Disappointment with God

trinity is absolutely not monotheistic. there is no way three can equal one. ask any person who knows a bit of math and they will tell you.

(BTW this post is just one-third of a post and three of my posts will be equal to one post.)

Hi Yahya Sulaiman

I will get back to you soon.


Hi Muhabe

Thanks for your kind words. Because the stomach caner was discovered in the early stage, it was successfully treated without surgery or chemotherapy. Besides this problem, I also had a separate surgery in which a tumor was removed from my lower abdomen. The official biopsy test (which was sent to France from Canada for further analysis) said it could be either malignant or benign. It sounded strange at first, but at least it did not say the tumor was malignant. As I mentioned in the first post of this thread, all things have returned to what they were before except two things: surgery scars and the heart. Yes, I have become a new person with a new heart! Before the trials I was full of disappointment, frustration and bitterness about my situation, myself and, most of all, God. As a result of my struggle with the disease and with doubt and questions about my own belief, I have become a true worshipper of God full of joy, thanks and freedom. Now I thank God even for the cancer I suffered from. Because of the disease, I learned to love and trust my God more, learned to be more thankful for everything, learned to have more compassion for other people, learned to resist better the temptation of lust and selfishness. God’s words have an amazing power that turned my anger, disappointment and fear into joy, thanks and freedom. Now to me, my faith is not a religion anymore, but a personal loving relationship with God. Now to me, worshiping means enjoying God as fully as possible, and expressing my joy and thanks to him in most genuine ways.

Back to your persistent comments, we do not worship 3 gods. We worship only one God that has been revealed to the world in different ways (the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit). Of course you should not think the Father has the biological Son. It would be absurd to say that Jesus was born as a result of physical relationship between God and a woman. Jesus (the Word) was with the Father before the creation. Jesus already existed long before he became flesh.In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was with God in the beginning. Through him all things were made; without him nothing was made that has been made.” (John 1:1-3) Here the Word means Jesus. When we call Jesus as the Son, it refers to the relationship between them, not a biological one.

Several readers have made the following comment to me, “1 God (the Father)+1 God (the Son)+1 God (the Holy Spirit) = 3 Gods. Therefore Christians worship three Gods.” But it comes from your confusion about deity and non-deity. You are applying non-deity mathematics to deity. We cannot compare deity with non-deity. Deity is eternal, while non-deity is mortal. Deity is perfect, while non-deity is imperfect. Deity is pure, while non-deity is impure. The difference between deity and non-deity is like sky and land, and in fact even more. Non-deity is like finite, while deity is like infinity. For non-deity mathematics, 1 + 1 + 1 = 3. But deity mathematics, infinity + infinity + infinity = infinity, not 3 infinities. There is no such thing as 3 infinities. Please do not use non-deity mathematics to deity, which would be very inappropriate.
 
i guess if i was really struggling i could kinda justify a trinity in example...

god says if you are two the he is a third and if you are three then he is a fourth.

you could say jesus peace and blessings be upon him was strengthened by the spirit.

2+1 = 3, not counting anyone else in the room.

i also could use that example to further explain the way muslims believe in the crusification of christ...

imagine two people who are accused and tortured daily.. both are there for a reason and both represent the will of god. sooner or later you would not be able to tell the difference between them. well i know i would try and be as he was (peace and blessings be upon him)

really random conjecture but i mean no malice or mischief, just really random thoughts... too much spare time.
 
Several readers have made the following comment to me, “1 God (the Father)+1 God (the Son)+1 God (the Holy Spirit) = 3 Gods. Therefore Christians worship three Gods.” But it comes from your confusion about deity and non-deity. You are applying non-deity mathematics to deity. We cannot compare deity with non-deity. Deity is eternal, while non-deity is mortal. Deity is perfect, while non-deity is imperfect. Deity is pure, while non-deity is impure. The difference between deity and non-deity is like sky and land, and in fact even more. Non-deity is like finite, while deity is like infinity. For non-deity mathematics, 1 + 1 + 1 = 3. But deity mathematics, infinity + infinity + infinity = infinity, not 3 infinities. There is no such thing as 3 infinities. Please do not use non-deity mathematics to deity, which would be very inappropriate.

I often wonder if the "1+1+1=1" cliche has any usefulness at all except to the Christians coming up with cute answers to it. You'll notice no one in this thread (at least, I don't think) has actually used it. The real issue is something more like "1=3". But ultimately argumentation about the Trinity is useless since it yields only flawed analogies on both sides and can always be ducked out of by the Christian whom we are attempting to reason with, using the classic tactic of "first I defend it based on the Muslim's purported misunderstanding of it, then based on its incomprehensibility, then claim knowledge of misunderstanding again, then play the beyond-human-comprehension card again, shifting my ground back and forth between the two mutually exclusive options whenever it is necessary."

I suggest that we stop here with the Trinity. The subject is quicksand. The amount of mental fortification (with rationalization and semantics) necessary to maintain the belief is almost impossible to be overcome by another person. I have generally observed the average Trinitarian to seem more likely to give up all of Christianity than to allow himself to listen to reason about this one particular optional doctrine of the religion.
 
Last edited:
The official biopsy test (which was sent to France from Canada for further analysis) said it could be either malignant or benign. It sounded strange at first


There is nothing strange about that, sometimes the bx is equivocal either the surgeon didn't get a good sample or didn't take a biopsy which includes the margins also inflammatory and fibrotic lesions can be confused for malignancy. I wouldn't call having a cancer or non-cancer a leeway to renew or drop out of faith. If you love God and believe in God's grace and mercy that will be the case in the difficult and lean times--surely death will ensue for every living being will you then stop your beliefs? I am not sure if you are using your experience to cajole the reader that the particular man/god you prayed to saved you whereas if you'd prayed to odin you'd have had a different outcome-- and if that is your intent then I feel sorry for you indeed.. I see many people given 2 months to live go on to live another 7 years, atheists though they maybe. God doesn't need us to believe, and god is in no need for our prayers, or fast or adoration. If you do good you do it for your own soul and if you do bad again it is for your own soul!

all the best
 
i honestly think our hearts are what leads us to God, which you also seem to believe.


I think our bodies which are created by God also indicate by its many reactions such as falling ill due to what God forbids and feeling shy of what God forbids are signs of the one true God.


Islam manifests all of these for us, therefore both heart - mind - soul - and body... all point towards islam being the truth.


I only posted this because i detested your saying "A FEW LINES". i know your refering to the Quran, Hadith and other religious scriptures.

These scriptures arent just a few lines my friend... they really arent.
 
no matter how much you say that trinity doesn't mean three separate beings, the truth is that everything in your scriptures shows that jesus, God, and the holy spirit were separate beings and could in no way be one. jesus cried out to God, according to your bible, asking why God forsaked him. that clearly shows two things: 1. Jesus didn't have the power to save himself from the people. If he were divine, he'd have been extremely powerful and no human would have been able to capture him. he'd have been able to fly, he'd have a body stronger than steel so even a bullet wouldn't have harmed him (think superman). 2. Jesus and God aren't the same being. Jesus is a separate being from God.

The only way you can say you are monotheist is if you believe Jesus is God and there is no other God other than Jesus. But if you believe that there is Jesus and there is God then you are believing in two different Gods.
 
Last edited:
no matter how much you say that trinity doesn't mean three separate beings, the truth is that everything in your scriptures shows that jesus, God, and the holy spirit were separate beings and could in no way be one. jesus cried out to God, according to your bible, asking why God forsaked him. that clearly shows two things: 1. Jesus didn't have the power to save himself from the people. If he were divine, he'd have been extremely powerful and no human would have been able to capture him. he'd have been able to fly, he'd have a body stronger than steel so even a bullet wouldn't have harmed him (think superman). 2. Jesus and God aren't the same being. Jesus is a separate being from God.

The only way you can say you are monotheist is if you believe Jesus is God and there is no other God other than Jesus. But if you believe that there is Jesus and there is God then you are believing in two different Gods.

no matter how much you say that trinity doesn't mean three separate beings, the truth is that everything in your scriptures shows that jesus, God, and the holy spirit were separate beings and could in no way be one.

jesus peace and blessings be upon him was a prophet... so inherently linked to god.
the fact that the spirit was a seperate entity does not detract from anything... if it was with him his whole life then who knew him better?
also the spirit was inherently linked to god.. so still no division.
also god... what can i say?

the fact that he peace and blessings be upon him cried out shows you who he was..seemingly without the spirit and seemingly without god.
he was a man that shouldered the problems of the whole world.. like all prophets did, peace and blessings be upon them.

you make the superhero analogy and for one thing.. its probably harder to stand up when you know you are not bulletproof.
i guess when he comes back the next time we should pray he is bulletproof, maybe he can break the laws of gravity...maybe he can break the world as we know it.
then we might not reject him...but we will as is always the case for the masses.
 
The difference between deity and non-deity is like sky and land, and in fact even more. Non-deity is like finite, while deity is like infinity. For non-deity mathematics, 1 + 1 + 1 = 3. But deity mathematics, infinity + infinity + infinity = infinity, not 3 infinities. There is no such thing as 3 infinities. Please do not use non-deity mathematics to deity, which would be very inappropriate.


So here you are saying Jesus is infinity, but the fact is Jesus was born, and (according to you) he died.
So he had a beginning and he had an end.
Does not sound like an infinity to me.
 
"Diety-mathematics"?!!!!
Christian apologetics is amusingly entertaining......

As for the Torah----Ask any Rabbi---The Torah does not have the concept of "original sin"---its purely a Christian re-interpretation.

how about this equation

original sin + crucifixion = salvation

but if you take out the original sin---there is no need for crucifixion or the resulting salvation......or is it that anything logical and reasonable isnt "diety-math" enough for a Christian?
 
if God couldn't forgive the original sin without a sacrifice (according to christians) then every sin would need a sacrifice. the original sin wasn't such a great sin compared to other sins, like murder. So what do Christians say about that? Between the creation of Adam (AS) and the birth of Jesus ppl must have committed millions of far terrible sins, why weren't there sacrifices for those? Also, if humans inherited Adam and Eve's sin, then does that mean we inherit our parents' sins and should be punished for them by God?
 
if God couldn't forgive the original sin without a sacrifice (according to christians) then every sin would need a sacrifice. the original sin wasn't such a great sin compared to other sins, like murder. So what do Christians say about that? Between the creation of Adam (AS) and the birth of Jesus ppl must have committed millions of far terrible sins, why weren't there sacrifices for those? Also, if humans inherited Adam and Eve's sin, then does that mean we inherit our parents' sins and should be punished for them by God?


There are more holes in christianity theology than a sieve after being attacked by a hive of moth. The more you study christianity closely, the more questions it cannot answer.
And all these stemmed from one act: elevating a human, albeit a very very special human, into an equal of God.
 
Just my own opinion. The Christian concept of entering Heaven is similar to going to the movie theater. To get in you need to pay the ticket price. If you can not afford the price you get rich uncle Charlie to cough up the money for you.

I do not see this as forgiveness. forgiveness erases all debt and their is no longer a price to be paid. To be forgiven we need only to repent fully and strive to become loyal servants of Allaah(swt). When our repentance is accepted, there is no longer any bill to pay, we no longer need to pay the purchase price as there is no charge for Allaah(swt)'s mercy.
 
Guys, you’re kind of swamping him. Let me help so that he no longer has any excuse not to indeed “be back with me soon”. Because I think that I know what he will respond:

muhaba said:
no matter how much you say that trinity doesn't mean three separate beings, the truth is that everything in your scriptures shows that jesus, God, and the holy spirit were separate beings and could in no way be one. jesus cried out to God, according to your bible, asking why God forsaked him. that clearly shows two things: 1. Jesus didn't have the power to save himself from the people. If he were divine, he'd have been extremely powerful and no human would have been able to capture him. he'd have been able to fly, he'd have a body stronger than steel so even a bullet wouldn't have harmed him (think superman). 2. Jesus and God aren't the same being. Jesus is a separate being from God.

Here he’ll either ignore what you said altogether about crying out to God, or brush it off as the prophecy from psalm 22, as always leaving the important missing context from the “prophecy” omitted or, if particularly desperate, pulling a far out “metaphorical” interpretation out to justify it. I’ve already said too much because this thread is likely now to be derailed on Psalm 22, but I guess it’s a risk I’ll have to take. As for the rest he’ll obviously tell you that there’s no problem with God being killed if He’s willingly let Himself be killed (even though he still hasn’t explained why this should have to be the case—and has all but ceded the point to me, in fact), and therefore it wouldn’t diminish His abilities. Which technically speaking it wouldn’t. He may hit you with a swarm of biblical quotations (the same ones you always hear) supposedly establishing the incarnation doctrine in response to the "everything in your scriptures shows that jesus, God, and the holy spirit were separate beings" part.

naidamar said:
So here you are saying Jesus is infinity, but the fact is Jesus was born, and (according to you) he died. So he had a beginning and he had an end. Does not sound like an infinity to me.

Here he’ll hit you with the opening of John and the elaborate labyrinths of semantics Christian theology have built up around it. Getting back into square one Trinity territory here, so expect the discussion to eventually go in a circle when he does so.

siam said:
"Diety-mathematics"?!!!! Christian apologetics is amusingly entertaining......

As for the Torah----Ask any Rabbi---The Torah does not have the concept of "original sin"---its purely a Christian re-interpretation.

how about this equation

original sin + crucifixion = salvation

but if you take out the original sin---there is no need for crucifixion or the resulting salvation......or is it that anything logical and reasonable isnt "diety-math" enough for a Christian?

To answer your last question (speaking as myself again), yes. To answer as I’m sure truth finder will, there are certain passages in the Old Testament which are often touted by Christians to that end and I may even be able to guess which ones he’ll cite, not that it matters since, as you have pointed out, during thousands of years of Judaism nobody ever took them in such a way as to indicate original sin until the Christians started touting it.

if God couldn't forgive the original sin without a sacrifice (according to christians) then every sin would need a sacrifice. the original sin wasn't such a great sin compared to other sins, like murder. So what do Christians say about that? Between the creation of Adam (AS) and the birth of Jesus ppl must have committed millions of far terrible sins, why weren't there sacrifices for those? Also, if humans inherited Adam and Eve's sin, then does that mean we inherit our parents' sins and should be punished for them by God?

The Bible goes back and forth and back and forth on the subject of whether people should be unfairly punished for their parents’ sins, so I don’t know what he’ll say about that. Probably he’ll ignore most of your post and just give a “general answer” that Christ (P) paid for all sins period on the cross. He may use some loaded analogy to this end. Never mind the fact that even if there were any reason for someone else to have to pay for our sins, it would absurd to think of them all being paid for by a few acts of torture and an unusually brief crucifixion.

Let me guess: the “he was suffering his whole life, not just on the cross” comeback? I don’t see 30-35 years as doing the trick either.

But once again, the important issue is whether or not the trick needs to be done. I repeat:

YahyaSulaiman said:
Forgiveness is not one person paying another person's debt but the debt being simply erased, by one who does not need anything and has no reason to demand anything except our own repentance. There is no escaping the basic fact of the contradiction in terms in pardoning entailing or containing punishment, whatever Old Testament re-interpretations you may pull out in a vain attempt to justify it…Nor is the other inevitable defense, which I'm sure is next on your itenerary--the vague and circular appeal to "the law"--going to fly. Say that you heard of a judge pardoning a guilty man from his death sentence and, with the very next bang of his gavel, sentencing himself to death in the culprit's stead. You ask what on earth is going on and your friend told you, "That's the law, so it's gotta be like this. They used to do something similar in the old days and this is just the continuation and consummation of it." What would your reaction be? To think that the story about the judge probably isn't true, especially given what you believe about the judge's wisdom and moral character? To think that there is something seriously wrong with the law and tradition being spoken of, and therefore that if someone told you that a person of the judge’s wisdom and character wrote that law himself then they were obviously wrong? Or would you just shrug and go, “Oh well, if it’s the law….” You are regarding grace lightly. That's the main problem with Christianity: it has to compromise the idea by tempering it with its mutually exclusive opposite…The judge doesn't have any way of knowing for certain whether someone's repentance is sincere; God does. If the judge did too then it would probably be best for him to accept a sincere one, yes, very much so.

EDIT: Brother Woodrow actually put it pretty well himself just as I was posting this! Well, how do you like that?
 
Last edited:
i kinda get the concept of original sin,
so people are inclined towards sin by nature.. this is true.

the quran says that mankind is nothing but insolence and competition, by our very nature.
although it does not say we are sinful by nature im sure you would all agree we are. (if you do not then thats really funny)

"In the theology of the Catholic Church, original sin is regarded as the general condition of sinfulness, that is (the absence of holiness and perfect charity) into which humans are born, distinct from the actual sins that a person commits"

thats from wiki and i kinda agree.

i know as kids we are supposedly closest to god.. but i know how i was when i was a kid :sorry::phew

anyway the only way forward is to our death and ressurection and finally judgement.. no bribes taken and little intercession.
 
Hi readers

I am very sorry for very late reply since I have been extremely busy these days. I hope to catch up with your replies. I have opened this thread to hear about your own personal stories of spiritual journey with God by starting with my own. As many of you have already read the first post, I was very disappointed with God at some point of my life, and my anger and bitterness against God were boiling inside my heart. As I said, I did not reveal it to others for fear that I would be ridiculed or rejected by them. I just shared my (shameful) past personal spiritual experience with you to ask you to share your own personal stories with me and other readers.

But quite a number of readers keep making some insulting comments to me and I had to get sidetracked to answer them in response to their comments. As I read some latest replies, several readers have made a comment on original sin. God expected Adam and Even to listen to Him, but they decided to give in to the temptation. God created us as human beings with free wills, not as robots, but we too often use our free wills doing sinful things. Although the Bible does not mention “original sin” by words, it is evident by reading the Bible and by observing how seemingly innocent babies behave. Young babies have never learned how to fight for toys from their parents or older siblings or TV. They have never had any bad influence from outside. But when they are put together with other babies, they automatically fight for the toys they want and try to take away toys from their competitors. Although at the beginning this greedy or sinful nature is not serious or cute if you wish to call it, surely it comes from the seed of sin because they were born with it.

As I mentioned, I opened this thread to share our honest spiritual experiences with God with each other, not to discuss the theology of Islam or Christianity. If you keep the contents of your reply to this direction, it would be greatly appreciated although you can make any comment as you wish.
 
Hi readers

I am very sorry for very late reply since I have been extremely busy these days. I hope to catch up with your replies. I have opened this thread to hear about your own personal stories of spiritual journey with God by starting with my own. As many of you have already read the first post, I was very disappointed with God at some point of my life, and my anger and bitterness against God were boiling inside my heart. As I said, I did not reveal it to others for fear that I would be ridiculed or rejected by them. I just shared my (shameful) past personal spiritual experience with you to ask you to share your own personal stories with me and other readers.

But quite a number of readers keep making some insulting comments to me and I had to get sidetracked to answer them in response to their comments. As I read some latest replies, several readers have made a comment on original sin. God expected Adam and Even to listen to Him, but they decided to give in to the temptation. God created us as human beings with free wills, not as robots, but we too often use our free wills doing sinful things. Although the Bible does not mention “original sin” by words, it is evident by reading the Bible and by observing how seemingly innocent babies behave. Young babies have never learned how to fight for toys from their parents or older siblings or TV. They have never had any bad influence from outside. But when they are put together with other babies, they automatically fight for the toys they want and try to take away toys from their competitors. Although at the beginning this greedy or sinful nature is not serious or cute if you wish to call it, surely it comes from the seed of sin because they were born with it.

As I mentioned, I opened this thread to share our honest spiritual experiences with God with each other, not to discuss the theology of Islam or Christianity. If you keep the contents of your reply to this direction, it would be greatly appreciated although you can make any comment as you wish.

I would like to share a trilogy with you. This trilogy is the true path of how a person found Christianity, embraced it dearly and never thought he would ever leave it.

The first part of the trilogy covers the first 40 or so years of the person's life. The second part covers the person's next 25 years and why the person left Christianity and the last part covers the past 5 years.

It is a long read, but perhaps it may explain some things to you.

My path to Christianity and the road to becoming an Evangelist

I thought I was born Christian. I was raised in a very religious family during a time of great hardship.WW2 had not yet started and the USA was still suffering the effects of the great depression, My family and community was devoutly Roman Catholic and predominatly Lithuanian/Polish. To add to the hardsip my father was drafted into the Army shortly after the USA became involved in the war. That was the last time I saw him. Although we were quite poor my mother raised us to always have faith in God and He would provide. That belief has remained a strong part of my life.

I was raised as a proper Catholic, having been Baptized a few days after birth, receiving First Communion at the age of 7 and being confirmed at the age of 12. I attended mass daily, recieved communion every Sunday and was an avid Catechism student. After my confirmation I joined CYO and like many served as an alter boy. I learned sufficient Latin to understand the Gregorian Mass which was the standard high mass on Sunday. Like many young Catholic boys my ambition was to be a Priest. At the age of 18 I joined the Knights of Columbus, shortly after I was accepted as a seminarian at .St. Thomas Seminary in Bloomfield, CT. I lasted one semester and decided the priesthood was not for me and dropped out.

I proceeded to my second love, aviation. I applied for and was accepted for the Aviation Cadet Program of the USAF. After completing training at Lackland and Kelly Airforce Bases near San Antonio TX I was commissioned a 2nd Lieutenant and was officially the proud pilot of an F-86. I had a very strange military career much of what it is best I do not share. I will only say I often did not fly in military uniform and often the planes I flew did not have USA markings. In 1963 I was flying a mission that took me at very low level over Hanoi in what was then North Vietnam. I picked up small arms fire from the ground and realized blood was filling my flight suit. When I felt the pain in my leg. I felt my best option was to climb to a higher elevation and attempt to reach Da Nang. As I pulled my plane upwards I lost conciousness. Some how the plane made it out over the Gulf of Tonkin, and miracuosly pancaked instead of nose diving into the Gult. I went down a matter of yards from a US submarine that had just surfaced. I was visually seen to go down and was pulled from my plane without even getting wet. I remained in a coma for the next three months or so..Over the next year I was moved to several different hospitals the last one being in Louisiana. After being discharged from the hospital I was found to be no longer physically fit to fly and lost my commission and flying status. I did want to remain in the Air force and was pemitted to re-enlist at an enlisted rank. This sent me on a 4 year journey that took me to many places. One place was Morocco and while there I enrolled in the University of Rabat to learn Arabic. Several other events in my life also took place. I became totally convinced that Catholocism was not proper Christianity. I had strong love for Jesus and sincerly felt I was spared so that I could find my place to serve Jesus. But I knew Catholocism was not the path. I began a search.

My search led me first to the Baptist Church, which I did love. but somehow it did not feel right I sensed I was on the right search, but had not reached my destination.Over the next few years I stumbled from denomination to denomination always looking. In 1968 I chanced upon a small Assembly of God church in Waskom, TX. My first meeting I felt overwhelmed by the presence of the holy spirit and by my second visit I was speaking in tongues. the feeling was beyond description, but I knew God had sent the Holy Spirit to work in me. Very soon I was Baptized in water and felt I had found my way to serve Jesus,

Because of my familiarity with the Arabic Language, some knowledge of North Africa and the mideast it was natural that one day I would become a Missionary to the region. first I established a very good reputation as a preacher and pastor, I also became quite good at evangelism in the States. Before long my dream came true and I began my evangelism in Morocco. Which was like returning home. I already had friends there and I knew that the people were very hospitable and tolerant of Christians. .

Over time I broke free from all denominational barriers and began Evangeliizng throughout the Islamic Nations. leading the lost to the truth of Christianity. I felt complete and finally serving Jesus as I had always wanted to and was given the strength and means through the ever present spirit of the Holy spirit. Amen


Christian to Agnostic

It is not a clear time line as to when I first began questioning the truth of Christianity. I deeply loved Jesus and still do. I fought the idea for a long time that Christianity was in error. It was something I did not want to consider. To me Christianity and the Bible were obvious tuths and even more certain then the sun will rise in the morning.

To me Christianity was the only path and any error was the result of man and the mistakes of some denominations. The bible was true, but man often misused it. resulting in many denominations some of which had strayed far from the truth. But, in spite of this the thought that the bible might be in error was unthinkable.

Denominations were the problem, if there was any problem. I can recall an incident in Agadir, Morocco. A very charismatic preacher was holding a gigantic tent revival and a call for Muslims to come to Christ. Each night the tent was filled to capacity with an overflowing,enthusiastic crowd. It was quite an exciting event. On the next to the last night of the revival he asked all of the crowd to return on the last night and to bring their Qur'ans. with them. The next night several hundred if not over 1,000 arrived with their Qur'ans. He asked them to stack them in a pile. They did so, he then poured kerosene over them and lit the pile the revival quickly ended as a near riot. He then discovered that what he had burned was a stack of bibles, he had not been aware that in the Darija Arabic the word Qur'an is used for any religious book. He was also unaware that Agadir is a city with a very large Arabic speaking Christian population. His entire revival was composed of Christians and not Muslims as he thought. This gave me a very dramatic lesson in the importance of fully understanding the people you preach to. It also made me wonder how and why Jesus would call such ignorant people to spread his word..


I knew it was impossible to study each and every one of the 30,000+ known denominations in depth to discover which was true. This led me to believe the only path was the bible based path untethered by denominational idiosyncrasies. The only way to Christ was through the Bible alone, the teaching of man only caused confusion. This necessitated a thorough study of the bible from it's origin to it's translations. The Bible had to be infallible as it was the true Word of God. As I studied the Bible more in depth and searching back through older translations including the Koine Greek. I became aware of how little the bible is composed of words from God, it is nearly all the words of man.The questions began to come. What was the basis for the particular books in the NT selected by the Council of Nicea as true and so many others were cast aside as being Gnostic? Why is it that no copies of any book in Aramaic exists or even mentioned. Aramaic was the common language of the time. Hebrew had stopped being a spoken language at about the time of Isiah and Koine greek was used mostly by the educated and along with Latin for legal decrees..Looking deeper into the NT I can find none of the characteristics of the metaphorical thought processes consistent with semitic people. Could it be the NT does not contain any books written by Jewish followers of Jesus? I always thought the followers of Jesus were Jews and considered themselves as pious Jews.

Another experiment took place, using the Red Letter editions of the KJV and the New Revised I wrote out only the words believed to have been exact quotes of Jesus and reading them without the comments by the alleged authors, the NT takes on a meaning much different than what is taught as Christianity. There is no concept of the Trinity nor that Jesus is the Son of God. There is no religion called Christianity. We have individual people calling themselves Christians but each following their own interpretations of what they want Christianity to be.The concept of a trinity and of god having a son were common beliefs among the ancient Greeks, Romans and Hindus. The new testament is composed of books selected by Romans and Greeks, could it be Christianity was merged with pagan beliefs? A thought I wanted to disbelieve..

Further study and more praying for guidance from the Holy spirit and many prayers for Jesus to remove all doubts from my thoughts. This was not what I wanted. I sincerely wanted to continue believing Jesus was the son of God and that he died on the cross for my sins to be forgiven.

It was all to no avail. the more I studied the more I came to understand that the Christianity I loved was no more real than Santa Claus, the Tooth Fairy or the Easter Bunny. Christianity is simply a revised version of Greek/Roman mythology perpetrated by Greeks and Romans to revive a dieing myth.

I can no longer sincerely call myself a Christian. While I still have strong belief in God verified by the many miracles in my life I can not find any instruction as to how to worship God or How Jesus fits into the picture. I have to be honest and adopt the label of agnostic, but while I continue my search to find the true way to serve God I will simply live the life style of the Buddhist which essentially follow the pricnciples of a Christian life but, without the worship. Contrary to popular belief True Buddhism is not a religion it is a philosophical method of living a moral life.



My Third and Final Testimony

The third testimony is how Islam found me and I returned home to where I belong. That I have posted on the forum several times in a short synopsis.
I will share the long version with you here

In my early years one of my interests was the study of languages. among the languages I learned was Arabic. However I studied in Morocco at the University of Rabat and learned the Darija Dialect, which unfortunately is not understood in much of the Arabic speaking world. But the written Arabic is the same world wide no matter what dialect you speak, so it was not a total loss.

I first learned of Islam to any extent while I was a Pilot in the USAF. One thing we were taught was how to say the shahadah in Arabic. It was believed that if we were found by any Muslims after crashing and if we said the Shahadah we would be treated as friends.This was taught in the event we ever crashed in a Muslim Nations, Our flights often originated near the Mediterranean and we sometimes flew over the Islamic nations.

By the year 1988 I had very much given up on organized Christianity, although I still felt Christianity was the path to salvation. I no longer belonged to any church and considered myself agnostic although I called myself Buddhist. In 1989 I lost my first wife and in 1990 married my second wife. My children did not like my second wife and that became the last year I had contact with my children. My wife and I pretty much became wanderers around the world. I had sufficient personal income and savings so we could pretty much indulge our travel desires. We both also did as much evangelical work we could during this time. However, my preaching became plain simple Christianity with no denomination affiliation. It was a self paid venture with no sorces for any religious panphlets, bible etc except for my own wallet. Yet, there was always sufficient money to provide for any needed material.

In 2004 We were living in the small town of Tennessee Colony. Texas a very Red Neck town smack in the Center of the Bible Belt. I was diagnosed with lung cancer and began preparing for my final days. But my wife passed away suddenly just a few weeks after my diagnosis. I went into a very deep depression and began drinking quite heavily. In May of 2005 I realized the stupidity of my drunken binge sobered up and set forth to regain control of my life. I began with a general clean up of the house. During my clean up I found my old Qur'an in Arabic that I had bought while I was a student at Rabat. I had bought it as a study guide to help me learn to read Arabic.

It had been many years since I had last read anything in Arabic. I was curious as to if I could still read it. I opened it to Surah Fatiha and the first line lieraly jumped out at me.

Bismillah ir Rahman ir Raheem. "In the name of Allaah, the provider, the Most merciful"

It was like the words glowed and completely filled me with an inner peace I never felt before.

I turned back to the fac page and saw:
“Auzu Billahi Mina Al Shaytan Al Rajeem”.
(In Allaah(swt) I seek refuge from the evils of Satan)

After over 20 years of not speaking Arabic it all flowed back to me. I coulc not stop reading and I was not simply reading words, the feeling of each ayyat came upon me with an indescribable warmth and sense of understanding. I could not stop. I do not know how long I read I know it was fro at least 48 hours and I still could not stop the feeling was so powerful and filling me with a strong sense of love and joy on the morning of what I believe was the 3rd day I finally set the Qur'an down and knew I was Muslim. I instantly said the Shahadah and knew I was now part of the Ummah. I did not even know if there were any Muslims in Texas much less if there were any Mosques.

I realized I was hungry and there was no food in the house. The nearest store was only a mile from me so I decided to walk down to it. When I entered the store there was a stranger from out of town. He was dark skinned. Our eyes met and he smiled and said "As salaamu Alaikum Akhi" without hesitation I answered back "Wa alaikum wa reamatullahi wa baraktuhu" He then asked "How long have you been Muslim, I answered about 15 minutes.

He then asked me if I had ever been in a Mosque, I said no. He then invited me to go to the Mosque in Tyler on Friday. I accepted. I later learned his name was Aadil and he had just moved to Texas from Pakistan. He had gotten lost and accidentally drove into Tennessee Colony, He had stopped at the store to get directions. Aadil and I became very close friends and still are although he has since moved back to Pakistan.

Things then moved so fast it became a blur. My youngest Daughter who I had not seen for 15 years called me on the telephone. She had been contacted by the VA and had learned they were concerned about my health. She insisted I move in with her family in Austin, which I did. The biggest surprise was finding out she had accepted Islam 10 years before and was married to a fine pious Muslim man and had 2 children I had never seen. A bigger surprise was soon to come. I discovered all of my children had reverted to Islam and all of my Grandchildren were Muslim.

My cancer was in remission for a while. In January of 2006 the cancer became active again. without treatment my prognosis was 3-4 months. I elected not to receive treatment and set about making my own funeral arraingements. In May for some reason I was still alive and accidentally stumbled across this forum. I joined and it became a source of purpose for me. Ramadan came and I was still alive. During Ramadan, came what I call the Beard miracle. People of my race have no facial hair or at most a few scattered whiskers(I am predominately Mongol)(Lithuanian Tatar-Lietuva Lipkas) I had never had to shave in my entire life. Yet on that Ramadan I grew a full, fist length, very thick beard. I still have the beard and although it has never been trimmed it is still the same length.

I am still alive and have not been back to any doctor since January 2006. I think I have lived past the 3-4 month prognosis.
 
Thanks for the long story. I can also find quite similar stories from Islam to Christianity. But I want to hear “your own personal” stories, not the stories of somebody else.
 
Thanks for the long story. I can also find quite similar stories from Islam to Christianity. But I want to hear “your own personal” stories, not the stories of somebody else.

I believe that is unc. Woodrow's personal story.

truthfinder, I believe everyone has their own miraculous story whether they realise it or not.
yours is far from unique.
 
Thanks for the long story. I can also find quite similar stories from Islam to Christianity. But I want to hear “your own personal” stories, not the stories of somebody else.

I am the author of that trilogy and that is my own story and words written by my own hand. That is my life story and why I am here on this forum.
 
I am the author of that trilogy and that is my own story and words written by my own hand. That is my life story and why I am here on this forum.

Please accept my sincere apology. I did not know you were the author. I will get back to you during the lunch time.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top