12 shot dead at US millitary base

  • Thread starter Thread starter The_Prince
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 86
  • Views Views 14K
Status
Not open for further replies.
I personally believe that a Muslim can not remain in the military. It is not a place for him or her to be. It is completely opposite of what our religion stands for.

Wa Allaahu a'lam


Ah, a pacifist.:D Even though my views are essentially pacifist, I believe that people need guns to protect us from other, more evil people with guns. I, like you, believe religion has essentially been raped by war mongerers, when it stands for the complete opposite.
 
I personally believe that a Muslim can not remain in the military. It is not a place for him or her to be. It is completely opposite of what our religion stands for.

Wa Allaahu a'lam

:sl:

It does depend. I don't mind if Muslims and non-Muslims are going to war against a country that is dangerous. For example Nazi Germany was a big threat...

EDIT: lol stupid typo
 
The thing is that this shooting is a best accusation of multiculturalism at all, as the army is a smaller version of whole nation. On the other hand, we cant do anything about it in USA.
 
Just my opinion. From what I have read so far. I doubt if Maj. Hasan actually wanted to harm anybody. It is my belief he was extremely depressed and could not live nor could he commit suicide so the only option was to place himself in a situation where he would e killed by the police. "Suicide by Cop" is not anything new. But often the person will have unloaded or toy guns. But being on a military base and being military the concept of unloaded weapons probably never would have registered. Outside of that I doubt if he would have thought one man, in the open, in the middle of 50,000 soldiers and armed only with 2 handguns would be able to do much damage before being killed.

I do feel pain for those killed but my heart and Du'as also go out to Maj. Hasan, the pain and depression he suffered that drove him to this horrible act, is the monster, not Maj. Hasan.
 
Why are there Muslims in the U.S. army? As the U.S. army is a Zionist one and at war with Islam. The Muslims should be Mujahidûn not in an infidel army fighting Mujahidûn.
If I was an American leader I would not let Muslims into the COUNTRY let alone the army.
I thought they had a big enough problem with Mexicans! I would not even let in Hindus 'cos of cultural clash. As an American leader I would only let in white redneck Protestants and Jews to look after the finances. LOL
 
Why are there Muslims in the U.S. army? As the U.S. army is a Zionist one and at war with Islam. The Muslims should be Mujahidûn not in an infidel army fighting Mujahidûn.
If I was an American leader I would not let Muslims into the COUNTRY let alone the army.
I thought they had a big enough problem with Mexicans! I would not even let in Hindus 'cos of cultural clash. As an American leader I would only let in white redneck Protestants and Jews to look after the finances. LOL

:sl:

Not sure if your being serious O_o

It is too simplistic to say America is with war with Islam otherwise America would have been fighting against ALL Muslim countries and destroying mosques etc.

The wars taking place now are due to economic reasons and need for resources...
 
Why are there Muslims in the U.S. army? As the U.S. army is a Zionist one and at war with Islam. The Muslims should be Mujahidûn not in an infidel army fighting Mujahidûn.
If I was an American leader I would not let Muslims into the COUNTRY let alone the army.
I thought they had a big enough problem with Mexicans! I would not even let in Hindus 'cos of cultural clash. As an American leader I would only let in white redneck Protestants and Jews to look after the finances. LOL

One thing you are overlooking. Us Americans are reverting to Islam probably faster than the people in any other nation. Outside of the East coast there are virtually no Jews in the USA. I do not believe there is a single Jew in the States of North Dakota, South Dakota, Wyoming, Montana or Alaska. America is only about 50% Non-Hispanic white. We also have some major cities such as Dearborn, Michigan that are now predominately Muslim. More Iranians now live in Las Angeles California than live in Tehran, Iran. There are more Muslims living in the USA than live in the 6 smallest Islamic nations combined.

Some Muslims do join the US military for the intent of protecting American Muslims.
 
Uthmān;1241788 said:

That is sad to read. It does make it seem his act was long planned and perhaps even his reason for joining the Army.

However, I think most people will understand it was the act of an individual perhaps any backlash will be short term.
 
Why are there Muslims in the U.S. army? As the U.S. army is a Zionist one and at war with Islam. The Muslims should be Mujahidûn not in an infidel army fighting Mujahidûn.
If I was an American leader I would not let Muslims into the COUNTRY let alone the army.
I thought they had a big enough problem with Mexicans! I would not even let in Hindus 'cos of cultural clash. As an American leader I would only let in white redneck Protestants and Jews to look after the finances. LOL

Then it is a Godsend you are not in any position of power. The Iraq war, despite being inherently evil and unjust, was more to do with America's greed for oil more than anything else.


One thing you are overlooking. Us Americans are reverting to Islam probably faster than the people in any other nation. Outside of the East coast there are virtually no Jews in the USA. I do not believe there is a single Jew in the States of North Dakota, South Dakota, Wyoming, Montana or Alaska. America is only about 50% Non-Hispanic white. We also have some major cities such as Dearborn, Michigan that are now predominately Muslim. More Iranians now live in Las Angeles California than live in Tehran, Iran. There are more Muslims living in the USA than live in the 6 smallest Islamic nations combined.

Isn't it amazing how religion is growing in the world's most developed country? It's essentially two fingers to all the atheists who believe religion has no place in society.
 
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=120162816

News > U.S. > Around the Nation

Officials Begin Putting Shooting Pieces Together
Tom Gjelten, Daniel Zwerdling and Steve Inskeep

November 6, 2009

Listen to the Story
Morning Edition
[5 min 48 sec]Add to Playlist
Download

November 6, 2009
As doctors attend to the wounded and funeral plans are made for the deceased, military officials at Fort Hood, Texas, are piecing together why the alleged gunman shot and killed 13 people and wounded 30 others. Among the things they are looking into: Whether Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan was disturbed by his deployment orders to go to Iraq.
STEVE INSKEEP, host:

So, authorities have answered one question: They believe it was a single gunman. But in a way, that only deepens the mystery about Major Nidal Hasan. We've been learning more about him this morning, first from NPR's Tom Gjelten, who's covering this story.

Tom, good morning.

TOM GJELTEN: Good morning, Steve.

INSKEEP: Who is he?

GJELTEN: Nidal Hasan was born here in the Washington, D.C. area in Arlington. His parents were Palestinian immigrants, it seems. He went to local schools, graduating from Virginia Tech, joined the Army. He spent basically his whole adult life in the Army. That's where he received his medical education. He was trained as a psychiatrist by the Army and served for several years at Walter Reed Army Medical Center, ironically specializing in the treatment of combat stress. He was then transferred to Fort Hood earlier this year. He was due to be deployed, apparently to Afghanistan. We've heard from various sources that that bothered him, for whatever reason. We know he was a devout Muslim, took his faith very seriously. We can't say, of course, that that was relevant, here.

INSKEEP: OK, so due to be deployed, and you also mentioned that he spent a lot of time at the Walter Reed Army Medical Center. I want another - bring another voice into the conversation, here. NPR's Daniel Zwerdling has covered posttraumatic stress disorder over the years and has also spent a lot of time with people at Walter Reed.

And Daniel, good morning to you.

DANIEL ZWERDLING: Good morning, Steve.

INSKEEP: I understanding you've spoken with someone who knew him, worked with him at Walter Reed.

ZWERDLING: Earlier today, I spoke to a psychiatrist who worked very closely with Hasan and knows him very well. And he said, you know, from the beginning -and Hasan was there for four years - the medical staff was very worried about this guy. He said the first thing is he's cold, unfriendly. At least that's who he came off. He did not do a good job as a psychiatrist in training, was repeatedly warned, you better shape up, or, you know, you're going to be in trouble. Did badly in his classes, seemed disinterested. But second of all - and this is, perhaps, you know, more relevant. The psychiatrist says that he was very proud and upfront about being Muslim. And psychiatrist hastened to say, and nobody minded that. But he seemed almost belligerent about being Muslim, and he gave a lecture one day that really freaked a lot of doctors out.

They have grand rounds, right? They, you know, dozens of medical staff come into an auditorium, and somebody stands at the podium at the front and gives a lecture about some academic issue, you know, what drugs to prescribe for what condition. But instead of that, he - Hasan apparently gave a long lecture on the Koran and talked about how if you don't believe, you are condemned to hell. Your head is cut off. You're set on fire. Burning oil is burned down your throat.

And I said to the psychiatrist, but this cold be a very interesting informational session, right? Where he's educating everybody about the Koran. He said but what disturbed everybody was that Hasan seemed to believe these things. And actually, a Muslim in the audience, a psychiatrist, raised his hand and said, excuse me. But I'm a Muslim and I do not believe these things in the Koran, and then I don't believe what you say the Koran says. And then Hasan didn't say, well, I'm just giving you one point of view. He basically just stared the guy down.

INSKEEP: So we have a picture of a man, then, who, at Walter Reed Army Medical Center, was disliked by his colleagues. Or maybe disliked is not the word. Disturbed some of his colleagues is perhaps a better way to put it.

ZWERDLING: No, and disliked is also a relevant word.

INSKEEP: OK. And then�

ZWERDLING: Then he - the psychiatrist this morning said people generally considered him a blank bag. You, you know, can guess what they say.

INSKEEP: And then he is sent to Fort Hood, Texas, and he knows at the point that this shooting allegedly begins, that the shooting begins of which he is accused, that he's about to be deployed by Afghanistan. Now, Tom, you've been looking into some of the stresses of military personnel of being sent overseas.

GJELTEN: That's right, Steve. You know, you referred to the Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. There's - almost seems to be a phenomenon that you could maybe call a pre-traumatic stress disorder. There have been a lot suicides in the Army, many more as a result of these wars than in previous years. Interestingly enough, as many soldiers have killed themselves before they were due to be deployed as after. Thirty-five percent of the suicides are pre-deployment, 35 percent are post-deployment. So there seems to be an issue here of expectation of what you are getting into. And the fact that Major Hasan would've known better than others, even, about how traumatic combat experience would be, you know, raises the question of, you know, was he an example of these soldiers who are literally freaked out by what they are likely to face when they are deployed?

INSKEEP: And it's hard to miss the location of this shooting: a processing center for people being sent overseas. Daniel Zwerdling.

ZWERDLING: I want to add something else about Hasan at Walter Reed. The psychiatrist I talked to today said that he was the kind of guy who the staff actually stood around in the hallway, saying: Do you think he's a terrorist, or is he just weird? And now, apparently, Walter Reed is in a lockdown mode where they've been instructed - all the staff has been instructed: Do not talk to anybody about this investigation, except military people. Do not talk to the FBI, because they're afraid, potentially, what if people decide investigating this that people missed potential warning signs about the guy? You know, this is speculation still, but�

INSKEEP: How can they not talk to the FBI?

ZWERDLING: Well, our colleague Dina Temple-Raston has heard that from the FBI, and this military officer is telling me the same thing from Walter Reed.

INSKEEP: OK. Gentlemen, thanks very much. NPR's Daniel Zwerdling and Tom Gjelten. Thanks to you both.

GJELTEN: Thank you, Steve.

ZWERDLING: Thank you.

INSKEEP: And we do want to mention: This is a moment in our coverage which can be distressing for some listeners because we hear so much about the suspect and so little about the victims. That is a factor of what we know now. The military is saying very little about the victims so far, expect that there are 13 dead, 12 military, one civilian. But it is very early, and we expect to learn more and bring you more in the coming hours and days.

It's MORNING EDITION from NPR News.
 
After reading that, it sounds like everybody saw him as a walking time bomb. Why the Hannah did they not grant his request for a discharge. He sure seemed like an ideal candidate for a medical discharge under section 8.
 
i believe he was getting bullied and he did it out of self defence and revenge do you think that being in the army is easy so much bullying goes on like look at that vid on youtube of prince harry calling a asian british soldier a paki the whole asian community of England were absolutely disgusted how there prince could behave in this way. i am telling you there so much crap they have to put up with aswell as fighting against the enemy
 
i believe he was getting bullied and he did it out of self defence and revenge do you think that being in the army is easy so much bullying goes on like look at that vid on youtube of prince harry calling a asian british soldier a paki the whole asian community of England were absolutely disgusted how there prince could behave in this way. i am telling you there so much crap they have to put up with aswell as fighting against the enemy


Self defense? Killing 13 people with handguns isn't self defense, it's cold blooded murder.

It's clear that the individual in this case was clearly distressed. However, he appears to be in the nutjob minority of the human race- instead of dealing with his bullying and his problems, he decided to take it out on other people by casually shooting and killing thirteen.


May the victims rest in peace. I shall pray for them.
 
Then it is a Godsend you are not in any position of power. The Iraq war, despite being inherently evil and unjust, was more to do with America's greed for oil more than anything else.



America and Britain have always been societies built on plunder and imperialism. That's why the world has always been in a state of despair and misery. But what I think is going on now in regards to the Iraq invasion is not primarily about plunder. They have just sacrificed far more than what the return was WORTH. I also disagree that the US and UK are not involved in a Zionist war. They quite clearly are. However, this is not the only factor at play either. If it was, then countries such as North Korea would not be incessantly bullied as well, so I do agree that the USA's war against Islam is not the ONLY motivation.

More precisely it's to do with destroying all other cultures and propagating the "American way" right throughout the planet and inculcating Anglo-American ideas and values. Yes, the invasion of Iraq would have been PARTLY to do with plunder, but that motive was only peripheral. The MAIN directive in the invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan is the USA's and UK's strategic positioning towards the ultimate invasion of Russia and China. Their aim is for the New World Order to become a reality. So it's big picture stuff. That's why they were trying so hard to get into Poland and Czechoslovakia with their missile bases (while using "Iran" as a completely pitiful excuse for the motivation). One can easily see a clear pattern with the invasion, occupation and manipulation of Asian and Eastern European countries closely bordering Russia. I admit that the USA's war on Islam is not the ONLY motive. There are several motives, but mere plunder for its own sake is not really worth all the trouble. It's when every single motive is added together that has made it seem worth it to them to invade Iraq. Unbeknownst to them though, they are clearly set to fail if they think they can ever be victorious against Russia. The day they attack Russia and China will really be the day that the USA's and UK's delusions of grandeur are finally realised!
 
Self defense? Killing 13 people with handguns isn't self defense, it's cold blooded murder.

It's clear that the individual in this case was clearly distressed. However, he appears to be in the nutjob minority of the human race- instead of dealing with his bullying and his problems, he decided to take it out on other people by casually shooting and killing thirteen.


May the victims rest in peace. I shall pray for them.

okay maybe not out of self defense lol anyway its hard to know what really happened i would not believe that story fully
 
I don't think they can attack Russia or China. But they might start another cold war.
 
okay maybe not out of self defense lol anyway its hard to know what really happened i would not believe that story fully
As Br. Woodrow said, he was a walking time bomb and he should have been discharged. Anyone (or group of people) not discharging him are either stupid or they had another motive in their mind.
 
When this story first broke, I remember thinking, "I really, really, really hope the shooter wasn't a Muslim."

I think it is clear that, for whatever reason, Hasan was motivated by a Salafi-style ideology. Reports say he shouted "Allahu ackbar" as he shot everyone. I think it's safe to say that he saw his act as a form of jihad.

Obviously there were other factors. I've read reports that he's gotten more and more extreme in his religious beliefs. And he has been discriminated against and been subject to abuse for those beliefs before—which probably further radicalized him. But it's not hard to see how someone with Salafi-style ideology would see the soldiers Hasan killed as part of the "other side." They were, after all, being deployed to places where they would probably end up killing Muslims.

All in all, though, I'm hopeful in the way that America and the Muslim community has responded to this. The army chief of staff is warning everyone not to judge all Muslims or Muslim soldiers by this guy's actions, and even Republican senators are saying that his actions don't reflect on Islam as a whole:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/09/us/politics/09casey.html?hp

(The exception, unfortunately, is Joe Lieberman, one of the biggest scumbags in the U.S...)

Reading this thread, and your guys' response, also makes me pretty hopeful. Let's hope everyone keeps a cool head.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top