300 Muslim Tsunami Orphans to be Christianized: Report

  • Thread starter Thread starter kadafi
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 168
  • Views Views 17K
Thank you, cheese. :)

The way I understand it now is that zakat is compulsory (one of the five pillars, right?), and can only be given to Muslims, or those 'inclined towards Islam).
Charitable giving to non-Muslims falls under general good deeds, and is encouraged but not compulsory ... :?

Thanks
 
^Yeh thats right. Charity is HIGHLY encouraged, like really really encouraged.

Anyway, when you think about, the non-Muslims living in an Islamic country don't pay Zakat, they pay something else, so why should they be given from the zakat money?:?
 
^Yeh thats right. Charity is HIGHLY encouraged, like really really encouraged.

Anyway, when you think about, the non-Muslims living in an Islamic country don't pay Zakat, they pay something else, so why should they be given from the zakat money?:?
Does zakat only apply in Islamic countries? :?
How do Muslims in non-Islamic countries pay zakat, and who to? Is it similar to tithing in Christian churches?
 
I will have to do some greater research into these claims of Christian missionaries going through all kinds of remarkable efforts to deceive non-Christians into becoming Christians ... most of those accounts are anecdotal and seem - forgive me for saying so - of a rather propagandistic nature.

I'm going to ignore the last part. Propaganda is by definition exaggeration or deceit, and I will have no part in it.

As for your verification, ask any missionary. I myself saw one in a thoub outside the ISNA convention in DC in 2002, extolling the benefits of "Submission to Isa" (astaghfirullah!). The Time magazine article I mentioned was their front cover article entitled "Should Christians Convert Muslims?", and I believe it was from 2004 or 2005.

Whilst I cannot and will not disproof that some people may use unconventional and unethical practices - and I would condemn those strongly!!! - none of the mainstream Christian missionary charities apply such tactics ... but then, perhaps I am totally naive and ignorant! :rollseyes

Don't count anything out


Perhaps I am just trying to add a little balance to this thread ... and perhaps it is futile of me to do so - but please don't think that this kind of thing is what Christianity teaches ... :?

That depends on what christianity you are talking about. Last I checked, there were about 33,000 different christian denominations totaling about 2.3 billion christians. Do you champion your version as correct and everyone else wrong?

If nothing else, cohercing people into changing their religion would be meaningless! God knows our hearts, and he knows whether our faith is genuine or just pretend. And that is what matters.

We should neither try to coherce people into converting into our faith, nor prevent people from converting into another faith if they so desire ...
Both, Christianity and Islam would do well to remember that!
:rollseyes

I agree with coercion in conversion. That also explains my dislike of missionaries and proselytization in general. I don't do it myself and I won't tolerate it being done to me. The last set of mormons that showed up at my door were close to getting chased around my front lawn with the cordless hedgetrimmer.


I wouldn't worry about death for apostasy now in Islam. For the death sentence to be warranted, a fully muslim state with the authority of Shar'iah must carry out the sentence, and since none of those exist nowadays.....

In any case, Islam combines both religious and political values. It is the Law, it is the State, and it is the Religion. As such, apostasy is viewed in the same vein as treason in the west, and last I checked in america, the sentence for treason was still death. Unless, of course, you sell out to the Israelies, in which case you get a long sentence in a low security prison with a long succession of israeli politicos begging for your release :rollseyes


It is easy for us to say that 'people have free will' and that there is 'no compulsion in religion' - but it is not so easy to apply in practice, when many of us desire to see other people to come to or remain in what we perceive to be the 'true faith'.
Perhaps we should all search out hearts in this matter ...

peace


Is there anything similar in the new testament that says there is no compulsion in religion?
 
^Yeh thats right. Charity is HIGHLY encouraged, like really really encouraged.

Anyway, when you think about, the non-Muslims living in an Islamic country don't pay Zakat, they pay something else, so why should they be given from the zakat money?:?

By the same token, it's reported that Umar (RA) provided for a destitute christian out of the public treasury, sort of like a retirement fund. The christian, of course, had advised Umar that he had paid the Jizya faithfully. And so, he was rewarded.
 
Does zakat only apply in Islamic countries? :?
How do Muslims in non-Islamic countries pay zakat, and who to? Is it similar to tithing in Christian churches?

No, zakat is the duty of muslims everywhere, regardless of whether or not they live in an "islamic state". If no islamic political authorities are available, then the funds are delivered to the local mosque.

Zakat is not paid by the non muslims. If non muslims are living under non muslims, or dhimmis (Dhimmitude! Eat your heart out, robert spencer!), they pay the Jizyah, which is significantly less than Zakat. Various interpretations have been given for Jizyah, I.E. "It's so they can practice their religions in our lands" or "It's for their upkeep of the state army since non-muslim post pubescent males don't have mandatory military terms" etc, but the latter bears the most weight, as we know that 'Umar (RA) returned the Jizyah of one northern arabian christian tribe whom he was unable to protect from christian advances. He also let a christian arab tribe pay zakat instead of jizyah when they claimed jizyah was "degrading".
 
I'm going to ignore the last part. Propaganda is by definition exaggeration or deceit, and I will have no part in it.

As for your verification, ask any missionary. I myself saw one in a thoub outside the ISNA convention in DC in 2002, extolling the benefits of "Submission to Isa" (astaghfirullah!). The Time magazine article I mentioned was their front cover article entitled "Should Christians Convert Muslims?", and I believe it was from 2004 or 2005.

Don't count anything out

That depends on what christianity you are talking about. Last I checked, there were about 33,000 different christian denominations totaling about 2.3 billion christians. Do you champion your version as correct and everyone else wrong?

I agree with coercion in conversion. That also explains my dislike of missionaries and proselytization in general. I don't do it myself and I won't tolerate it being done to me. The last set of mormons that showed up at my door were close to getting chased around my front lawn with the cordless hedgetrimmer.

I wouldn't worry about death for apostasy now in Islam. For the death sentence to be warranted, a fully muslim state with the authority of Shar'iah must carry out the sentence, and since none of those exist nowadays.....

In any case, Islam combines both religious and political values. It is the Law, it is the State, and it is the Religion. As such, apostasy is viewed in the same vein as treason in the west, and last I checked in america, the sentence for treason was still death. Unless, of course, you sell out to the Israelies, in which case you get a long sentence in a low security prison with a long succession of israeli politicos begging for your release :rollseyes
Thank you for your comments.
Like I said, I will try to do my own research into this ... but not at 6.00 in the morning ... :D

I am not saying that these practices don't happen (there are two million people in this world, who refer to themselves as Christians ... I cannot possibly speak for all of them ...! :rollseyes ) - I am more interested to find out how significant such worrying practices are in statistical terms. Christians should want to know, because such practices are harmful to our faith, and how we are viewed by others!

Is there anything similar in the new testament that says there is no compulsion in religion?
Not in that wording, that particular quote referred to Qu'ranic teachings. :)

But people do not have to believe.
Jesus told his disciples to leave people alone, if they were not willing to listen to their teachings.
"If people do not welcome you, shake the dust off your feet when you leave their town, as a testimony against them." (Luke 9:5)

Peace
 
Hi Glo,

No it is not true that Muslims cannot give in charity to non-Muslims. There is a difference between zakat and charity. Zakat is like a tax payed by the Muslims has a specific use:

“As-Sadaqaat (here it means Zakaah) are only for the Fuqaraa’ (poor), and Al‑Masaakeen (the poor) and those employed to collect (the funds); and to attract the hearts of those who have been inclined (towards Islam); and to free the captives; and for those in debt; and for Allaah’s Cause (i.e. for Mujaahidoon — those fighting in a holy battle), and for the wayfarer (a traveller who is cut off from everything); a duty imposed by Allaah. And Allaah is All-Knower, All-Wise”

[al-Tawbah 9:60]​

Charity itself is different to zakat, and is not compulsory and can be given to anyone, Muslim or non-Muslim:

9 – It is not permissible to give zakaah to kuffaar and mushrikeen.

Sadaqah may be given to kuffaar and mushrikeen.

Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning):

“And they give food, in spite of their love for it (or for the love of Him), to the Miskeen (the poor), the orphan, and the captive”

[al-Insaan 76:8]

Al-Qurtubi said: In dar al-Islam (the Muslim lands), a captive could only be a mushrik.​

http://www.islam-qa.com/index.php?ref=9449&ln=eng

Hope that helps!

Thanks for clearing that up (you too glo!) :). I am not completely convinced it is very ethical yet (only giving social welfare money to your own kind), but it is certainly an improvement.
 
hi glo,

i attending the funeral of my grandmother recently in a c of e church in my home village. as i left i saw the Christian Aid magazines available for reading...

on it was a picture of an elderly pakistani man carrying a christian aid package on his back, i assume they were referring to the earthquake but the title was something like 'carrying the message of jesus to all parts of the world' or something like that.

christian aid is one of the bigger charities and yet is advertises in churches that it carries out missionary work in the muslim world, and yet denies it publically...

i have also heard simular such stories of christian aid lies and missionary work being carried out on condition of giving aid and there are so many more less reputable christian charities out there.

peace be upon those who follow righteous guidence,
Abu Abdullah
 
hi glo,

i attending the funeral of my grandmother recently in a c of e church in my home village. as i left i saw the Christian Aid magazines available for reading...

on it was a picture of an elderly pakistani man carrying a christian aid package on his back, i assume they were referring to the earthquake but the title was something like 'carrying the message of jesus to all parts of the world' or something like that.

christian aid is one of the bigger charities and yet is advertises in churches that it carries out missionary work in the muslim world, and yet denies it publically...
Greetings, Abu Abdullah

Can I ask you if you read the article, or just made a judgement based on the picture and title?
I assume that 'carrying the message of Jesus' may refer to Jesus' instructions to care for the needy, the orphans and the widows, rather than spreading the gospel.

That is an assumption on my part (I have tried to find this article, but cannot come up with anything), and the reason I feel I can make that assumption is that I have found no evidence for evangelising, and I know ChristianAid to be a highly reputable charity.

You are right, there seems to be no mention of handing out leaflets or evangelising on their website - according to the charities commission (see http://www.charity-commission.gov.uk/) charities are legally required to mention such things in their mission statement.
If they haven't that means either that they don't evangelise, or that they are dishonest about their intentions ... :rollseyes

I find the latter highly unlikely. You need to know that charities such as ChristianAid are heavily scrutinised, not only by the charities commission, but also other secular groups such as the humanist society, who strongly argue against any form of dawah/evangelising.

A very popular charity, called Operation Christmas child, came under much criticism from secular groups a few years ago, for including 'leaflets of religious content' with their gift boxes. This caused quite a stir and resulted in them losing much support from local groups, schools, the co-operative group etc.
So you see that mainstream Christian charities in the UK can not just go off and do what they like ... even if they wanted to!

I accept that sadly there are probably charities, which are less reputable, but I do not think Christian Aid (or other mainstream charities in the UK) are amongst them.

Despite all your misgivings, so you think charities such as ChristianAid do good and contribute to alleviating some of the suffering in the world?

Peace
 
No one disagrees that charity is bad glo. Whats bad is taking advantage of it to preach your faith, when people haven't asked u too. So how can it be considered charity with good intention, if u also have the intention to preach your religion no one has asked you or when they're in their weakest state? Thats the point being made here.

I would never preach my religion no matter how correct i think it is because thats not what they need at the moment. All they need is help. Thats why in Islam, its better if you do charity quietly, cuz ur not showing off telling everyone "hey look im giving charity, compliment me please." When you keep it to urself and not show it off like that, your doing it for His sake, and cuz u were commanded too, not so people can see how good ur doing. It would mean your doing it to impress people, not God. Thats the difference.
 
Last edited:
No one disagrees that charity is bad glo. Whats bad is taking advantage of it to preach your faith, when people haven't asked u too. So how can it be considered charity with good intention, if u also have the intention to preach your religion no one has asked you or when they're in their weakest state? Thats the point being made here.
Greetings, Tayyaba
I understand the point very well.
If you have read my previous posts, you will know that I am in agreement with you. :)

I would never preach my religion no matter how correct i think it is because thats not what they need at the moment. All they need is help. Thats why in Islam, its better if you do charity quietly, cuz ur not showing off telling everyone "hey look im giving charity, compliment me please." When you keep it to urself and not show it off like that, your doing it for His sake, and cuz u were commanded too, not so people can see how good ur doing. It would mean your doing it to impress people, not God. Thats the difference.

This is a different matter to what we have discussed here previously, but I agree with this too! :)
Jesus himself said this on charitable giving:
"Be careful not to do your 'acts of righteousness' before men, to be seen by them. If you do, you will have no reward from your Father in heaven. So when you give to the needy, do not announce it with trumpets, as the hypocrites do in the synagogues and on the streets, to be honored by men. I tell you the truth, they have received their reward in full. But when you give to the needy, do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing, so that your giving may be in secret. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you."
(Matthew 6: 2-4)

Peace
 
peace glo,

this wasnt the only instance, i have many personal reports from contacts in pakistan who reported that they were trying to spread christianity whilst there doing aid work.

as for operation christmas child, my friend was one of the key campaigners stopping them in his town and this led to many others knowing about their sneaky methods.

basically they would open up the shoebox of goodies you were sending overseas and then put in christian literature in the language of the country it was going to, and funny enough it was usually a muslim country... then send it off.

i also help run a islam information stall in my local city centre, time and again christian missionaries approach us and try to talk to us, even if you get them admit they are wrong on a matter i know they will come back the next week and speak to other guys on the stall with the same lies all over again and there are lies when they admit they are wrong arguments to one person and then use the same argument again the next week,

why do christian missionaries have to use window salesman tactics? if the product is good enough then surely it sells itself?

peace be upon those who follow righteous guidence,
Abu Abdullah
 
Poor kids. May allah swt protect these little innocent kids insha allah. Its so hard for them to differentiate what these socalled helpers want. Similar exploits have been proven succesful in several poor countries.


LA hawla Wala Quata Ilaa Bilaah. Qadro Allah

Man Yahdihi Leh Fa Laa Modila Laah, Wa Man Yodlil Fa Laa Hadiya Laah!
 
Last edited:
Greetings, Abu Abdullah
peace glo,
as for operation christmas child, my friend was one of the key campaigners stopping them in his town and this led to many others knowing about their sneaky methods.

basically they would open up the shoebox of goodies you were sending overseas and then put in christian literature in the language of the country it was going to, and funny enough it was usually a muslim country... then send it off.
I know.

I loved the Operation Christmas child, because it was a wonderful way to teach my young children the principles of charity. I remember doing it one year, when they were still quite young. They made up one box each, and got to choose the things to put into it (Certain things were specified, such as toothbrushes, soap etc, but also small suitable toys. Interestingly enough it was specified at the time not to include anything that was of religious content!). I remember my children opening 'their' boxes again and again, just to imagine what it would be like for a child in need to receive their gift ... :statisfie

Since the scandal about including literature, we do not participate anymore ... but I am still looking for a charitable cause which has such an impact on my children!

If you look at their website, you will see that Operation Christmas child are quite open about including 'Gospel booklets in their own language' (quote from website) ...

i also help run a islam information stall in my local city centre, time and again christian missionaries approach us and try to talk to us, even if you get them admit they are wrong on a matter i know they will come back the next week and speak to other guys on the stall with the same lies all over again and there are lies when they admit they are wrong arguments to one person and then use the same argument again the next week,
Yes, ongoing evangelising/dawah is annoying. I find that too ...
(But please remember that those Christians perceive the information you give out as much as lies as you perceive theirs to be! It's circular argument, really. And if you do dawah, I guess that's the kind of thing you have to expect ... :rollseyes)

Back to the charity topic, I noticed that you did not answer my previous question:
Despite all your misgivings, so you think charities such as ChristianAid do good and contribute to alleviating some of the suffering in the world?

I pray there will be peace between your faiths, Abu Abdullah.
That is my greatest prayer! That people will stop wasting their energies on fighting and pickering with each other, respect each others faiths instead and focus their energies on more worthy causes!

Much more could be done about poverty, famines and diseases, if we all stopped wasting our precious time and resources on wars and fighting ... and I don't just mean in far-away countries such as Afghanistan and Iraq, but in our own communities too!

How about trying to get together with thos Christian missionaries who come to your dawah stall to tackle issues like local crime and drug abuse, instead of arguing with each other ...
It takes one to make the first step! It could be you! :D

My best wishes (to the rest of your family, too!) :)



 
Greetings, Abu Abdullah

I know.

I loved the Operation Christmas child, because it was a wonderful way to teach my young children the principles of charity. I remember doing it one year, when they were still quite young. They made up one box each, and got to choose the things to put into it (Certain things were specified, such as toothbrushes, soap etc, but also small suitable toys. Interestingly enough it was specified at the time not to include anything that was of religious content!). I remember my children opening 'their' boxes again and again, just to imagine what it would be like for a child in need to receive their gift ... :statisfie

Since the scandal about including literature, we do not participate anymore ... but I am still looking for a charitable cause which has such an impact on my children!

peace glo,

i know plenty of poor families we try to help out personally, look at all the children who will be poorer this year due to the folding of the xmas saving schemes?

i know this might be like teaching grandma to such eggs, but try to install charity all year around, i know a lot of churches have addressed this problem but still in some towns and cities the poor are kicked out of their homeless shelters straight after xmas and right into the heart of winter.


If you look at their website, you will see that Operation Christmas child are quite open about including 'Gospel booklets in their own language' (quote from website) ...

but the point is they were not open with those they asked to help them were they? in fact they hid this from them and hid it from many schools in nottingham that this was their intention until it was pointed out to the schools independently.


Yes, ongoing evangelising/dawah is annoying. I find that too ...
(But please remember that those Christians perceive the information you give out as much as lies as you perceive theirs to be! It's circular argument, really. And if you do dawah, I guess that's the kind of thing you have to expect ... :rollseyes)

i am not talking of disagreements. i am talking about missionaries using a set line and argument like the moon god one for example. you bring them proof and show it is not true. they admit it is not true. sometimes the very next week they will try using the same argument to a different muslim who is on the stall that week.

that is just plain dishonest and lying would you not agree?

if i found a flaw in any argument i used then i would stop using it, i would not just stop using it on one person and then use it again on someone else like the flaw had never been pointed out to me otherwise i would be a liar.


Back to the charity topic, I noticed that you did not answer my previous question:

Despite all your misgivings, so you think charities such as ChristianAid do good and contribute to alleviating some of the suffering in the world?

they help with some human suffering, but at the expense of putting people into further spiritual peril. i know this seems harsh but they seem to be directing much of their effort at the muslim lands when there is desparate poverty and pure evil from lack of religious conviction in our own towns and cities here in the uk.


I pray there will be peace between your faiths, Abu Abdullah.
That is my greatest prayer! That people will stop wasting their energies on fighting and pickering with each other, respect each others faiths instead and focus their energies on more worthy causes!

Much more could be done about poverty, famines and diseases, if we all stopped wasting our precious time and resources on wars and fighting ... and I don't just mean in far-away countries such as Afghanistan and Iraq, but in our own communities too!

if you look through out history, muslims have been peaceful with those who are peaceful with us, and we are told in the Quran that of the people of the book we will find many of the christians to be closer to us than the jews.

this is my personal experience, although the jews might be closer to us docterine wise, from a position of their deeds i find myself closer to the thoughts and actions of the good christians in my area.


How about trying to get together with thos Christian missionaries who come to your dawah stall to tackle issues like local crime and drug abuse, instead of arguing with each other ...
It takes one to make the first step! It could be you! :D

My best wishes (to the rest of your family, too!) :)

they are liars, proven to me time and again. once when i confronted some of them they just gave me a smarmy smile. how can i trust such liars? i could never trust as they see the ends as justifying the means and that is a dangerous attitude.

however i am attending a local dialogue group with other muslims and christians - catholics, C of E, methodists, and even the local pink haired sufi christian deacon of sheffield cathedral who prays in the same manner as muslims, even having memorised the prayers in arabic but still believes in trinity... certainly an interesting though unusual character.

peace Glo,

Abu Abdullah
 
Another way of looking at this.

Isn't it wonderfull that Allah(swt) is giving these children the opportunity to eventually return to Islam out of pure love and understanding, not just as a birthright. they are given the chance for a great reward as compensation for what they lost. Some if not all of them will return and could very well be the tools to streingthen the Ummah,

Agree ! When they get older, they still can choose, what path to go ! I see no problem on that !
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top