but anyway, once more, imy advice wud be to thank allah swt for the glorious quran, focus on that, as ur brother sys poetry is good, so u cud begin revealing ur talents and writin your very own poetry perhaps one day u cud even compile an islamic poetry book inshallah! i dont mean to sound blatant sisters, but quite frankly you dont miss out on a WHOLE lot when it comes to nasheeds. its a time pass in a way. and secondly its far better to just, GET ON and listen to what ur bro says since he duz seem to have the 'say' in this issue lol, than to wish you cud listen to them and long for something wich u may/may not achieve dont mean to sound mean, but i didnt know how else to put it sisters lol.

nasheeds are simply a 'time-pass', we dont need them, we can live without them, and we can practice islam just as well, without them walaikumussalam

Thanks very much sis. I will take the advice. After all "Advice is like snow, The softer it falls, the longer it dwells upon, and the deeper it sinks into the mind." I apreciate all of your comments and thoughts. Jazaakalhu'kayran.

format_quote Originally Posted by junna1

:'( You are all sooo lucky you can listen to it. I heard it before, but my brother believes its haram so he won't let me listen to nasheeds no more and I love that song sooooooooooo much. This is his computer you know. :mad: :'( I cry for nasheeds day and night. Oooooooooh the horror of not being able to listen to nasheeds. Especially Zain and Kamal Uddin(they are my favorites ) and Dawud and Yusuf Islam and oooooooh I can't list them all. :'(

The names you listed are all permissable, and I don't think there is any dispute of scholars on this because none of them use forbidden instruments. For this reason, it is not right for someone to declare them categorically haraam.

I think nasheeds without music or drums are permissible. Duff(drum) is only allowed on weddings for ladies only, well that's what I heard and read and I also think they become haram when you listen to them too much. I used to listen to too much nasheeds and when he stopped me from it I listen to Quran more alhamdulillah, but I don't think that its fair for him to stop me from nasheeds completely. He should allow us to listen to it sometimes, but he will never do that cause he thinks they are haram and he will never change his mind about that. I am glad he is helping us out, but sometimes he should let us have our own choices because Allah gave us choices too.

Jazaakalahu'kayran for sharing that. very very useful to me.

Jazakallahu khayran for posting that. It is very true. I guess it is good that my brother won't let us listen to nasheeds cause he says it's bid'ah. Madeenahsh are you a salafee? My brothers are, that's why they don't listen to nasheeds.

Jazakallah for that great article!

As-Salaamu 'Alaykum Wa Rahmatullaahi Wa Barakaatuh,

Baaraka-Allaahu Feekum madeenahsh for the reminder.
May Allaah reward you for your intentions, Aameen.

format_quote Originally Posted by junna1

Madeenahsh are you a salafee? My brothers are, that's why they don't listen to nasheeds.

You're cute Masha-Allaah.
May Allaah always protect you, Aameen.

'Alaykum As-Salaam Wa Rahmatullaahi Wa Barakaatuh.

salam
jazakallah sis for sharing that, it was very useful