Is fuctioning of the heart contradict between science and Islam ? (OP)
Assala mu aliqum ! my brother and sister
As per my knowledge : functioning of the heart is contradict between science and Islam .
According to science : heart is the organ which can helps to distribute blood in our body . Its act as a pumping machine . Brain is the cause for all type of emotions such as love , hate, trust , believe , angry etc .
But
According to Islam : Heart is the cause or place for all type of emotions such as love, hate , trust , believe , angry etc .
So any body can help me to remove this contradiction ? ...... Please please please ... ....
Stunningly beautiful adhaan from the Dome of the Rock in Masjid ul Aqsa Download (right click and choose "save target/link as").
This is a clear message for mankind in order that they may be warned thereby, and that they may know that He is only One God, and that those of understanding may take heed (14:52)
Indeed Allah knows, and you know not (16: 74, part)
This three links are nothing but only statements . Those statements are not approved by any modern scientific society . In this world there are many authentic scientific organizations . For example : In India AIIMS ( All Indian Institute of Medical Sciences ) , American Medical association , there are many .
I am not bother about others statements . Every body have right to speak . It does not mean speaker is always right . I hope you understand ....
Re: Is fuctioning of the heart contradict between science and Islam ?
Brother i think you are seeing a problem where there is none.
reference to the heart (broken heart, hard hearted, whole hearted) can be used in a metaphorical sense as well as the physical sense.
why?
the physical heart is probably the most important organ after the brain, it keeps us alive, it sends blood around our bodies nourishing other organs, it reacts to emotion...
ever had your heart skip a beat? ever had your heart melt?
these metaphorical expressions by no means contradict science.
and just asides...i, too, have read something to the effect that there exist 'memory cells' in the heart and that reports exist of transplant patients displaying characteristics or talents which were unique to the heart donor.
Re: Is fuctioning of the heart contradict between science and Islam ?
Assalamu Alaikum hopeonallah,
The first problem is the English language it does not have similar idioms and the richness of the ancient languages as is so with Arabic and even less with Fushat (the Arabic of the Quran). Mind you I don't speak it, but my mother tongue is as old as and has many similar saying and expressions (different language same expressions)
While you are thinking in one language it's hard to understand another so try and get into the spirit of the language and not the English equivalent words. Some explanations are as the brothers in previous post told you similar to English.
When you hear that memorising is from the chest you assume the heart "Qalb" where as the reference is to the "Fuad" the heart of the soul.
For when you die you body disintegrates along with your organs, but the spiritual self was there before you where born and still there after you're gone. The essence of you is in that "Fuad" pains, sorrows, sins, knowledge all.
The same applies for the brain its neurons, nerves and what have you, what it is not, it's not a recorder of your life that would be the "Fuad" again.
I and millions of others wish it was only the brain so when the worms ate it our bad self would vanish also but alas it ain't so.
So back to the verses such as "sealed their harts" would again reffer to unfeeling as the heart the emotional center which again could only be the "Fuad". The Quran was delivered to the prophet s.a.w's heart ?
You may ask why then does not Allah S.W.T just make it clear ?
There are of course many many theories but the best answer would be that He chose not to and He surely knows best.
You could to look at the Tafsir of those verses to get a analogy of different ways to accept the same.
Another point I would like to make that a lot of people say that this "Fuad" thing is from Sufis if that be true then what better explanation can they offer and mind you it would have to be in the realms of what would have been acceptable to those past generations as well. The truth does not change only perceptions do.
One last thing too, that the heart muscle as it may be and a pump it gets damaged from emotional stress does it not and it cant just be pumping issues otherwise athletes would die from stress; and a final neurological truth about the brain's true main function take a look at diagram of the body and see where the majority of these neurons end up. I'm sure then you will see the irony !
In today's world some of us place our hopes in science for they may find a solution that suits the hopes of our sinful self.
I hope I've not confused you more in my attempt to keep this brief,
Masalam
PS: The true mistery lies in how the one heart (physical) relates to the other (spiritual)
Hey there! Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
When you create an account, we remember exactly what you've read, so you always come right back where you left off. You also get notifications, here and via email, whenever new posts are made. And you can like posts and share your thoughts.
Sign Up
Bookmarks