Do Muslims Believe Jesus Was Not Really Crucified?

[Predator]

Question ,you know the consequences of using the pronoun (he) ( he appeared to be so) ? it would bring the substitution theory on its face and reverse it..???????

because what (he) refers to then? it would be a reference to Jesus(not anyone else) , making jesus the one who appeared to them?!!!!!!

So you believe Ahmediyya theory that he was indeed put on the cross but was taken down alive and hence didnt die ?

 

[hasan2]

Now that you guys have wasted so much time, energy, forum space, etc. let me explain:
it doesn't really matter HOW Jesus died, just as long as his blood was spilled.

The only thing that matters is ... Jesus' blood was spilled, and he died.

 

[Woodrow]

Now that you guys have wasted so much time, energy, forum space, etc. let me explain:
it doesn't really matter HOW Jesus died, just as long as his blood was spilled.

The only thing that matters is ... Jesus' blood was spilled, and he died.

Several errors here.

1. Jesus(as) did not die

2. The blood of Jesus(as) was never spilled. A Prophet is very much protected from harm

3. You are quoting errors from an erroneous book.

 

[Alpha Dude]

Now that you guys have wasted so much time, energy, forum space, etc. let me explain:
it doesn't really matter HOW Jesus died, just as long as his blood was spilled.

The only thing that matters is ... Jesus' blood was spilled, and he died.

You're wrong. Isa As was not crucified.

Your post is very misplaced. The thread title is 'Do Muslims believe Jesus was not really crucified?' Not: 'tell me what the final decisive conclusion is regarding Jesus' crucifixtion according to Christianity'.

Please at least try to respect that.

Oh and Al Manaar, your posts are nothing but you spreading fasad through your own ignorant musings. What you say flies in the face of 1400 years of valid Islamic scholarship. You seem to have your own little fringe tafseer going on too.

Nobody should take you seriously.

 

[Woodrow]

This thread has gone on for 25 post. The question was answered in the first 2 or 3 replies.

Plain simple answer to the original question.



Most of us Muslims do not believe Jesus(as) was crucified.


That is all that ever needed to be said.

:threadclo: