Hadith Challenge . . .

I've got loads of questions, so there's nothing to worry about . . .

Umar bin al-Khataab narrate's a hadith to two people who come to him (topic: regarding the issue of knowledge and leadership): "man kuntu maula, fa 'aliu maula". Where is this hadith?

format_quote Originally Posted by Muslim_brother

Ahmed what do you mean where is this hadeeth, Do you mean who narrated it, or you mean ist in Muslim or Bukhaari? Can you clrify the question akhi Filaah, May Allah reard you for it, amiin amiin

Your brother in islaam

Welcome to the Forum . . .

I noticed you are not very familiar with how we go about the hadith challenge; basically all types of questions are put forward as a challenge, and the one who answers them correctly get's rep points. As for this question; all you need to do is write the hadith reference . . . Insha-Allah . . .

You will find that I gave the clue by slipping it into the thread about Ali bin Abi Talib (as) . . .

A second clue:

It's not in "A complete idiots guide to using computers" . . .

format_quote Originally Posted by amani

ermmmmmm im still looking
though does it continue to

the Prophet saying
`oh Allah. love those who love ali and be hostile to those who are hostile to ali`?

*totally unsure*


still searching

That's not quite the translation of the narration in my question, keep looking Insha-Allah . . .

format_quote Originally Posted by amani

who I am their Masterful Gentleman or (Mawla) is ' Ali also its Gentleman or Teacher (Mawla


this? :S

Very good indeed; it is "for whomsoever I am a Master, then Ali is his Master", so now I think it should be a little bit easier to find Insha-Allah . . .

format_quote Originally Posted by amani

give up

cnt find :S

:applaud: Good effort; I'll give it another day or two Insha-Allah. If no-one answer's it, then I'll write-up the answer . . .

Here's a link you can use for a little bit of help on finding the answer:

http://www.alltheweb.com/search?cat=...&_sb_lang=pref

Please make good use of it . . .

format_quote Originally Posted by amani

ok umm is it in kanzul ulum ummul somthing like that?

:zip: Do you mean kanzul amal?

It's actually in Tareekh al-kabeer, Musnad Ahmad, and a few other books . . .

Well therer you go; I had to give the answer: 36 points to you . . .

Next question:

Qaal rasolullah (saw): "ana daarul-hikmah wa aliun-baabuhaa" aina?

(Where is this hadith; which book?)

format_quote Originally Posted by amani

hmm i know there is one similiar in saheeh tirmidhi
i am city of knowledge and ali is its gate?
right?

The translation you have given is WRONG; however your reference is correct . . . :applaud: :applaud: :applaud: :applaud: :applaud: :applaud: :applaud: :applaud:


NEXT QUESTION:

Where is the hadith you translated (Clue: It's not in tirmithi) . . .

Second Clue: It's not in Bukhari or Muslim . . .