His death please God?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Oleander
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 57
  • Views Views 9K
that's not what he's saying. would you kill yourself to save your wife?

He didn't kill himself. He freely gave his life to save others from a life of sin. That's sacrifice not suicide. He had power to lay down his life, and power to take it up again.

does it say in Isaiah 53 "it pleased the Lord to bruise himself?

It says it pleased the Lord to bruise him.

Peace be upon those who follow the guidance,

how could god the son killing himself please god the father?
IF there are both the same, then god the father would have forsaken god the son because Christians claim that god the son said:



Matthew 27:46
About the ninth hour Jesus cried out in a loud voice, "Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani?"—which means, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?"

and here again

Mark 15:34
And at the ninth hour Jesus cried out in a loud voice, "Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani?"—which means, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?"

Well, he didn't forsake him on the cross. To forsake him would mean that he broke fellowship with him, and Jesus said in St. John that the Father has not left him alone, and he still even on the cross asked the Father to 'forgive them because they know not what they do.' So they still had fellowship. Graceseeker mentioned once that Jesus was just fulfilling a Psalm of David, who wrote a good many of Messianic prophecies.

so because god the son and god the father are the same, we could also translate that

"Myself, Myself, why have i forsaken me?"

and out of all this, god [the son] losing faith in god [the father] is the apex of Christian beliefs????

god loses faith in himself as he commits suicide. well, that makes so much sense!

:w:

Well, the Christian understanding of God is that God exists as one God in three persons. You've heard different ways of explaining the Trinity, I'm sure. Mathematically I could say that the Trinity would equate to something like 1x1x1=1
 
Last edited:
Greetings,
Well, he didn't forsake him on the cross. To forsake him would mean that he broke fellowship with him, and Jesus said in St. John that the Father has not left him alone, and he still even on the cross asked the Father to 'forgive them because they know not what they do.' So they still had fellowship.

I'm not sure how you square this with "Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani?"

Did Jesus make a mistake or something?

Peace
 
Greetings,


I'm not sure how you square this with "Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani?"

Did Jesus make a mistake or something?

Peace

Well, Graceseeker can perhaps explain it better than I can, but he was the one who put this forth.
 
Why did a Muslims even start this thread?

According to your Quran GOD caused Jesus to die and was raised him up to himself. Why cause the one perfect sinless man on earth to die for no benefit?

Yes, GOD lovingly sacrificed His WORD incarnate for us.

Is GOD happy that He had to because of our sin- No.


How do you know a 'muslims' started this thread?

This thread is in the 'comparative religion' section, so it doesn't matter who is starting the thread they can ask about other religions

According to OUR Quran where does it say God caused the Prophet Jesus to die? It clearly says the jews did not kill him and he was raised up, he will descend into this world later near the end of time, meaning he is not dead

So please don't talk about things with you don't know about with such certainty

if you have such beliefs about Jesus then why have your way of life as undisclosed, why not have it as christianity
 
Last edited:
It's not suicide to lay down your life to save others. That's called sacrifice. Like, if I lay down my life to protect my wife whose being assaulted, and I show up just in time and whatnot. I die, but she escapes and lives on. Sacrifice is different from suicide. And to answer the question, yes it did please the Father. The Bible says that Christ's death was a sweet smelling savor to God the Father, and Isaiah 53 says that it pleased the Lord to bruise him.
So what you are saying is that you are God too? you have just made an analogy between God and your person-- so God died so the people who 'sacrificed' him can live on?
Why would God love us, if he can't love himself long enough to uphold his own commandments, even if it is just for show to get us to play along?

all the best
 
Why did a Muslims even start this thread?

According to your Quran GOD caused Jesus to die and was raised him up to himself. Why cause the one perfect sinless man on earth to die for no benefit?

Yes, GOD lovingly sacrificed His WORD incarnate for us.

Is GOD happy that He had to because of our sin- No.

A bit of a clarification. The Qur'an does not say Jesus(alaihis salaam) "died" and then was "raised" up. Allah says in the Qur'an that, thats what Christians say, but it never happened. Allah raised him up before it took place.

Allah(swt) mentions in Surah An - Nisa in the following verses:

And because of their saying: We slew the Messiah, Jesus son of Mary, Allah's messenger - they slew him not nor crucified him, but it appeared so unto them; and lo! those who disagree concerning it are in doubt thereof; they have no knowledge thereof save pursuit of a conjecture; they slew him not for certain. (157)

But Allah took him up unto Himself. Allah was ever Mighty, Wise. (158)
 
Last edited:
Well, Graceseeker can perhaps explain it better than I can, but he was the one who put this forth.

Peace be upon those who follow the guidance,

actually, i also raise a question about the quote and i was directing it at you.

if you believe that the whole trinity is the same as 1x1x1=1, then they would all have to be the same one. keeping that in mind,

how do you square:

"Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani?"—which means, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?"

for in order for your equation to be consistent with your beliefs, Jesus IS in effect saying, " Myself, Myself, why have i forsaken me?"!

He had power to lay down his life, and power to take it up again.

IF he was in fact the only creator cherisher and sustainer of the entire world, then ONLY he would have the power to end his life. IF you can kill him, then he is DEFINITELY not God!

And to answer the question, yes it did please the Father. The Bible says that Christ's death was a sweet smelling savor to God the Father, and Isaiah 53 says that it pleased the Lord to bruise him.

again, for your 1x1x1=1 equation [or misdirection] to be true, then we can reinterpret Isaiah 53, "it pleased the Lord to bruise [the Lord]" this implies a god who enjoys feeling pain, especially self inflicted pain. does that make sense to you?

Jesus is quoted in the New Testament as saying that 'Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends,' in St. John.

this is strange, should the quote read: "that a god lay down his life for his friends?" OR is Jesus denying that he is a part of a trinity here?

:w:
 
Greetings,


Isn't that the same with any dogma?

"Just believe! And don't try to understand why!"

Peace

Indeed.. however some beliefs are more illogical than others.
I can believe for instance, Dr. Sampson's theories on retrograde menses causing endometriosisas as very plausible even though they don't explain endometrioma present in the nose or lungs tissues, over say, Dr. John Martin theories on stealth viruses.. as there is usually a painstaking process and criteria that makes unknowable things more approachable by tightening the confidence interval so if there is doubt it can be dispelled, and that is what any belief should do for you, so one doesn't find him/herself in heaping gaps that can't be mended as is the case with Christianity!

all the best
 
Last edited:
It's not suicide to lay down your life to save others. That's called sacrifice. Like, if I lay down my life to protect my wife whose being assaulted, and I show up just in time and whatnot. I die, but she escapes and lives on. Sacrifice is different from suicide. And to answer the question, yes it did please the Father. The Bible says that Christ's death was a sweet smelling savor to God the Father, and Isaiah 53 says that it pleased the Lord to bruise him.

What?? Jesus is the savior of humanity right? Savior from what? The punishment of God.

Why does God have to kill himself to save humanity from his own wrath?? :enough!:
 
My brain starts going mumbo jumbo when I hear this stuff, which is way too confusing. I confuse myself more as I write it myself or say it! :/
 
So what you are saying is that you are God too? you have just made an analogy between God and your person-- so God died so the people who 'sacrificed' him can live on?
Why would God love us, if he can't love himself long enough to uphold his own commandments, even if it is just for show to get us to play along?

What commandments would these be? Are you talking about Jesus upholding the Old Testament? If so, Jesus lived perfectly under the Old Testament, the only one who ever did so. In fact the only thing the Pharisees and religious leaders of the day could level his way was that he was healing on the sabbath days.


Peace be upon those who follow the guidance,

actually, i also raise a question about the quote and i was directing it at you.

if you believe that the whole trinity is the same as 1x1x1=1, then they would all have to be the same one. keeping that in mind,

how do you square:



for in order for your equation to be consistent with your beliefs, Jesus IS in effect saying, " Myself, Myself, why have i forsaken me?"!

That was just an expression of Jesus' humanity. On the cross he took on the entirety of humanity's sin, past, present, and future. So he was feeling the wrath of almighty God while he was on the cross, or the anger of God.



IF he was in fact the only creator cherisher and sustainer of the entire world, then ONLY he would have the power to end his life. IF you can kill him, then he is DEFINITELY not God!

Well, there is a passage in St. John where the Roman soldiers try to apprehend Jesus and they all fall backward. Here:

'Jesus therefore, knowing all things that should come upon him, went forth, and said unto them, Whom seek ye?

They answered him, Jesus of Nazareth. Jesus saith unto them, I am he. And Judas also, which betrayed him, stood with them.

As soon then as the had said unto them, I am he, they went backward, and fell to the ground.

Then asked he them again, Whom seek ye? And they said, Jesus of Nazareth.

Jesus answered, I have told you that I am he: if therefore ye seek me, let these go their way.' St. John 18:

The reason being is because they couldn't forcefully take his life, he had to give it of his own self. There's also a section somewhere in the Gospel's where they try to throw him off a cliff and he just walks past them before they do so. Here:

'And all they in the synagogue, when they heard these things, were filled with wrath,

And rose up, and thrust him out of the city, and led him unto the brow of the hill whereon their city was built, that they might cast him headlong.

But he passing through the midst of them went his way...' Luke 4; 28-30.

We all die because we have sinned and we continue to sin. Death had no authority over Jesus because he didn't sin. Which is also why he rose from the dead, because death could not hold him.




again, for your 1x1x1=1 equation [or misdirection] to be true, then we can reinterpret Isaiah 53, "it pleased the Lord to bruise [the Lord]" this implies a god who enjoys feeling pain, especially self inflicted pain. does that make sense to you?

No, that's not what it implies. The life, death, and resurrection of Jesus is just the fulfillment of the Old Testament. The Old Testament was an imperfect covenant, one in which its adherents (the Jewish people) could not realistically live. If everyone could live perfectly under the old covenant, there would have been no need to send Jesus into the world to redeem us.

And yes, it did please the Lord (God the Father) to bruise the Lord (God the Son). It doesn't mean that he enjoys self inflicted pain, it just means that he is a God of perfect justice and perfect mercy.

this is strange, should the quote read: "that a god lay down his life for his friends?" OR is Jesus denying that he is a part of a trinity here?

No, it doesn't mean that. Jesus was just expressing his humanity, he was relating to them on their level.



What?? Jesus is the savior of humanity right? Savior from what? The punishment of God.

Why does God have to kill himself to save humanity from his own wrath?? :enough!:

As I said, it has to do with God being a God of perfect justice and perfect mercy. Sin carries with it a price, and it has to be paid. God has provided payment through the atoning work of his Son Jesus Christ. Why? So that all men might honor the Son, even as they honor the Father.
 
Last edited:
What commandments would these be? Are you talking about Jesus upholding the Old Testament? If so, Jesus lived perfectly under the Old Testament, the only one who ever did so. In fact the only thing the Pharisees and religious leaders of the day could level his way was that he was healing on the sabbath days.
.
I am talking about thou shalt not kill amongst many others.
I am talking about committing suicide for no good reason.
I am talking about the absurdity and absolute logical contradiction for a man to pray to himself the night before forsaking himself -- I am talking about a man who is pleased to see himself bruised for infantile reasons. And the impossibility of selling the rest of the world that each entity had a separate will and are yet one in the same!

There is really nothing Grace Seeker can do for you, when at the very fulcrum of your tenets is something so severely flawed you couldn't possibly drown it with all the florid language in the universe!

all the best
 
Greetings and peace be with you burdenofbeing;
I understand but my belief is troubled

You are in my prayers, life is a journey always one day at a time, knowing that our God holds us in the palm of his hand.

In the spirit of praying for an inner peace that surpasses all understanding.

Eric
 
Last edited:
I am talking about thou shalt not kill amongst many others.
I am talking about committing suicide for no good reason.
I am talking about the absurdity and absolute logical contradiction for a man to pray to himself the night before forsaking himself -- I am talking about a man who is pleased to see himself bruised for infantile reasons. And the impossibility of selling the rest of the world that each entity had a separate will and are yet one in the same!

There is really nothing Grace Seeker can do for you, when at the very fulcrum of your tenets is something so severely flawed you couldn't possibly drown it with all the florid language in the universe!

all the best


Question dear, if ALL things in life have to be logical, when do you leave room for God to be God and to come through? Where does faith and hope come into play.
 
Question dear, if ALL things in life have to be logical, when do you leave room for God to be God and to come through? Where does faith and hope come into play.

Where in ANY of my posts 'dear' have I used the term 'ALL'? -- other than that I recommend you work on formulating a better question, it is faulty on many levels!

all the best
 
Question dear, if ALL things in life have to be logical, when do you leave room for God to be God and to come through? Where does faith and hope come into play.

:sl:

why would ANYTHING to do with God be illogical? does that mean that Xianity is the most illogical religion you could find?

faith comes in because we can't see Allah, hope comes in because no matter how hard we try, we fall short. we cannot number the blessings that Allah has poured out on us, so we could never really "pay for them." thus we rely on Allah's Mercy. plus we "tie our camel."

:w:
 
Where in ANY of my posts 'dear' have I used the term 'ALL'? -- other than that I recommend you work on formulating a better question, it is faulty on many levels!

all the best

My use of ALL was not to literally said that you spelt it out A-L-L in any of your posts.Its metaphoric! To formulate a better question to you 'dear', haven't you even gone through an experience in life that was beyond your understanding or raised so many questions that you wondered where God was when all that was happening? Sounds like you've had a smooth one.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top