Brave American Troops Exposed!

Is this suppose to be a joke? I would never join the Pakistani military I am better off joining American military. Why do we have to reach for the weapon everytime? We can do much better job of stopping the war just by exposing the crimes. Do you believe every American will enjoy watching that video?

Note: I was not the user of youtube who posted video..

apparently the idiots who made the movie are the ones who posted it on youtube. Youtube loves sensationalism and is a form of yellow journalism in the same league as the "National Enquirer" it is an "Entertainment" source and can not be considered legitimate news.
 
I didn't watch the youtube vid...but from folks been saying here I am glad I didn't. We can all imagine the kind of filth commited round the world and we can all see it till we are blue in the face but unless we are in a position to do something we will just corrupt our minds and hearts....so let us make use of the weapons we have for now...our Dua

The Prophet Muhammad (sa) said: "Supplication is the weapon of the believer, the pillar of the religion, and the light of the heaven and earth" [Hadith Al-Hakim]

The Prophet Muhammad (sa) said, Allah said: "O My slaves! You are all astray except him that I guide, so seek for My guidance, I will guide you. O My slaves! You are all hungry except him whom I feed, so seek for provision from Me, I will feed you" [Hadith Muslim]

The Prophet Muhammad (sa) said: "Whoever does not ask from Allah, He becomes angry at him" [Hadith Bukhari and Ahmad]

‘God will not change the state of a people until they change their own state’ (Sura 13:12)

:w:
 
:sl:
brother you raise a good point. but im also of the opinion that we should propoagte this stuff. a) how is anyone going to make dua for others when we dont know the situation. b) it good to know what is what happening to out brothers and sisters.
:sl:
 
things like this do need to be exposed. however, exposure alone is not going to help much, exposure on youtube is even less helpful as that does not have a very high credibility level.

while the video shown here could be true there are other possibilities some possible scenarios:

1. It is true

2. It is a made to order sensationalism for shock purpose only

3. It was deliberately made by anti Americans to show America in a bad light

4. It was a group of drunk teenagers fantasizing

what we do know for certain.

1. the people in the film speak english

2. they are of young age

3. It appears they were and had been drinking beer

Now for the questions:

Why would anybody make that video? They had to know that if it is seen by the "wrong" people it can result in serious trouble for them.

When was the video made?

When was the speaker in Iraq?

what unit did the speaker serve with?

What are the names of any of the people in the video?

How come all events spoken of are generalities and no specific identifiable event was named?

Yes, when we know of such events it is important to have them made public, but to make something public, you need verifiable events that are documented and not just idiots shooting off their mouths.

Yes, if that is true those people are a danger. They are not the type of person you would want living next door to you even if you are not Muslim. Nobody is safe from a sexual deviant. If that story is true that young man is just as much of a danger to Americans as he was to Iraqis. A pervert is a pervert is a pervert, they will have no honor or respect of anything or anybody that stands in the way of their own desires.

One thing that is known is the email address of the person who posted that video. I do believe that person will soon be asked to explain how he came across that video and who are the people in it. A crime may have been committed and that crime will not be protected simply because the man was in the Army. The American public also wants to be protected from the likes of that.
 
:sl:
brother you raise a good point. but im also of the opinion that we should propoagte this stuff. a) how is anyone going to make dua for others when we dont know the situation. b) it good to know what is what happening to out brothers and sisters.
:sl:

:sl:

I am not saying we should ignore it, all I am saying is that we shouldn't dwell on it and forget to address the roots of the problem.
What this thread addresses is only part of a very big problem.

The biggest loss of the Ummah wasn't the loss of the Khilafah but it was the death of Mohammad(SAW). An Illiterate man(SAW), bringing peace unity and justice wherever he went with the help of Allah Azza Wa Jal.

Please also read this thread :):

http://www.islamicboard.com/general/48443-start-your-self.html

:w:
 
I'm with Woodrow on this one...all we see in this video are immature imbeciles who I seriously doubt ever set foot in Iraq. I could be wrong, but without anything to back any of this drivel up...I don't see the point in creating drama around it.
 
Nevertheless, I'm sure you'll agree with me that stuff like this do happen in Iraq?

Oh I'm sure there have been isolated incidents of military misconduct in Iraq, as there are in every war. However, watching some video on Youtube and blanketing the whole of the U.S. military with it is foolish.
 
There propably have been incidents like that in Iraq. However, I doubt if anybody who has done so would be so stupid they would make a video and brag about it. People do their best to hide their crimes, not publicize them.

A false video can be very damaging and have a reverse effect. If a video such as that is discovered to be false, it will only reduce the credibility of actual reports. yes, criminals have to be exposed and brought to justice. But, to expose we have to have proof that what we show is factual and verifiable.That video is not verifiable. It is going to send the wrong message and make people think that all stories of crimes in Iraq are fabrications.

If that story is true, I believe by now it is in the process of being verified and It will be used as evidence against that idiot.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top