Do you celebrate it? (Milaad)

  • Thread starter Thread starter ------
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 53
  • Views Views 8K

Do you celebrate Milaad Un Nabi?

  • Total voters
    0
Status
Not open for further replies.
pauper said:
:sl:

Its really Simple , If you believe its Bid3a stay away from it , if you dont Celebrate it .

But dont impose your thoughts on others , cause there is always more than one opinion in islam
Click to expand...
:w:

sorry brother, but I just wanted to ask, are both these opinions correct?
 
piXie said:
:w:

sorry brother, but I just wanted to ask, are both these opinions correct?
Click to expand...

:sl:

sister 3/4 of our religion is our intention right ?

So if we do something with the Niyat , that is for Allah SWT amd his prophet SAWS and for the welfare of the Ummah , then Inshallah Allah SWT will give us the reward for it .

Now that applies to both , both parties have that in mind and in their intention .

How Allah SWT will judge between them is not up to us .
 
I just had the feeling this thread would just cause problems, subhanAllah some don't even feel guilt or shyness about causing problems in public. What'sthe point of such a thread.

Wallahi I don't know if people just like to make this place a hard place to be.
 
:salamext:

I'm not causing problems! FOR HEAVENS SAKE! I ONLY ASKED FOR VOTES, NOT A GAZILLION FATWAS.

Ya Allaah when will people bother to read the first post properly?!?!?!
 
al Amaanah said:
excuse me? do not lecture u? subhan Allah, why should u ask about something which is a bid3a if we celebrate or not? should an innovation be celebrated? and im not editing al haqq.

wont reply here any more, Allah yahdina
7ayaakom Allah

:wasalamex
Click to expand...

Safe don't reply. :thumbs_up And your so called Al Haqq is an opinion of a scholar. Just like there are many other scholars who have opinions.
 
- Brok3n - said:
:salamext:

I'm not causing problems! FOR HEAVENS SAKE! I ONLY ASKED FOR VOTES, NOT A GAZILLION FATWAS.

Ya Allaah when will people bother to read the first post properly?!?!?!
Click to expand...

Wa Alaykum Salam Wa Rahmatullahi Wa barakatu,

I find it hard to think that you wouldnt have thought that the thread would have headed the way it headed, khalas no problem if you feel ok with opening threads like this its your choice, do what you want.
 
:salamext:

Seeing as the moderators, or anyone else for that matter, do not understand the reason for me starting the thread in the first place, just close it...

:threadclo
 
Calm down everyone. Broken sis asked who celebrates it because we know there are people for and against it, so by asking she can see what the majority do. What's the harm, except when people start making mountains out of molehills.
 
I have witnessed the unfairness of the people who celebrate this first hand as i have been in that Jama'ah for over five years. I have even defended the milaad, amongst other things.

Alot of them do not do it for love of the Prophet sallahu alayhi wasallam. To them it's merely another excuse to attempt to takfir anybody who does not celebrate it. This can be seen by the sitting in their gatherings, where i have heard scholars "debunking" the "Wahaaaabi" arguments one by one, the crowd are like noooooreeeee takbiiiiiiiiiiiir - Allllaaaaaaaaaahhhhhuuuu Akkkkkkkbaaaaaar , nooooooreeeee Risaaaaalaaaat - Yaaaaaa Raaaaasuuulllulllllllaaaaaaah, and so forth.

So for most, it's just another day to beat their chest with the claim they are the right group.

However, there are those who sincerly love the Prophet sallah alayhi wasallam from amongst them. The signs of them are that they grow the beard. And i am not talking about the fashion beard, i am talking about the full sunnah. They just do not understand what is going off because their people make every attempt to mislead them.

They want the people to think that Salafis are anthromopists in their creed, that they do not love the Prophet salallahu alayhi wasallam, but in all fairness, i feel that Salafis have been made an unfair target, and it is the people of desire to be liked others that persecute Salafis, because the idea of following the Salaf is not at all fashionable.

I cannot defend Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahhab, but neither can i condemn, but if he is in line with thee Ahlus Sunnah wal Jamaa'ah, which is the people of Sunnah and the majority of agreed upon scholars (not the biggest headcount of Muslims worldwide as some would have us believe), then, he is Ahl us Sunnah, and we can find this out by comparing his doctrine to that of the Salaf.

Only with fairness one will reach truth. If you do not know, do not condemn, seek ....
 
:salamext:

Correction: It's not "noooooreeeee takbiiiiiiiiiiiir", Its Naarahe Takbir. And they are not doing it for fun, its called out of love for Islaam. Sheesh. And then you say people judge.

Anyway mods close this thread, it's getting pathetic.
 
:salamext:


^ The majority of people before thought the earth was flat.
 
Then thats another good point for not following the majority (i.e. modern day interpretation of the Jamaa'ah, the Muslim laity).
 
Muslimah_Sis said:
Calm down everyone. Broken sis asked who celebrates it because we know there are people for and against it, so by asking she can see what the majority do. What's the harm, except when people start making mountains out of molehills.
Click to expand...

The harm is that sometimes you have on your conscience threads like this, to close or not to close, will it promote something that you believe to be sinful, what if it leads others to commit that act, what if it gives a platform for others to promote something which you might feel is wrong.

This is why I feel it is harmful.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top