Is it permissible for the one who follows the Imaam in the Taraweeh prayer specificly, to hold the Mushaf (in his hands) in order to follow the Imaam and look within it?
Answer:
No, No, No this is not from the Sunnah...
Questioner:
Is the prayer of one who does this permissible?
Ash-Shaykh al-Albaani Rahimahullaah:
Yes, his prayer is permissible...
Questioner:
However, we say that is it in opposition to the Sunnah?
I don't get it. His prayer is permissable, but you are not allowed to hold it?!
Yes. His prayer is still valid (so he doesn't have to repeat it), but the action itself (holding the mushaf whilst following the Imaam) is not correct.
The things that invalidate the prayer are well known, but the number differs according to differences among the fuqaha’. They are as follows:
1 – That which invalidates wudoo’, such as breaking wind or eating camel meat.
2 – Uncovering the ‘awrah deliberately. But if it is uncovered by accident and what is uncovered is only a little, or if a lot becomes uncovered but he covers it immediately, then the prayer is not invalidated.
3 – Turning away from the qiblah to a large extent.
4 – Presence of najaasah (impurity) on one's body or clothes, or in the place where one is praying. If he notices it or remembers it during the prayer and removes it immediately, then his prayer is valid. Similarly, if he does not find out about it until after the prayer is over, his prayer is still valid.
5 – Excessive continuous movement during the prayer for no essential reason.
6 –Omitting one of the pillars (essential parts) of the prayer, such as bowing and prostration.
7 – Deliberately doing an extra pillar, such as bowing.
8 – Deliberately doing some pillars before others.
9 – Deliberately saying the salaam before completing the prayer.
10 – Deliberately changing the meaning whilst reciting.
11- Deliberately omitting one of the obligatory parts of prayer, such as the first tashahhud. But if a person forgets, his prayer is valid but he must do the prostration of forgetfulness (sujood al-sahw).
12 – Deciding to stop praying.
13 – Laughing out loud. Merely smiling does not invalidate the prayer.
14 – Deliberately speaking. If one speaks by mistake or out of ignorance of the ruling, the prayer is not invalidated.
15 –Eating and drinking.
See: Daleel al-Taalib li Nayl al-Mataalib by Shaykh Mar’i ibn Yoosuf al-Hanbali (p. 34). And Duroos Muhimmah by Shaykh Ibn Baaz.
So there are some things which are not correct and lessen the perfection of your prayer, such as smiling during the prayer, but do not invalidate the prayer. Allah knows best.
I find that holding the mushaf stops you doing a number of things such as looking at the place of Sujud, putting the right hand over the left hand, etc and there is that feeling of how and where to place the mushaf when you want to do sujud and or ruku'.
assalamu alykum brothers and sisters, i hope you are enjoying your ramadhan
during tarawih prayer, i stood beside along a brother whom held the quran while the imam is reciting, i think he is following through what he is reciting.
I still think the first post is mashed I see no problem with followin the Imam whilst holding the Qur'aan. People in Makkah and Madina do it, and people don't say nothing to them, so it's not a problem.
***** قال ابن أبي مليكة : أدركت ثلاثين من أصحاب النبي - صلى الله عليه وسلم - كلهم يخاف النفاق على نفسه
Ibn Abī Mulaykah said: "I encountered thirty Companions of the Prophet, every one of them fearing hypocrisy for himself." [Muslim]
If you want to find out more about this subject, just listen to the lecture by Waleed Basyouni, called 186 Rules for Ramadan
In there he mentioned that it is permissible to hold the mushaaf while praying and it doesn't invalidate your prayer, however you get less reward as the other parts of the sunnah such as placing right hand over left, looking on the spot of sujood etc. are not carried out.
it also states that for instance if the imaam asks the person behind him to correct him during taraweeh due to a weak memory or so, the requested person is able to read from the qur'an, considering that thy are not haafiz.
Wallahu A3lam
okay so what about holding mushaf during your pray.... individually at home
I think the same is applied here as well
I used to hold mushaf when I pray taraweeh alone in my room...is that invalided the salah?
Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
When you create an account, we remember exactly what you've read, so you always come right back where you left off. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and share your thoughts. Sign Up
Hide
Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks