does this have music in it

[Malaikah]

Does this have music in it? Silly me, I can't tell.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t8dGisCH-HA&eurl=http://muslim-responses.com/

 

['Abd al-Baari]

Salams

Hmm i think it has
Allah knows best

 

[muslim 4 lyf]

i think so but only allah knows

فَتَعَالَى اللَّهُ الْمَلِكُ الْحَقُّ


High Above All Is God The True King

 

[strider]

No, i think it's just product of the human voice.

 

[Malaikah]

^Yeh, that is why I can't tell... but there is something in the background that I think might be a piano??:?

 

['Abd al-Baari]

Salams

I thought that between 0.17mins and 0.26 was a piano or a flute
Allah knows best

 

[England]

Yes it does have music... some wanky arabic music.

 

[strider]

Salams

I thought that between 0.17mins and 0.26 was a piano or a flute
Allah knows best

Sounds like human voice to me.

lol @ England.

 

[Malaikah]

Oh man! It was really nice, why did they have to ruin it! imsad

 

[Pk_#2]

i thought it was their voices and humming etc,

but at point 47 sec ish it sounds like flute

Allahu Alim-Allah knows best

manners bro 'England' tsk

Peace!

 

['Abd al-Baari]

Salams

aren't there any different versrions, without music?

 

[strider]

Oh man! It was really nice, why did they have to ruin it! imsad

Sis, who is the artist of this nasheed?

 

['Abd al-Baari]

Salams

I think its Hamza Mahmood

 

[Malaikah]

I haven't got a clue...

 

[tomtomsmom]

No sister that has no musical instruments in it. The reason it sounds like that is because there are many people singing in harmony that when done well (like this one is) can very much sound like an instrument. I know this because for 6 years in school I was in the chorus. (it is a group of people that sing )
Many times we sand with no music and it was the harmony that made it sound like we were! Hope this helps

 

[Maidah]

It's a shame it's soo beautiful and they had to add music into it. I'd be very happy if it's not music, is it not possible to find out from some expert?

To me it sounds like the piano is in it:-\ .

 

[jzcasejz]

Huhhhh? I'm Pretty Sure That Don't Have Music In It...Like Someone Said...It's All The Product Of Human Voice...

What You Gotta Realise Is That...There's Many Tones That Can Be Made By Humans...Like A Kid Talks High Pitched When He's Young...But When He's Older, He Has The Ability To Smash Windows With His Deep Voice...

So...In That Nasheed The Guys Hummed In A Low Tone For The Background And Stuff...I Am Pretty Sure That It Don't Contain Music.
In Music, You Get Various Instruments And sounds Going Off At Once...And In This Nasheed...You Have Alot Of Voices Going Off At Once...Making It Sound Populated...So Some People Might Confuse It For Music...

and the artist is Muhammad Husayn btw...tracks called Mawlaya Salli...
And Anywayz...If You Want Another Version Of It By Zari Ziyaad Patel..Can Be Found Here (If U Want It):
http://www.zshare.net/audio/qari-ziyaad-patel-and-friends-mawlaya-salli-mp3.html