BlueCrayon
New member
- Messages
- 1
- Reaction score
- 2
Asalamu wa alaikum, brothers and sisters!
I have a few questions about Jan-na, you see, so I thought maybe I would find an Islamic forum online to discuss it with.
Before I start, I'd just like to say that I'm 15 years old, so maybe my questions will sound a little trivial or stupid to you guys, and if so, I hope you'll excuse me.
It's just that I have been dwelling on these questions for a few days now, and would like to know what others will make of it.
Okay, well, one of the things I was wondering was...like, you know how if by Allah :Swt: 's mercy, you manage to make your way to Jan-na, then you will be granted eternal happiness and peace? (This includes, I suppose, being given whatever it is that you wish for.) Well, what if one of the things that you want in Jan-na is to be able to, let's say, watch a certain television program that you enjoyed very much while you were on Earth? At first, I thought "Well, since you will be granted whatever you wish for, then you will probably be able to." But would that really be possible? Let's say that the television program you enjoyed happened to have, as a part of the plot, a little bit of conflict, and maybe martial arts or something. If you think about it, maybe that kind of thing won't be allowed in Jan-na, because in Jan-na, there can't/won't exist any conflicts or troubles or violence. But wouldn't that mean you wouldn't be granted what you wished for, thus disrupting the concept of eternal happiness there? (Obviously there are other things you could entertain yourself with in Jan-na, but let's just say that you really really wanted to watch this particular television program.) So what would happen, then?
Or what if your life-long dream (while you lived on Earth) consisted of becoming a skilled person at martial arts, or sword-fighting? Such activities require an opponent, plus you are, technically, aiming to harm someone, which wouldn't be allowed in Jan-na. But this has always been something you've dreamed of, so of course if you went to Jan-na, you would really want to wish for that particular thing (to become a martial arts/swords master). What would happen here, too?
Again, I apologize if my questions appear trivial and point-less, but I really would be interested in knowing the answers to them! So please impart any knowledge on this matter that you might have!
Thank you, brothers and sisters!!

Before I start, I'd just like to say that I'm 15 years old, so maybe my questions will sound a little trivial or stupid to you guys, and if so, I hope you'll excuse me.

Okay, well, one of the things I was wondering was...like, you know how if by Allah :Swt: 's mercy, you manage to make your way to Jan-na, then you will be granted eternal happiness and peace? (This includes, I suppose, being given whatever it is that you wish for.) Well, what if one of the things that you want in Jan-na is to be able to, let's say, watch a certain television program that you enjoyed very much while you were on Earth? At first, I thought "Well, since you will be granted whatever you wish for, then you will probably be able to." But would that really be possible? Let's say that the television program you enjoyed happened to have, as a part of the plot, a little bit of conflict, and maybe martial arts or something. If you think about it, maybe that kind of thing won't be allowed in Jan-na, because in Jan-na, there can't/won't exist any conflicts or troubles or violence. But wouldn't that mean you wouldn't be granted what you wished for, thus disrupting the concept of eternal happiness there? (Obviously there are other things you could entertain yourself with in Jan-na, but let's just say that you really really wanted to watch this particular television program.) So what would happen, then?
Or what if your life-long dream (while you lived on Earth) consisted of becoming a skilled person at martial arts, or sword-fighting? Such activities require an opponent, plus you are, technically, aiming to harm someone, which wouldn't be allowed in Jan-na. But this has always been something you've dreamed of, so of course if you went to Jan-na, you would really want to wish for that particular thing (to become a martial arts/swords master). What would happen here, too?
Again, I apologize if my questions appear trivial and point-less, but I really would be interested in knowing the answers to them! So please impart any knowledge on this matter that you might have!

Thank you, brothers and sisters!!