I am a recent convert and my understanding is that all music is forbidden "anything with an instrument". I can understand "anything with lyrics", but I am having trouble understanding. Then I find stuff like "hip hop with an Islamic message". On that same note, how can something instrumental be construed as something for/against Allah on its own? I guess what I am saying, wouldn't it be more important the intent of the singer/speaker/musician? My question is, if something (for example, a song) is written to glorify Islam and Allah, why is it forbidden? On that same thread, I suppose it would be like saying "I am going to get drunk for the name of God", i.e. that you cannot do something that is forbidden, even to attempt to praise Allah.
Secondly, if not all music is forbidden, are there any songs that complement the studying the Quaran? Excuse me if this is inappropriate and/or insulting to even ask.
You are right in saying that intention is important, and indeed it takes precedence over action. However, intention alone is not enough of a prerequisite to perform an action. We would also need the proper knowledge. So always keep in mind the importance of Intention (niyyah), Knowledge (ilm), and Action/Practice ('amal).
In regards to music, I don't believe I am qualified to be giving you any advice on that matter
You are right in saying that intention is important, and indeed it takes precedence over action. However, intention alone is not enough of a prerequisite to perform an action. We would also need the proper knowledge. So always keep in mind the importance of Intention (niyyah), Knowledge (ilm), and Action/Practice ('amal).
In regards to music, I don't believe I am qualified to be giving you any advice on that matter
Perhaps what the Quaran says about niyyah is where I should begin looking for answers. Thanks hulk for guiding me that way!
We have a number of threads providing details on this issue, but currently it is difficult to find them as the forum was recently upgraded. Here is one thread but it is quite long and detailed: http://www.islamicboard.com/forum/le...ran-and-sunnah
You will note that there are many things that have to be considered when finding answers, and it is often not as simple as finding a verse in the Qur'an. We have to also look at the teachings of the Prophet , amongst other things. If the issue is causing you confusion, focus on building the foundation first - learn about the Islamic creed and the pillars of Islam and eemaan. As you do this, (if Allah wills) everything else will fall into place. Take things one step at a time.
Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
When you create an account, we remember exactly what you've read, so you always come right back where you left off. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and share your thoughts. Sign Up
, amongst other things. If the issue is causing you confusion, focus on building the foundation first - learn about the Islamic creed and the pillars of Islam and eemaan. As you do this,
(if Allah wills) everything else will fall into place. Take things one step at a time.
Hide
Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks