Oh my God, but does Q'uran allow punishment to death? Doesn't Q'uran prohibit killing people no matter what mistake they did? Shouldn't the punishment be left to God??
you are misinderstanding ^^ let me please explain this and clear it out to you , by the way most of answers are based in opinions without real knowledge
i will give you an example like cutting the hand if someone steals,when you read it and have no knowledge about it you would be scared, wouldnt you?^^ but under this rule
you have many things actually, if they catch the stealer there are many things they have to deal with,like the things that have been stolen have to be expensive and there have to be no problems
between the stealer and the victim.for example if the stealer stole something because the victim have some problems with him or he orders him money or anything like that then there will be no punishment.If the victim does not care about his money or his stuff.For example if he put his money in a taple in the restaurant and show it for all people or if he does something that makes the stealer thinks to steal or any things like that,then there will be no punishment.If the victim forgives him its fine.However there are many things i really forgot because i studied it when i was in high school in Saudi Arabia.i can tell you 99% of stealers,their hands are not cutting down,its just to scare them and let them think ^^
let us move to cheating,its the same things, its to scare people and prevent them from doing that.I will give you some things that have to be done before they judge
first of all.there have to be 3 witnesses ant these 3 witnesses have to see the boy or the girl in their eyes,not just because they see them naked, its not enough,even if they see them
kissing each others it still not enough and they will be asked a question what did you see exaaaaactly,each one of them will be asked alone,if there is a very small contradiction then there will be no punishment ^^ and these witnesses have to be good people and righteous and they have no bad history.Actually the things i just mentioned you know its impossible really
you will never have these things except for few very few.
i will tell you a story of the prophet mohammed so that you may understand . a woman came to the prophet peace be upon him and told him i did zina she was mohsanah wich means married
and the prophet mohammed did not respond and she repeted it and the prophet was kindful he does not want to do it and he did try that the woman may just go back then the woman said please i want to clean my sin and i am pregnant from that and she also said do you want to reject me as you reject maez then the prophet respond and said go until you he or she gets born,
after that she came back and said ok this is the child i want you to clean my sin completely and he looked at the child and said go back and take care of him until he grow up then she came back and ask him and he did it because she wants it to clean the sin completely.
i hope you get the clear answer,there is no singal contradiction in the quran the problem is that you are talking without knoeledge ^^ so please be careful before you judge
there are many kind of sins in islam some are high some are low
high like,if you kill other person then there will be a punishment in this life because its a big sin, and it causes a lot of problems if there is no strict punishment for it. sounds good?
and if you want to remove the sin so that there will be no punishment in the hereafter like zina.
low, you can just ask for forgiveness and God willing it will be accepted
i suggest that you learn,it might give you better understanding in many aspects in islam
i hope this is helpful and sorry for my bad English ^^
That's not fair, to me.
