Can you get those fish to fly?

  • Thread starter Thread starter أحمد
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 49
  • Views Views 9K

Are you willing to take action for the cause of uniting the Muslim Ummah?

  • Total voters
    0
:sl:

I agree with Br. azim's post; this thread, if anything, seems to be dividing more than uniting anyone. I only just understood what was being said here, and so I apologise for the late reply, but I am quite surprised. Why should we disregard "history books" as you called them, when they were written by some of the greatest scholars in our past?

If anything, we should be learning from such books of knowledge as a step towards increasing our understanding of Islaam and uniting the Ummah thereby.

:w:
 
Muhammad said:
:sl:

I agree with Br. azim's post; this thread, if anything, seems to be dividing more than uniting anyone. I only just understood what was being said here, and so I apologise for the late reply, but I am quite surprised. Why should we disregard "history books" as you called them, when they were written by some of the greatest scholars in our past?

If anything, we should be learning from such books of knowledge as a step towards increasing our understanding of Islaam and uniting the Ummah thereby.

:w:
Click to expand...

:sl:

Have you actually read the first poat in this thread? It is not about disregarding the books, it is about getting people to actually start considering them, because at the moment all that can be seen is people teaching eachother lies to cover up the truth. To cover up one lie, many lies are told; until what people are taught becomes currupt.

If people do not wake up and read what these books say, then there will be more problems when it comes to history and hadeeth.

:w:
 
:sl:

I am sorry, perhaps I misunderstood you; I think I got that impression from the poll. It is unlikely that anyone will vote for the last 4 options unless they are non-Muslim.
 
Muhammad said:
:sl:

I am sorry, perhaps I misunderstood you; I think I got that impression from the poll. It is unlikely that anyone will vote for the last 4 options unless they are non-Muslim.
Click to expand...

:sl:

The poll is there to get people to think, not merely to just see what people might vote for. They might actually at some point see the importance of picking up the book and reading what it says. There is still plenty of knowledge stored in those books, we just have to read them.

:w:
 
azim said:
Asalamu alaykum.

Regarding sectarian issues, I think it is a very good idea to restrict their discussion. Why? Look around the forum, there is a large number of youngsters, many of whom perhaps know little about different sects, their history etc... If they want to learn about the different sects, there is plenty of information in the respective sub-sections and on the internet in general.

The point is, sectarian issues should be discussed by those who have knowledge (deep knowledge). It shouldnt be discussed by youngsters and teenagers (even they might have an excellent understanding of the deen and history of Islam etc...) because its not our place to discuss it.

What benefit could come from allowing sectarian discussions?
Click to expand...

Asalaamualaikum

agreed.
 
Ummah said:
Quote:
Originally Posted by azim
Asalamu alaykum.

Regarding sectarian issues, I think it is a very good idea to restrict their discussion. Why? Look around the forum, there is a large number of youngsters, many of whom perhaps know little about different sects, their history etc... If they want to learn about the different sects, there is plenty of information in the respective sub-sections and on the internet in general.

The point is, sectarian issues should be discussed by those who have knowledge (deep knowledge). It shouldnt be discussed by youngsters and teenagers (even they might have an excellent understanding of the deen and history of Islam etc...) because its not our place to discuss it.

What benefit could come from allowing sectarian discussions?


Asalaamualaikum

agreed.
Click to expand...

:sl:

Can we get back to the topic now?

:w:
 
Eddi said:
:sl: Do you have a recorded or written version to your talk about the apple tree (from last year)?
Click to expand...

:sl:

I haven't, but I can try to get hold of it from someone Insha-Allah. Or I can write another version of it; I still remember the topic.

:w:
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top