Any Dr Zakir Naik fans here?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hamayun
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 58
  • Views Views 7K

Do you like Dr Zakir Naik's Dawah methods?

  • Total voters
    0
Status
Not open for further replies.
Güven said:
well who doesnt make mistakes

:w:
Click to expand...

and you want to take your deen from someone like that when we have more knowledeable scholars present? Do you take your deen that lightly, upon which your akhirah is dependent on? Would you go to the best doctor or one that makes mistakes?

"In the past, he has made other clear errors on the issue of Aqeeda.
On this basis, he is not a credible Sunni scholar, despite his expertise in comparative religion. "
Click to expand...
 
raOnar said:
:sl:

SixTen could you back that up? Otherwise do no make comments like that!
Click to expand...

Many of his dawah, regarding the Qur'an, is utmost contradictive of what authentic tafseers state - as well as contradict many of the greatest scholars. Yes, he seems so good, when you do not have a lot of knowledge about Islam, but if you took your time to study the Qur'an, regarding what he preaches, you will find him not being just wrong, but intellectually bankrupt on many of the things he says and how he justifies oh so many things.

To put it simply, he has just made his own version of Islam, if you know what I am saying. In that, he makes verses mean things which they do not. Sure, people try excuse him with, verses could have several meanings. But believe it or not, the Qur'anic verses were given with meanings - and its one thing to have 1 verse mean a lot - but to mean contradictive meanings is an insult to the Qur'an.

Most people start getting into Naikh, in the teen years, as I did. I thought he was the grand master of dawah. Until you saw, everything he says has been refuted. Not just by non-muslims, but also MUSLIMS.

Their are things, he does say right and answer correctly. But I think, he has, imo, robbed muslims of real Islam, you can't so easily forgive him or, call him a speaker. Its more than just a "mistake". Sadly, from such roots, we have the weak dawah being spread all over the world - for many young muslims. This in turn makes them give dawah which is actually isn't true. What good is it if you convert muslims over somthing which isn't really factual? Ontop, alot of the arguements, would just make intellectuals laugh - as they really are that bad.

As for Ahmed Deedat, he doesn't get the same treatment as Naikh as, as far as I know, he hasn't "butchered" the Qur'an. He does comparative religion a lot. Again, although his arguements seemed great when I was young, having learnt a bit more about several faiths, I do feel that he does to Christianity, to say, what Robert Spencer does to Islam. Sure, Robert Spencer seems to make perfect sense to non-muslims about Islam, but that is because they are non-muslim. I have found people converting to Islam over his work, but then I know people who left Islam over works criticising Islam. Does this mean either of the dawah was factual? No not at all, just that it convinced the person. Personally, both sides actually use very weak arguements.

Want to learn about Islam? Go for the real stuff, not this modern re-translation of Islam.
 
islamirama said:
and you want to take your deen from someone like that when we have more knowledeable scholars present? Do you take your deen that lightly, upon which your akhirah is dependent on? Would you go to the best doctor or one that makes mistakes?
Click to expand...

Oh cmon Obama makes mistakes on his great campaigns. its called bein human.
You make mistakes (like right now). We all make mistakes, Unless we're not immune to perfection, thats completly normal.

stop hatin on zakir naik man! he is the most humanist human in the world of humans....ok not really . but cmon give him a break, he memorizes the quran, the bible, the every possible religon related book in the world, hadiths, and well he prety much has the world in his head, and he's only like 37 or worrever.
 
islamirama said:
and you want to take your deen from someone like that when we have more knowledeable scholars present? Do you take your deen that lightly, upon which your akhirah is dependent on? Would you go to the best doctor or one that makes mistakes?
Click to expand...

Well the best doctor obviosly if you have the money , but isnt Ahmed Deedat a good scolar ? or i mean zakir Naik not a good scolar ?
 
You go to a doctor who is not among the best, what happens? you loose a limb, longer illness, maybe death. You go to a questionable source of knowledge, what happens? maybe loose jannah due to wrong aqeedah....is it the same as loosing life? is it worth it?

no thanks, i don't need to go to self made scholars when something so great is on the online, and when the option exists of going to someone MORE knowledgeable.
 
akhi can you name us some modern day scholars which you would as you say go to...
 
:sl:

^ subhanALLAH..iplz let me know of this "great" scholars..i must be missing out

Dr.Zakir Naik is a great scholar

what mistakes?

please inform me

it seams like theres more hatred on here then love..i mean more critics

everyones has their oponion though

JazakALLAH Khair

:w:
 
No one so far has mentioned any real mistakes apart from the Yazid incident.
 
i have heard of Dr Zaki, his pretty good but i swear if u havent listened anything from iman Anwar al-awlaki ur missing out. In my opinon he tops, just listen to 10min from his lectures and u would gain soo much knowledge
i have all his stuff if anyones interested
 
Hamayun said:
No one has mentioned a single mistake yet apart from the Yazid incident.
Click to expand...

and that wasnt even a mistake!

these so called scholars who point out mistakes in other muslims, are just ridiculous, they want to look good by puttin down others, and the best way to find them out, is check their aqeedah, and then you can shame them up!
 
I dont know him, but I Do know what he looks like? thats about it.
 
ok ive given up
i dont have a background knowledge on islamic history so i dont understand what they r talkin bout
 
I haven't known him until I searched abt him in google>>
he has a program -i guess- on Huda Tv..right?
 
ok i think its time we closed this thread lol!

tbh, it dont matter what we think of zakir naik, Allah (Swt) is the judge! l

i think he is a great scholar, and those who go againist him, like i said check their aqeedah and you will clearly see who is wrong! also before judgin someone else, we should judge ourselfs and see if we are perfect!!

may Allah (swt) preserve zakir naik! and may he give him the strength to give more lectures brap brap!

:threadclo

any objections phone us on our LI hotline :embarrass
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top