Is Arab Nationalisam Haram ?

[Futuwwa]

I suppose the problem here is that there are so many tribes and races that call themselves Jews so it gets very complicated as well as different sects of Judaism. The original name for the Jews came from the city of Judah. Jewish ultra nationalism (as they believe all the Gentiles are born to be their slaves) holds their little Israel together at a very high cost internationally, but I think it is doomed to fail. If they had listened to Jesus (PBUH) maybe their destiny would have been better.

Care to answer the question rather than blabber random scarcely related stuff?

 

[Karl]

Care to answer the question rather than blabber random scarcely related stuff?

No Jewish nationalism is a bad idea as they are scattered throughout the world. Also they are surrounded by Arabs around and within Israel. Jewish nationalist attacks by the press on NAZI Germany resulted in very harsh backlashes. Also Jewish internationalism is also bad. Zionism is a very bad path. Jesus (PBUH) was trying to show them the light and also Muhammad (PBUH) but they refuse it.

 

[Futuwwa]

I wasn't asking whether it was a good idea, but whether it was good, as in, just and moral? Ditto for Arab nationalism.

 

[Karl]

I wasn't asking whether it was a good idea, but whether it was good, as in, just and moral? Ditto for Arab nationalism.

Well that is a difficult one to answer because I have not the divine sight to see the future. Things are not so simple as good or evil they can be taken from different points of view, different cultural norms. I can not truly judge if something is good or evil or ethical only on a shallow human level which is subjective and flawed.
But Jesus (PBUH) said "Love your enemies" to the Jews, which on the face of it sounds crazy. But look at the situation, the Jews were ruled and surrounded by powerful pagan Romans. King Herod was a childhood friend of Claudius and the ruling family of Rome. Jewish ultra nationalists (Zeolots) were iching for a fight to take on "The Beast" Roman Empire. So Jesus advice was good because if the Jews went to war with the Romans they would have been slain in battle and any surviving Jews would have been crucified and left for the vultures and rats.