How do Atheists view the Prophets (messengers of Allah)?

[ranma1/2]

u think its just like that?????? OMG!!!!!

First, explain how out of all people Sulaiman (saw) was able to understand animals?
and how Muhammed (saw) was able to split the moon?
and how Yunus (saw) was able to lie in a whale for 40 days without suffering or dying?
and all the other miracles of prophets???:zip:

easy, the same way thor throws down lighting, herucles carried the world on his back and zeus lived forever.

its a story.

or do you have evidence?

 

[Ummu Sufyaan]

we have evidence, problem is you have trouble accepting it :sunny:

 

[ranma1/2]

age: WRONG..i think u just givin ur age... no offence... and NOWAY i dont want to know anything about these fake religions... islam was the FIRST religion...these came like after ppl were even born! but islam, we have an answer for everything..u NO!

test: for non-muslims

1. who is your "god"?
2. Do you have messengers?
3. who gave you what you have today?
4. what direction is your god facing right now?
5. what is your "god" doing right now?
and
6. what came before your religion, and when did your religion start?

speechless ,eh?

islam cleary was not the first religion. It was founded centuries after christanity.
1 none.
2. I use MSN does taht count?
3. well my parents raised me but i live on my own now.
4. N/A
5. N/A
6. N/A
nope.

 

[Qingu]

First, explain how out of all people Sulaiman (saw) was able to understand animals?

Why don't you explain why you believe Suliemon could understand animals. Do you believe in Dr. Doolittle too?

and how Muhammed (saw) was able to split the moon?

Again, why don't you tell me why you believe this. It's physically impossible. And even if it was "God magic" we'd still have records, as I'm sure the hundreds of non-Muslim astrologers would have noticed and frantically recorded their observance of the moon splitting.

and how Yunus (saw) was able to lie in a whale for 40 days without suffering or dying?

Whale? I thought it was a fish.

and all the other miracles of prophets???:zip:

You are assuming these miracles actually happened.

Can you explain how mighty Arjuna was able to split a mountain in half with his bow and arrows?

Can you explain how the monkey-god Hanuman picked up a mountain and threw it across the sea from Indian to Sri Lanka?

Can you explain how Joseph Smith received magical golden tablets from an angel that told him how Jesus appeared to the native Americans?

Because obviously all these miracles really occured—since religious texts say they did.

 

[Ummu Sufyaan]

islam cleary was not the first religion. It was founded centuries after christanity.

where is your proof for this?

 

[wilberhum]

u think its just like that?????? OMG!!!!!

First, explain how out of all people Sulaiman (saw) was able to understand animals? He didn't. It is just a story.
and how Muhammed (saw) was able to split the moon? He didn't. It is just a story.
and how Yunus (saw) was able to lie in a whale for 40 days without suffering or dying? He didn't. It is just a story.
and all the other miracles of prophets???:zip:
There are no prophets olr miracles they are just stories.

I don't believe Ra commanded sky, earth, underworld either.

 

[truemuslim]

we have evidence, problem is you have trouble accepting it :sunny:

thank YOU

easy, the same way thor throws down lighting, herucles carried the world on his back and zeus lived forever.

its a story.

or do you have evidence?

yep its a story..ours...not

Hello, this thread is getting a bit heated and don't know if I'm jumping on someone elses line of thought here. My answers are above in blue, if you really want to know what I think.

Thanks.

1. think??? lol...and also you answered all WRONG!! you guys are bad at answering

May be when you get all grown up, say 12, you may start to understand.

oh and before islam?? never happened...like i have been saying... islam was the first religion... Adam (saw) was the first person on earth, and he believed in allah (swa) and he had kids with the second person on earth, huwwa , and her kids had kids, and so on... but you guys have NO EXPLANATION! and if your thinkin islam came when the quraan came..then you need to see a doctor...then check google...translate the quraan..then come back...hehe...

 

[Qingu]

where is your proof for this?

The lack of any Islamic theology whatsoever in the world before the early 7th century? The Quran's obvious derivation from earlier Christian, Jewish, and Arabian myths?

You do realize that just because a religious text says it's a million years old does not make it so, yes? Or do you believe that Scientology predates all religions because it says so in Dianetics?

 

[truemuslim]

Why don't you explain why you believe Suliemon could understand animals. Do you believe in Dr. Doolittle too?


Again, why don't you tell me why you believe this. It's physically impossible. And even if it was "God magic" we'd still have records, as I'm sure the hundreds of non-Muslim astrologers would have noticed and frantically recorded their observance of the moon splitting.


Whale? I thought it was a fish.


You are assuming these miracles actually happened.

Can you explain how mighty Arjuna was able to split a mountain in half with his bow and arrows?

Can you explain how the monkey-god Hanuman picked up a mountain and threw it across the sea from Indian to Sri Lanka?

Can you explain how Joseph Smith received magical golden tablets from an angel that told him how Jesus appeared to the native Americans?

Because obviously all these miracles really occured—since religious texts say they did.

you know..have you ever heard of ..hmm...legands?? stories??? yep..well if u have...then all u said was one of them that some guy wanted to make true..of course some people are actually dumb enough to believe it..no offence..hehe

 

[wilberhum]

where is your proof for this?

If you clam Islam is the first, the proving is clearly up to you.
Quotes from a book that the vast majority of people reject is not proof.

 

[Qingu]

Do the Muslims on this board realize that non-Muslims do not accept the Quran?

You all seem to be operating under the assumption that if the Quran says something, everyone should believe it's true. Can you rationally defend this assumption? Or do you think repeating your claims over and over again makes them true?

 

[truemuslim]

If you clam Islam is the first, the proving is clearly up to you.
Quotes from a book that the vast majority of people reject is not proof.

here go try this... Go to somewhere and buy a quran..then change the words in it... and copy it and give some to people... or take the quraan, step on it, rip it... I DARE YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! becuase it aint possible...and if you do..and it is possible...then you will have a really severe punishment once u dead.

 

[Qingu]

you know..have you ever heard of ..hmm...legands?? stories??? yep..well if u have...then all u said was one of them that some guy wanted to make true..of course some people are actually dumb enough to believe it..no offence..hehe

Ah.

So let me get this straight.

Guy finds golden tablets from an angel—LEGEND.

Guy rides a flying, woman-faced donkey up into the sky—FACT.

Talking divine monkey battles demons—STORY.

Jews turn into monkeys and are possessed by invisible djinn—TRUTH.

I'm curious as to how you tell the difference.

 

[truemuslim]

The lack of any Islamic theology whatsoever in the world before the early 7th century? The Quran's obvious derivation from earlier Christian, Jewish, and Arabian myths?

You do realize that just because a religious text says it's a million years old does not make it so, yes? Or do you believe that Scientology predates all religions because it says so in Dianetics?

no not really... you dont even know ur god. or anything... DUMB!!! ^^^

 

[truemuslim]

Ah.

So let me get this straight.

Guy finds golden tablets from an angel—LEGEND.

Guy rides a flying, woman-faced donkey up into the sky—FACT.

Talking divine monkey battles demons—STORY.

Jews turn into monkeys and are possessed by invisible djinn—TRUTH. HAHA

I'm curious as to how you tell the difference.

and no all of those are STORIES OF SOME GUY OR GUYS WHO WANT TO BE REMEMBERED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Ummu Sufyaan]

If you clam Islam is the first, the proving is clearly up to you.
Quotes from a book that the vast majority of people reject is not proof.

i can prove and prove all i want, the problem is the fact that you cant accpet it.

 

[ranma1/2]

here go try this... Go to somewhere and buy a quran..then change the words in it... and copy it and give some to people... or take the quraan, step on it, rip it... I DARE YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! becuase it aint possible...and if you do..and it is possible...then you will have a really severe punishment once u dead.

lol, its not possible, except of course when it is.

 

[Qingu]

and no all of those are STORIES OF SOME GUY OR GUYS WHO WANT TO BE REMEMBERED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

You believe al-Buraq and Allah turning Jews into monkeys and djinn are just stories of some guy who wants to be remembered?

 

[truemuslim]

maryam u r soooo write... they are just too stubborn..and ranma1/2 i think u should re read what i JUST SAID!! i said and if it is possible you will get the worste punishment of all..u know no time is left at the end!!!

 

[ranma1/2]

maryam u r soooo write... they are just too stubborn..and ranma1/2 i think u should re read what i JUST SAID!! i said and if it is possible you will get the worste punishment of all..u know no time is left at the end!!!

i did, im still lauging. i dohave a question what if we have a ebook of hte quran and we chagne words or delete it. Is that ok? And which god should i worry more about, the christain and the islamic god both threaten to burn me for every or some similar nastiness. Neither have really cared to let me knowthey exists though. who shoudl i choose andwhy?