Yeah I grew up listening to Ahmed Deedat (Even though I may not have understood) I remember I was so upset at his passing. SubhanAllah... Both are good masha'Allah
Yes, He is a great speaker
No, I don't completely agree with him
Seems like when it comes to the methods of Daawah by Dr Zakir Naik people seem to have mixed feelings.
Some people love him and some hate him.
I personally admire his efforts.
Although I am a much bigger fan of Sheikh Ahmad Deedat. He was such a powerful speaker.
Mashallah, both are very good speakers
As I have hardly heard any Ahmed Deedat lectures, I have the utmost respect for Dr. Zakir Naik.
Yes Definitely
Dr Naik is one of my best masha allah
may allah bless that man
If anyone has not seen the Sheikh Ahmad Deedat Vs Brother Swaggart debate then you are missing out bigtime!!! Beats watching a Hollywood action thriller hands down
Do a search on Google Videos for it. Get some pop corn. You will be gripped when he starts to speak
Ahmed Deedat and Shorrosh!format_quote Originally Posted by Hamayun
If anyone has not seen the Sheikh Ahmad Deedat Vs Brother Swaggart debate then you are missing out bigtime!!! Beats watching a Hollywood action thriller hands down
Do a search on Google Videos for it. Get some pop corn. You will be gripped when he starts to speak
Yep zakir naik is great!! I do not understand why some people hate him, u cnt blame him for the accent he has!
Ahmed Deedat was a great speaker and had some truly great debates, but his approach was more aggressive and in your face.
Dr Naik is more subtle in his approach but is equally talented, and more importantly for the modern age, he is able to give dawah to athiests.
I won't even start on this thread :X though I should advice you that he is not reliable.
I am off to search for that right nowformat_quote Originally Posted by JσℓιєFℓєυяAhmed Deedat and Shorrosh!
There are several articles I have seen while searching google about Dr Zakir Naik with a heading "Zakir Naik is a Kafir" :Xformat_quote Originally Posted by raOnar
Yep zakir naik is great!! I do not understand why some people hate him, u cnt blame him for the accent he has!
There are many Muslims who say he is misleading people and mis-representing Islam.
SixTen can you please tell us why you think that?
Last edited by Hamayun; 10-02-2008 at 03:14 PM.
format_quote Originally Posted by HamayunI am off to search for that right now
There are several articles I have seen about Dr Zakir Naik with a heading "Zakir Naik is a Kafir" :X
There are many Muslims who say he is misleading people and mis-representing Islam.
These accusations are more fact than you may give it credit for.
SixTen could you back that up? Otherwise do no make comments like that!
format_quote Originally Posted by SixTenCan you please explain what you mean by thatformat_quote Originally Posted by SixTen
format_quote Originally Posted by SixTen
If you are a Muslim, then respect Zakir Naik. If you aren't, respect him anyway. The amount of knowledge and debates he has done, and the amount of people he has converted to Islaam, I doubt you would be even equal to an inch of that.
May Allaah sort your mind out, Ameen.
Assalamu Alaikum
I have never heard Dr Zakir Naik say anything that would be against Islam. I don't understand what people mean when they accuse him of being a Kafir?
Exactly, the only people who might not like him are those who debate agianst him.format_quote Originally Posted by HamayunI have never heard Dr Zakir Naik say anything that would be against Islam. I don't understand what people mean when they accuse him of being a Kafir?
his knowledge alone is great marshaallah even my husband who perfers to stick to the scholars of knowledge such as sheikh fowzaan, sheikh bin bazz sheikh al-albanne and so on even like to listen to dr zakir naik and we also listen to Ahmed deedat i think its good that they they both have there own way of giving dawah as some times different ways of dawah work better for different people
dr. Zakir Naik is one of the best , even tho i didnt understand him in the beginning cuz of his accent :X but i got used to it MashaAllah
and Ahmed Deedat .....He was Great MashaAllah!
May Allah be pleased with him !
first of all, before we say anythin to scholars, we need to remember they are scholars and they have much more knowlegde then us nobooodiessss!
secondly the Yazeed issue, imam ghazali, who is really respected amongst many muslims, even gave a fatwa along the lines of the claims which were made againist yazeed, are false and have not been proven, and he said its mustahab to say Radi-Allah-Anhu for him, and you an check this fatwa up in his books!
and sheikh ibn taymiyyah, said its not right to curse him
also dont believe the shia events of karbala, Yazeed wasnt even present in karbala, he was in syria, so we cant blame him for somethin which is not proven, so its best not to speak about someone without knowlegde
personally, i think zakir naik is thaaa man
Jaa-Ro-Nee-Mo!!!SMILE
Hide
Looks like you're enjoying the discussion, but you're not signed up for an account.
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks