Doha Debates ft Yasir Qadhi

  • Thread starter Thread starter Al-Hanbali
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 30
  • Views Views 9K
Light of Heaven said:
I'm not sure I said otherwise. I said she was cool too, not I loved her opinion and is the best or I would go with any opinion unislamically. Obviously Islam is meant to govern our every aspect of life. I already know this....
Click to expand...

My intention wasn't to imply that you didn't...sorry if it was confusing; I was just adding some more thoughts of my own.
 
Sheikh Yasir's arguments were clear, factual and logical. The arguments coming from the other side were weak and emotional based on whims and desires. The correct view is quite clear, except to those who don't want to see it.
 
Yasir Qadhi, mashaAllah, what a speaker! Don't think I've ever seen/heard much from him before, just his name, oh and that mac/pc article, lol. I admire how patient he was with Asra, I might have gotten slightlyyy frustrated with her.

Here's his take on the debate, a very interesting read.
 
Last edited:
There's this really brilliant part where I think YQ hit the nail on the dot...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9CHEhZL0OA (watch @ 38:20 mins)...

Asra had nothing to say but, "...your version of the Laws of God..." <-- what nonsense!

May Allaah guide her and guide us all...Ameen!!
 
Uthmān;1167173 said:
It's the role of the moderator to challenge the pannelists, regardless of their position. After all, he did it for the other team as well!
Click to expand...

Yes, but as a moderator you should let people speak. He asks one question, interrupts them before they can finish their answer, and then switches the question up (but essentially asking them the same thing). As a moderator, your role is to be neutral. Personally, I feel like he was siding with one side too much.
 
:sl:

Nah, I don't really think he was unfair. He only might have cut into Sheikh Yasir Qadhi a couple times to make things go a lil faster. When Asra Nomani was trying to ramble, he cut in also, and at one point she looked real foolish after his questioning.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top