Can Allah change the past

Islamicboy123 said:
Do you have any evidence from the Quran or Sunnah to back your point
Click to expand...

No I haven't...but just think about it...

1. What would be the benefit of changing the past? The past is to learn from...things happened in the past, mistakes, though times, etc, form life experience and is meant to learn from...sins can be forgiven instead of erased.

2. I don't want to be mean but if your past is a burden for you...then it means you can take it...just take your lesson from it, give it a place in your life and pick up your life again. Allah does not burden anyone more than he can take.

3. What would be the entire use of giving us free will if He could manipulate the made decisions anyways...so we have a free will, but in reality we haven't?...you have gone through things because of a reason...a reason you and I may not know, but Allah knows of course.

4. You cannot expect EVERYTHING to be described in Quraan and Sunnah. Allah gave us brains and the ability to reason. Islaam is logical and easy to understand. So therefore...Of course Allah can do anything He wishes, but I do not believe that He would change the past because of the above meant reasons.
 
Ümit said:
No I haven't...but just think about it...

1. What would be the benefit of changing the past? The past is to learn from...things happened in the past, mistakes, though times, etc, form life experience and is meant to learn from...sins can be forgiven instead of erased.

2. I don't want to be mean but if your past is a burden for you...then it means you can take it...just take your lesson from it, give it a place in your life and pick up your life again. Allah does not burden anyone more than he can take.

3. What would be the entire use of giving us free will if He could manipulate the made decisions anyways...so we have a free will, but in reality we haven't?...you have gone through things because of a reason...a reason you and I may not know, but Allah knows of course.

4. You cannot expect EVERYTHING to be described in Quraan and Sunnah. Allah gave us brains and the ability to reason. Islaam is logical and easy to understand. So therefore...Of course Allah can do anything He wishes, but I do not believe that He would change the past because of the above meant reasons.
Click to expand...
And the non-Muslims dare to tell us that we have to interpretate Islam literally without questioning it......

The truth is that The Holy Quran has metaphor, figuritive and literal. So it is not set on literal interpretation.
 
Nitro Zeus said:
And the non-Muslims dare to tell us that we have to interpretate Islam literally without questioning it......

The truth is that The Holy Quran has metaphor, figuritive and literal. So it is not set on literal interpretation.
Click to expand...

No...it is a mixture of literal and figurative interpretation. Yes it contains metaphores...but that doesn't mean everything in the Quraan must be interpreted literally or figuratively
..you still can reason.
In another thread we spoke about mountains prostrating before Allah. Of course this is not meant literally prostrating as we know it.

I will continue to repeat that the world we live in is a logical world. Everything is bound to laws of nature...and if we understand these laws...we can explain a certain phenomena...so if Allah has created everything...and therefore made everything logical and explainable...why would logic end there?...why should Islaam not be logical?
 
Ümit said:
No...it is a mixture of literal and figurative interpretation. Yes it contains metaphores...but that doesn't mean everything in the Quraan must be interpreted literally or figuratively
..you still can reason.
In another thread we spoke about mountains prostrating before Allah. Of course this is not meant literally prostrating as we know it.

I will continue to repeat that the world we live in is a logical world. Everything is bound to laws of nature...and if we understand these laws...we can explain a certain phenomena...so if Allah has created everything...and therefore made everything logical and explainable...why would logic end there?...why should Islaam not be logical?
Click to expand...
I have never said that nor I believe that Islam isn't logic but this idea I got from non-Muslims. No wonders why they make articles such as "scientific errors of Quran"! This is because they love to interpretate literally and without questioning. Since when have they become experts of Islam!?? This is not acceptable! I do not see any scientific error in Quran for I use logic and reason and I do not do what sheyteen are doing.
 
In my opinion Allah can change the past and you pray to him there’s a chance that he will change your past like make that event not happen in the first place literally.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top