Did The Prophet ever Kill?

[Ghazi]

Salaam

This question has been ask on another fourm but I wasn't too sure about the answer so could someone answer this, jazzakallah.

 

[Najiullah]

Salaam

This question has been ask on another fourm but I wasn't too sure about the answer so could someone answer this, jazzakallah.

i dont know why people ask scuh questions????

anywaz bro i dont think so...............
i dont think its possible as he is Rehmat ul lil alameen ( sorry about the spelling );D

 

[IceQueen~]

the brother's right-why do people ask such questions?
the prophet (saw)was a walking talking quran and anything he did was by Allah's will and according to His laws.

 

[Ghazi]

the brother's right-why do people ask such questions?
the prophet (saw)was a walking talking quran and anything he did was by Allah's will and according to His laws.

Salaam

I'm talking about times in jihad the prophet participated and allah has allowed killing in situations but he tells us not to kill unjustly. It's good to know such things imagine you were ask this by a non-muslim what would you say.

 

[IceQueen~]

I am not sure but during battles I think he(SAW) may have killed...

whatever he did he never did without good reason! once there were some evil prisoners and the prophet (saw) and the muslims did not know whether to kill them or what..
they discussed the matter and umer (r) said they should be killed but the porphet (SAW) and abu bakr were soft hearted and thought other wise.
then Allah revealed that He was angry because they should have been killed but since the muslims had done 'mashwara' (consultation) He had mercy on them.
what does this show about the prophet(SAW)'s character?!
what about what happened at 'ta'if'? he was stoned so badly and bleeding that his shoes were stuck in his sandals! even then what did he say? he(SAW) said ''O Allah forgive them! they do not know what they are doing..''

even when the angel of the mountains came and said whether he should crush the people of 'ta'if' between the mountains, the prophet (SAW) was so merciful he said no, perhaps from their offspring will become muslims..

 

[Najiullah]

whatever he did he never did without good reason! once there were some evil prisoners ..........................................what does this show about the prophet(SAW)'s character?!
what about what happened at ......................................................

the prophet (SAW) was so merciful he said no, perhaps from their offspring will become muslims..

JazakALLAh i agree with you sister

 

[Ghazi]

LOL... nobody is disputing the character of the prophet Muhammad, we know that everything he ever did was from Allah. It is just a question of whether the he (SAW) ever killed anyone. To me it seems likeley in battle perhaps...

Salaam

Yeah were not questioning his character or intention just asking did he kill or not?

 

[MetSudaisTwice]

salam
to win a battle are you not required to kill? you cant jus stand there with a sword in your hands and not use it
wasalam

 

[Ghazi]

salam
to win a battle are you not required to kill? you cant jus stand there with a sword in your hands and not use it
wasalam

Salaam

So did he?

 

[IceQueen~]

OK this is tricky business here-someone go call a scholar!

 

[MetSudaisTwice]

salam
allahu alam, if we dont know for sure, then why speculate?
wasalam

 

[IceQueen~]

salam
allahu alam, if we dont know for sure, then why speculate?
wasalam

masha allah akhee, well said!

 

[Ghazi]

salam
allahu alam, if we dont know for sure, then why speculate?
wasalam

Salaam

Gaining knowladge the question was put to me and I wasn't sure so I'd thought I'd ask on this fourm.

 

[IceQueen~]

Salaam

Gaining knowladge the question was put to me and I wasn't sure so I'd thought I'd ask on this fourm.

what metsudaistwice means to say is that if we don't know then we shouldn't say things. we need a scholar here who can give us the truth insha allah!

 

[Ghazi]

what metsudaistwice means to say is that if we don't know then we shouldn't say things. we need a scholar here who can give us the truth insha allah!

Salaam

I see, but I don't think we need a scholar just someone fimilar with certain battles that took place for example Badar and Uhud.

 

[MetSudaisTwice]

salam
that is what i mean, it is safer and wiser to ask someone of ilm to answer your questions, rather than people speculating and misleadin intentionally or unintentionally
wasalam

 

[IceQueen~]

Salaam

I see, but I don't think we need a scholar just someone fimilar with certain battles that took place for example Badar and Uhud.

yes that can be supported with hadith insha allah.

 

[Najiullah]

we need a scholar here who can give us the truth insha allah!

i cant find anything on net about this , yeah sis we really need a scholar here

 

[MetSudaisTwice]

salam
imams and ulama's have studied islam and deen in depth, inshallah if you ask your local imam he will be able to tell you inshallah
wasalam

 

[IceQueen~]

hey check this site out- ithink it may have some answers insha allah: http://www.muslimaccess.com/articles/misc/prophet_bravery.asp