Non mahrams Salam

[sirajstc]

i hav heard dat wen a nön mehram gives a muslim sister salam, she is not supposed to giv salam back.since v meet a lot of non mehram brothers,how do v greet them bck da salam?pls enlighten me about who nd all cn b cald as our mehram nd wit da knowledge of islam

:rolleyes::rolleyes:

[Dawud_uk]

i hav heard dat wen a nön mehram gives a muslim sister salam, she is not supposed to giv salam back.since v meet a lot of non mehram brothers,how do v greet them bck da salam?pls enlighten me about who nd all cn b cald as our mehram nd wit da knowledge of islam

:rolleyes::rolleyes:

this was a ruling of imam malik, one of the four great imams but i have heard many hanafi ulema teach it also.

basically the ruling is as salaams can lead to conversation or fitnah and as a woman's voice is also part of her aurah then if a man gives her salaams then she should reply back in her head and keep walking so as not to cause a fitnah.

and then the same is said to a man if a woman gives you salaams then reply in your head and not out loud.

[sirajstc]

ok then

bro

like forums we say in itrodusion section Assalamu Alaikum then sisters also reply walaikum salam

is thizz rit?

[Dawud_uk]

ok then

bro

like forums we say in itrodusion section Assalamu Alaikum then sisters also reply walaikum salam

is thizz rit?

well i use salaams as this is an internet forum and i am never going to meet any of the sisters off here in person.

it is like when i have held meeting for masjid open days then yes i give salaams then and we discuss the business we have, but if i saw the same sister in the street i would go past as there is no need for us to talk or give salaams then.

[Zahida]

It is a Muslim mans/womans farz to give salaam even to your empty house as you enter like brother Dawd said there is no need to keep a conversation going if you have done your obligatory salaam...............:smile:

[sirajstc]

yaaa jaza kalla kahair 4 info