Both CAN’T be there :-o

[suffiyan007]

i agreed...but my country everywhere music cant defense/resist! maybe i should put an ear plug should be a solution! just kidding!

 

[Güven]

Not Only in Your Country Bro , Its In The Whole World , But you gotta resist put Quran Or Nasheed In Your Ipod(if You have One ofcourse) Or somethin

 

[Maymunah]

she is a muslimah...i mean paula abdul...and she still going strong in her music career? she making haram thing..so how...?

Im I missing a point here....:?
So wat if paula abdul is working in the music industry.
On the day of judgment allah is not going 2 ask u bout paula abdul ,but u will b questioned on your life n how u lived it, if u followed the quran n the sunnah of the prophet pbuh etc

 

[suffiyan007]

Ya i understand and i had agreed...! well sorry for debating..! i hope for the best! we should not have music and put Quran in priority!...sorry my english quite lousy...cause i am not white skin people...i am yellow skin..people...u will know where i am from!

 

[Maymunah]

Ya i understand and i had agreed...! well sorry for debating..! i hope for the best! we should not have music and put Quran in priority!...sorry my english quite lousy...cause i am not white skin people...i am yellow skin..people...u will know where i am from!

alhamdullilah...Im glad

 

[Güven]

Ya i understand and i had agreed...! well sorry for debating..! i hope for the best! we should not have music and put Quran in priority!...sorry my english quite lousy...cause i am not white skin people...i am yellow skin..people...u will know where i am from!

LOl;D SO What If your not white skin that has NOthing To do with Your Language and Btw Your English is Not That Bad :thumbs_up

 

[Fishman]

On music:
Every culture in the world uses some form of vocalisation to express itself. Its a natural thing, even for Muslims. That's what naats/nasheeds are for. However much people mess around with words by saying 'reading' instead of 'singing', or calling them 'poetry', naats are still a kind of song, but one which scholars agree is allowed. I've noticed that Muslims, despite music being regarded as haraam, are actually incredibly vocal people. You can't find a gathering without some sort of artistic use of the human voice. So that does away with the old 'how can you not have music!? Its natural!' argument.

This, however, leads to a new question that people ask. They say that only allowing Islamic songs is racist and intollerant of other cultures. However, there is in fact no reason why you can't read a naat/nasheed written in for example, a Chinese style, or an African style, or an English style, provided no musical instruments are used.

 

[al Amaanah]

exactly guven. or mp3 player.

 

[suffiyan007]

Aiyo! u a strong point man...fishman...there lotsa to learn in islam bout hadith what Nabi SAW...told his companion...hear/listen to music..are haram...!
my comments that, lotsa people say no music..so boring...life so dull? i mean now these day people saying...OMG! **** boring no music so lifeless...so how much u can see when Music in world is prohibited? i not to debate but to be a commentator..i just to give some of my view..! music are everywhere! so the world are so dangerous!

 

[Umu 'Isa]

:salamext:
There have been several threads on this topic before. Use the search function and you shall find insha Allaah.



Reference for original post from sister -Serene-:

It is reported from Abdullah ibn Mas'ood (May Allaah be pleased with him):

"Music sows hypocrisy in the heart like water causes seeds to grow in soil''

(Ad-Durru al-Manthoor, by As-Suyootee 5/307-308, explanation of verse 31:6 of the Qur'aan)